Aunt Cookies Sub Shop
76 Main St, Geneseo
(585) 243-2650
Customers' Favorites
Salt \u0026 Pepper
Italian Salame
Banana Peppers
Salt & Pepper
Spicy Mustard
Cooked Salami
Black Olives
Italian Sub
Roast Beef
Turkey Sub
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The subs used to be a lot better when they toasted their buns more. That is their whole slogan. And yet when you get your sub it's barely even warm, and when you asked them to toast it twice it's barely browned like it used to be. If they toasted their roles better I would give it a four and a half Stars.
I was back in town this weekend for my 50 year college reunion and it was as good as they were 50 years ago. Family owned for all that time and had a great conversation with the owner Joanne.
The meat, cheese and veggies have always been top notch but their rolls are what truly sets them apart. 😋
The meat, cheese and veggies have always been top notch but their rolls are what truly sets them apart. 😋
After hearing so much about this place, I came in got 2 subs one was a toasted cheese sub other was a turkey not toasted. It was $32 dollars after a $10 dollar tip. The turkey is great quality,but the reviews about how soggy and wet the subs are were not lying. I just didn't care for it being that wet. Gonna stick with my previous place for now.
You May Also Like
Bar-Eat-O - 3 Bank St
![]()
Bar & Grill, Mexican, Gluten-Free, Cocktail Bar
Kelly's Saloon - 71 Main St
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar
Mama Mia's - 87 Main St
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Wraps, Vegan