I ordered our usual - Medium combo. Pizza I order was 1/2 pizza with spicy pepperoni on the other 1/2 regular pepperoni, sausage and meat balls. What I got.... 1/2 pizza with just cheese. The other half with spicy pepperoni, regular pepperoni, sausage and meatballs!! When you are spending $40 + dollars on a pizza and wings it would be nice if they got the order right. Pizza Paul's used to be our go to Pizza place but this past year its been hit or miss!! And the misses are beginning to happen more often!! And it's A shame because I really like the owner!!
Half Pint Ranch
One of the best in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allen Givens Jr.
Overpriced. The extra large is a standard large everywhere else, and it was $30 for a standard cheese, and pepperoni. Visually, it looks decent when you open the box. Cheese looked like it was barely melted, or if someone grated a block of great value over the pie. The sauce tastes like it came from a can, and over-seasoned. Too salty. I will say that the crust was good! Do yourself a favor, and order across the street. It looks like a train wreck inside, and smells like the place is about to catch fire, but the pizza is leaps and bounds above whatever I tasted here. One of the better qualities is that the staff was friendly.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Paul
I ordered a personal pizza with anchovies and bell peppers on their site. I didn't realize that I had managed to order twice. Personally I think it was due to vague interface of their website. Anyway, when I came to pick up the pizza (s) they had cooked two pizzas and told me that I had ordered twice. One with bell peppers and one without. I simply accepted the mistake and said okay after hoping they would give me some sort of break but they didn't.
Look it was my fault that I know but having worked in pizza places myself I know they could have called me to make sure of an obvious mistake or told me that they would give me a break since this was the first time. What is that pizza? Two bucks for them? The girl at the counter seemed to be subtly challenging my stupidity. Okay I made a mistake and no breaks. I will not give them a break either. Not going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Andy Patterson
I have always loved Pizza Pauls and I’ve never had any issues in the past but the past several times I’ve ordered from the Geneseo store. I am very disappointed when I specifically ask for the wings to be saucy and have extra sauce and I get them home and find out that there is barely anything on them More grease in the bottom of the container than sauce is a little upsetting. Especially for the price that you pay. Unfortunately, I think at this point I will be taking my business to another establishment.
Food: 1
Charlotte McCormick
The friendliest staff and the best pizza ever! Fresh, fast, and flavorful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isabella Zambito
Pizza was cooked exactly how we asked, wings were delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cliff Aho
Steak sub was horrible, no cheese on it, peppers were raw so was the onions, steak had no flavor, boiled, although the fries were delicious,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
PaulM5505
One of the best pizza places I ever visited (and I’ve been to pizza joints all over NY, New England, the west coast and even the UK). GINORMOUS slices (with generous amount of toppings) for very little money. And absolutely delicious too! Friendly staff and nice atmosphere as well. I have become a semi-regular in the past couple of months.
Whoever made the calzones on 4/23 around 6:30 should NEVER be allowed to make them again. First off the cheese isn’t even melted second of all I think they used a whole bottle of seasoning on top. I scraped half of it off already. This is absurd. It tastes AWFUL. I’ve had amazing calzones here but this is not it. Please reteach this person on how to make them
Cheltsea Scutt
Our pizza was cold and barley any cheese when it got to our house, and then they said they forgot our chicken wings. We waited about 30 mins for them to arrive. They only use door dash now for delivery. Pizza Pauls has gone down hill. Sad we spend $70 for our family to have cold and late pizza and wings
Kathleen McEneany
Best pizza around. Great staff. Always friendly and they go the extra mile.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allen Russell
We love this place. Having an autistic son we are constantly dealing with his picky easting. I decided to choose my battles but consistently offer new foods to try. In the meantime he loves garlic bread with cheese. They've gotten to know us and have even made a large version for him. Also the regular pizza and wings are also great.
Parking: You'll probably find a meter with time left but if not be sure you have a quarter. The meters only take quarters. I'd say roll the dice on parking illegally BUT the town police are literally across the street.
