Lori is a gem! I just ordered over the phone because I wasn't sure what the hours were with their upcoming move, and she made it happen! awesome customer service, and even more awesome cookies! we love finger lakes cookies! you should, too! They taste amazing and the variety and quality are outstanding. place your orders today!
Christina Joslin
We had finger lake cookies for our wedding on 6/26/22 for our dessert bar. Amazing!!! Everyone loved them. We will definitely be using them again. Great service and quick response time.
Elena Hanish Oyer
Such delicious and freshly baked cookies. Love the Lemon Crack cookie!
fawnrunairbnb
Love their cookies! Right on Main Street in Geneseo, close to cute shops and cafes, a nice area to walk.
Heather Kingston
Our family LOVES Finger Lakes Cookie Company cookies! Planning our wedding we knew we wanted Finger Lakes Cookie Company to be apart of our day. A simple meeting with Laurie is it all it took. She met with us, explored all options as well as taste testing and we were set to go! She even gave us the left over tasting cookies to take home ( even better!) Laurie and her staff are Professional, knowledgeable and so very kind. They delivered the cookies the day of our wedding and set up so we didn’t have to worry about anything! Living local to Finger Lakes Cookie Company is a blessing and I highly recommend there cookies for any event big or small. Thank you so much Finger Lakes Cookie Company!
Christine
If you have not had Lori’s cookies then you are really missing something.. they all are the best but my favorite are the peanut butter ones. Yum. Thanks again Lori for all you guys do
Charlotte Zeman
Thank you for providing the sweet treats for my sons’s college graduation last week. I tell everyone that his cake was specially made for him in Geneseo and transported to Syracuse. Thank you again Lori . We love your Cookies and cakes!
Sarah Macauley
We ordered gluten free cookies this weekend for a birthday party, they were wonderful! The texture was perfect, plus they were LOADED with M&M’s and peanut butter! ????
Gail Smith
We visited just before Easter while in the area for the college. Serendipity! The cookies were delicious but also the staff are really special. After eating our cookies (we tried four different kinds and all were delicious), we requested to purchase some Easter Egg cake pops that they were making for pre-orders. They specially made four extras, and then presented them as a gift. The variety and taste of everything was great. I will be sending them out as gifts to friends who need a little pick me up!
Jenna Carrington Frazier
Oh yummm absolutely delicious!! It was our first time in and Laurie was so kind and friendly, salt of the earth kind of person who really brightened our day! Can't wait till the next time, I want to try everything!!
We have been gifted a few delicious treats from here. There was an unfortunate mailing incident with one and the ladies were so sweet when I let them know! Everything we've had from here has been amazing!!
Nikole Dechau
Adorable cookie shop with the most delicious cookies ever! Owner is so helpful and kind. It has become a family favorite and they even ship out of state for those that still crave the amazing treats!
sallyh317
amazing cookies and great present! was sent a box of 6 variety cookies and a mug with coffee for my birthday and i LOVED it!! everything was packaged so nicely and it arrived safely and quickly, cookies were still soft and delicious
Jack Royer
I have never had a better experience, truly the most delicious cookies I have ever had and their service is amazing. Please try them!
Paige L.
Their cookies are amazing! The Max Black cookie tastes just like the wine from Deer Run. The brownie with peanut butter frosting was amazing. The chocolate chip cookies with PB frosting on the inside were soooo good! Can't wait to stop by again soon!
Lori is a gem! I just ordered over the phone because I wasn't sure what the hours were with their upcoming move, and she made it happen! awesome customer service, and even more awesome cookies! we love finger lakes cookies! you should, too! They taste amazing and the variety and quality are outstanding. place your orders today!
We had finger lake cookies for our wedding on 6/26/22 for our dessert bar. Amazing!!! Everyone loved them. We will definitely be using them again. Great service and quick response time.
Such delicious and freshly baked cookies. Love the Lemon Crack cookie!
Love their cookies! Right on Main Street in Geneseo, close to cute shops and cafes, a nice area to walk.
Our family LOVES Finger Lakes Cookie Company cookies! Planning our wedding we knew we wanted Finger Lakes Cookie Company to be apart of our day. A simple meeting with Laurie is it all it took. She met with us, explored all options as well as taste testing and we were set to go! She even gave us the left over tasting cookies to take home ( even better!) Laurie and her staff are Professional, knowledgeable and so very kind. They delivered the cookies the day of our wedding and set up so we didn’t have to worry about anything! Living local to Finger Lakes Cookie Company is a blessing and I highly recommend there cookies for any event big or small. Thank you so much Finger Lakes Cookie Company!
If you have not had Lori’s cookies then you are really missing something.. they all are the best but my favorite are the peanut butter ones. Yum. Thanks again Lori for all you guys do
Thank you for providing the sweet treats for my sons’s college graduation last week. I tell everyone that his cake was specially made for him in Geneseo and transported to Syracuse. Thank you again Lori . We love your Cookies and cakes!
We ordered gluten free cookies this weekend for a birthday party, they were wonderful! The texture was perfect, plus they were LOADED with M&M’s and peanut butter! ????
We visited just before Easter while in the area for the college. Serendipity! The cookies were delicious but also the staff are really special. After eating our cookies (we tried four different kinds and all were delicious), we requested to purchase some Easter Egg cake pops that they were making for pre-orders. They specially made four extras, and then presented them as a gift. The variety and taste of everything was great. I will be sending them out as gifts to friends who need a little pick me up!
Oh yummm absolutely delicious!! It was our first time in and Laurie was so kind and friendly, salt of the earth kind of person who really brightened our day! Can't wait till the next time, I want to try everything!!
Restaurantji Recommends
We have been gifted a few delicious treats from here. There was an unfortunate mailing incident with one and the ladies were so sweet when I let them know! Everything we've had from here has been amazing!!
Adorable cookie shop with the most delicious cookies ever! Owner is so helpful and kind. It has become a family favorite and they even ship out of state for those that still crave the amazing treats!
amazing cookies and great present! was sent a box of 6 variety cookies and a mug with coffee for my birthday and i LOVED it!! everything was packaged so nicely and it arrived safely and quickly, cookies were still soft and delicious
I have never had a better experience, truly the most delicious cookies I have ever had and their service is amazing. Please try them!
Their cookies are amazing! The Max Black cookie tastes just like the wine from Deer Run. The brownie with peanut butter frosting was amazing. The chocolate chip cookies with PB frosting on the inside were soooo good! Can't wait to stop by again soon!