Burger was cold and hard. Had to throw it out ? ill try the place across the street instead. It can’t be that hard, it wasn’t even busy.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Howard B
Wonderful lunch with friends. The boneless wings with honey stung sauce are the best in town! Service was fast and friendly.
Blake Turner
Come here a lot until now.. service is terrible !! Sub par food this time explains why no one is here on a
Service: 1
Joe Martinez
Friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tater Tots
Lew Thomas
Great place, food was good, great atmosphere, really cool server. Knocked a star off for lack of liquor selection. It was all there but limited selections of each.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew McAllister
Food and service were absolutely phenomenal. Would, and will, go back in a heartbeat. Definitely recommend hitting up Jeremiah's and getting some good food and drink.
Disappointing food and disappearing service.... I had the black and blue burger which was a thin patty on a stale brioche bun, my wife had the steak sandwich on a stale roll as well the kids had chicken fingers (ok) and chicken wings (good!). The server seemed ok but was m.i.a. after taking the order. All in all a truly meh experience
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Cheryl Butter
So I am saddened to have to post a negative review about "what use to be" my to go to wing joint.My husband and I picked up some wings maybe two or three weeks ago.Our wings were fried so hard we could barely eat them; needless to say, we "DID NOT" enjoy them.While I understand Covid has affected the help that restaurants have, I think that occasionally maybe managers need to become tasters every week on their different cooks.Maybe then, they could give constructive criticism, thereby helping cooks to improve!!!!....We took our food out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Adrienne Quintero
I'm not sure how Jeremiah's got such a great reputation for wings. This is the second location we've been to where all the sauce was poured in the bottom of the basket and there didn't seem to be anything on the wings themselves. The rest of the food wA decwnt- basic bar food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Metal Fabcreations
Food was good, took a little long to get the food with hardly any customers in their but would eat there again.
Great food but my dad is now going to puke his guts out for the rest of the night because the French fries were fried in the same oil as the fish and shrimp. But it’s our fault because we didn’t inform our server.. Disappointed I hope y’all practice better food safety in the futureDietary restrictions: BEWARE FISH/SHELLFISH ALLERGIES: Jeremiah’s does not have separate friers for fish/shellfish, went here for dinner and the French fries were cross-contaminated. The fries were cooked in the same oil as the fish and shrimp, not great..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
James Patterson
Went to Jeremiah's for a soccer fundraiser and everything actually went extremely well. Everyone's food was good and as ordered, and the service was great too. And we had a table of 15!
Jeremiah's has a restaurant side and a bar side so there's a great atmosphere for everyone. They have traditional American favorites like burgers, wings, tenders and flatbread pizza. But then also some dishes with a little extra flair with some spicy dishes and some European flavors. Servers are always personable. About $30 for lunch for two without alcohol but with an app..The Meatball Skillet is amazing!Wheelchair accessibility: This Restaurant is pretty accessible with wide doors getting in and out of the building and getting into the bathroom. Steep-ish ramp to get into building but always well kept and not icy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron C
Went on a steady Friday night, and service wasn’t that good. Most everyone enjoyed their food. However, I ordered extra crispy wings and steak fries. Both were extra soggy. I was starving, so just ate them (server was not existent). Our food was dropped off by someone who wasn’t our waitress. We asked for more beers and wine. Our server finally came over when my brother in law was done with his food. He ate his food without a drink. Waitress asked if we wanted refills when he was done, and didn’t really care that he ate food without a beverage.So, basically I don’t know how they have best wings in Rochester. They are big, but soggy when asked for extra crispy. Also, everyone asked if they had sauce on them because they were dry and not wet.If you want wings and a beverage with your meal I would not recommend coming here. If everyone else didn’t enjoy their food I’d have given this place a 1. With inflation everything is super expensive, so it is reasonable to expect food how asked and being able to have a beverage with your dinner.
Terrance Ray Trybus
The food was really good, as well as the service. Thanks for staying open and getting us in late.
Burger was cold and hard. Had to throw it out ? ill try the place across the street instead. It can’t be that hard, it wasn’t even busy.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Wonderful lunch with friends. The boneless wings with honey stung sauce are the best in town! Service was fast and friendly.
Come here a lot until now.. service is terrible !! Sub par food this time explains why no one is here on a
Service: 1
Friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tater Tots
Great place, food was good, great atmosphere, really cool server. Knocked a star off for lack of liquor selection. It was all there but limited selections of each.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food and service were absolutely phenomenal. Would, and will, go back in a heartbeat. Definitely recommend hitting up Jeremiah's and getting some good food and drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Wings, Wing Sauces, Ellie
Disappointing food and disappearing service.... I had the black and blue burger which was a thin patty on a stale brioche bun, my wife had the steak sandwich on a stale roll as well the kids had chicken fingers (ok) and chicken wings (good!). The server seemed ok but was m.i.a. after taking the order. All in all a truly meh experience
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
So I am saddened to have to post a negative review about "what use to be" my to go to wing joint.My husband and I picked up some wings maybe two or three weeks ago.Our wings were fried so hard we could barely eat them; needless to say, we "DID NOT" enjoy them.While I understand Covid has affected the help that restaurants have, I think that occasionally maybe managers need to become tasters every week on their different cooks.Maybe then, they could give constructive criticism, thereby helping cooks to improve!!!!....We took our food out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
I'm not sure how Jeremiah's got such a great reputation for wings. This is the second location we've been to where all the sauce was poured in the bottom of the basket and there didn't seem to be anything on the wings themselves. The rest of the food wA decwnt- basic bar food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Food was good, took a little long to get the food with hardly any customers in their but would eat there again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food but my dad is now going to puke his guts out for the rest of the night because the French fries were fried in the same oil as the fish and shrimp. But it’s our fault because we didn’t inform our server.. Disappointed I hope y’all practice better food safety in the futureDietary restrictions: BEWARE FISH/SHELLFISH ALLERGIES: Jeremiah’s does not have separate friers for fish/shellfish, went here for dinner and the French fries were cross-contaminated. The fries were cooked in the same oil as the fish and shrimp, not great..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Went to Jeremiah's for a soccer fundraiser and everything actually went extremely well. Everyone's food was good and as ordered, and the service was great too. And we had a table of 15!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Wings, Wing Sauces
Jeremiah's has a restaurant side and a bar side so there's a great atmosphere for everyone. They have traditional American favorites like burgers, wings, tenders and flatbread pizza. But then also some dishes with a little extra flair with some spicy dishes and some European flavors. Servers are always personable. About $30 for lunch for two without alcohol but with an app..The Meatball Skillet is amazing!Wheelchair accessibility: This Restaurant is pretty accessible with wide doors getting in and out of the building and getting into the bathroom. Steep-ish ramp to get into building but always well kept and not icy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went on a steady Friday night, and service wasn’t that good. Most everyone enjoyed their food. However, I ordered extra crispy wings and steak fries. Both were extra soggy. I was starving, so just ate them (server was not existent). Our food was dropped off by someone who wasn’t our waitress. We asked for more beers and wine. Our server finally came over when my brother in law was done with his food. He ate his food without a drink. Waitress asked if we wanted refills when he was done, and didn’t really care that he ate food without a beverage.So, basically I don’t know how they have best wings in Rochester. They are big, but soggy when asked for extra crispy. Also, everyone asked if they had sauce on them because they were dry and not wet.If you want wings and a beverage with your meal I would not recommend coming here. If everyone else didn’t enjoy their food I’d have given this place a 1. With inflation everything is super expensive, so it is reasonable to expect food how asked and being able to have a beverage with your dinner.
The food was really good, as well as the service. Thanks for staying open and getting us in late.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4