Kid-friendliness: I've had no problems bringing my special needs 8 year old son here.
I ordered our usual - Medium combo. Pizza I order was 1/2 pizza with spicy pepperoni on the other 1/2 regular pepperoni, sausage and meat balls. What I got.... 1/2 pizza with just cheese. The other half with spicy pepperoni, regular pepperoni, sausage and meatballs!! When you are spending $40 + dollars on a pizza and wings it would be nice if they got the order right. Pizza Paul's used to be our go to Pizza place but this past year its been hit or miss!! And the misses are beginning to happen more often!! And it's A shame because I really like the owner!!
One of the best in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Overpriced. The extra large is a standard large everywhere else, and it was $30 for a standard cheese, and pepperoni. Visually, it looks decent when you open the box. Cheese looked like it was barely melted, or if someone grated a block of great value over the pie. The sauce tastes like it came from a can, and over-seasoned. Too salty. I will say that the crust was good! Do yourself a favor, and order across the street. It looks like a train wreck inside, and smells like the place is about to catch fire, but the pizza is leaps and bounds above whatever I tasted here. One of the better qualities is that the staff was friendly.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
I ordered a personal pizza with anchovies and bell peppers on their site. I didn't realize that I had managed to order twice. Personally I think it was due to vague interface of their website. Anyway, when I came to pick up the pizza (s) they had cooked two pizzas and told me that I had ordered twice. One with bell peppers and one without. I simply accepted the mistake and said okay after hoping they would give me some sort of break but they didn't.
Look it was my fault that I know but having worked in pizza places myself I know they could have called me to make sure of an obvious mistake or told me that they would give me a break since this was the first time. What is that pizza? Two bucks for them? The girl at the counter seemed to be subtly challenging my stupidity.
Okay I made a mistake and no breaks. I will not give them a break either. Not going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
I have always loved Pizza Pauls and I’ve never had any issues in the past but the past several times I’ve ordered from the Geneseo store. I am very disappointed when I specifically ask for the wings to be saucy and have extra sauce and I get them home and find out that there is barely anything on them More grease in the bottom of the container than sauce is a little upsetting. Especially for the price that you pay. Unfortunately, I think at this point I will be taking my business to another establishment.
Food: 1
The friendliest staff and the best pizza ever! Fresh, fast, and flavorful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was cooked exactly how we asked, wings were delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steak sub was horrible, no cheese on it, peppers were raw so was the onions, steak had no flavor, boiled, although the fries were delicious,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
One of the best pizza places I ever visited (and I’ve been to pizza joints all over NY, New England, the west coast and even the UK). GINORMOUS slices (with generous amount of toppings) for very little money. And absolutely delicious too! Friendly staff and nice atmosphere as well. I have become a semi-regular in the past couple of months.
Get the double dough
Restaurantji Recommends
Whoever made the calzones on 4/23 around 6:30 should NEVER be allowed to make them again. First off the cheese isn’t even melted second of all I think they used a whole bottle of seasoning on top. I scraped half of it off already. This is absurd. It tastes AWFUL. I’ve had amazing calzones here but this is not it. Please reteach this person on how to make them
Our pizza was cold and barley any cheese when it got to our house, and then they said they forgot our chicken wings. We waited about 30 mins for them to arrive. They only use door dash now for delivery. Pizza Pauls has gone down hill. Sad we spend $70 for our family to have cold and late pizza and wings
Best pizza around. Great staff. Always friendly and they go the extra mile.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love this place. Having an autistic son we are constantly dealing with his picky easting. I decided to choose my battles but consistently offer new foods to try. In the meantime he loves garlic bread with cheese. They've gotten to know us and have even made a large version for him. Also the regular pizza and wings are also great.
Parking: You'll probably find a meter with time left but if not be sure you have a quarter. The meters only take quarters. I'd say roll the dice on parking illegally BUT the town police are literally across the street.
Kid-friendliness: I've had no problems bringing my special needs 8 year old son here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Chicken Wings
Always good food from Pizza Pauls.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...