I got hired here to watch the parlor as a security director. I was stationed in a claustrophobic borderline janitorial closet packed to the brim with high tech security equipment. (FBI/CIA aesthetic) I was hired temporarily only five nights. I was not presented with the fact there happens to be an evil robotic bear with a nice hat staying and entertaining within this establishment. I had signed a contract which required me to return the entire 5 nights. My shifts were 6 hours long from 12am - 6am, not a single amount of coffee, five hour energy, or monster peach mango punch could have prepared my sacred soul for what was about to go down in this haunted chophouse. If ANYBODY is looking for a security job, trust me this is NOT the one. 10/10 would work here again great employers who called to check on the shop once a night, and amazing pay.
Ian S.
Pizza is good ambiance is trash there were little rascals outside the windows punching a dead bird and playing with it using their blind friends walking stick. Service was fantastic!! The employees are very kind and quick with the food. But the dead birds and kids really just set a bad tone for the meal. The food was really really amazing I got a 18 inch pizza with wings and it was delightful!
Rachel Harrington
We had a large order for delivery tonight. The delivery arrived before scheduled time. All the food was hot, fresh and made to order. Everything was delicious. We were very pleased and would highly recommend! ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Wings, Pizza, The Mighty Bulldog Pizza
xiled_blackdragon
Ordered fried dough online came without powdered sugar
Hope Kelley
Great place all around my food is great to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Chicken Wings
Sara Jane
That pizza was, no question, the grossest I’ve ever had. That includes frozen, homemade we tried to make at home, when we were young, etc. it was raw doughy and literally had straight up tomato paste for sauce, couldn’t eat it, my daughter, who I picked up from school, and I, stopped in for slices yesterday afternoon, they’re on the back side of campus, so they’d have a gold mine if they did the one thing they’re in business for, right. The one good thing was the workers were friendly. You guys can’t serve that. Try it, yourselves. I would have rather had a frozen pizza. You need to take a look at what you’re serving. We aren’t picky, this was Unbelievable .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Sherrie Silvis
Yum ! Pizza and wings crust and sauce were amazing! I like thick crispy crust that stands up to the weight of the toppings! And crispy wings that weren't dried out.
LOVE this place! Excellent food, service, and people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
justin koschara
Sadly this place has gone down hill. Wing sauce was really lacking... no Buffalo favor or body at all. And the sheet pizza hardly any pepperoni except for the couple pieces they dumped a pile on. This was a childhood treat that is not the same anymore!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
The_Rock_Painter 1
I was told they don't take phone orders except for Saturday and Sunday. They don't offer their pizza / wing combos on line . I was told over the phone how to do this , which probably took longer than it would than to have just taken my order. I hung up the phone and dialed j and t pizza where they take phone orders !!!!!!! Lost my business
Edward P.
Slice of pizza was warm not hot the pepperoni was not cooked and the dough was soggy and tough
joe dagostino
What happened to the pizza I grew up on?I have consumed 100's of pizza Paul's pizzas since the late 80's. It has been a year or two since I had the chance to stop in. Stopped in today and the pizza was thick and doughy. You guys had the BEST thin crust pizza! Why did you mess with perfection?
I got hired here to watch the parlor as a security director. I was stationed in a claustrophobic borderline janitorial closet packed to the brim with high tech security equipment. (FBI/CIA aesthetic) I was hired temporarily only five nights. I was not presented with the fact there happens to be an evil robotic bear with a nice hat staying and entertaining within this establishment. I had signed a contract which required me to return the entire 5 nights. My shifts were 6 hours long from 12am - 6am, not a single amount of coffee, five hour energy, or monster peach mango punch could have prepared my sacred soul for what was about to go down in this haunted chophouse. If ANYBODY is looking for a security job, trust me this is NOT the one. 10/10 would work here again great employers who called to check on the shop once a night, and amazing pay.
Pizza is good ambiance is trash there were little rascals outside the windows punching a dead bird and playing with it using their blind friends walking stick. Service was fantastic!! The employees are very kind and quick with the food. But the dead birds and kids really just set a bad tone for the meal. The food was really really amazing I got a 18 inch pizza with wings and it was delightful!
We had a large order for delivery tonight. The delivery arrived before scheduled time. All the food was hot, fresh and made to order. Everything was delicious. We were very pleased and would highly recommend! ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Wings, Pizza, The Mighty Bulldog Pizza
Ordered fried dough online came without powdered sugar
Great place all around my food is great to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Chicken Wings
That pizza was, no question, the grossest I’ve ever had. That includes frozen, homemade we tried to make at home, when we were young, etc. it was raw doughy and literally had straight up tomato paste for sauce, couldn’t eat it, my daughter, who I picked up from school, and I, stopped in for slices yesterday afternoon, they’re on the back side of campus, so they’d have a gold mine if they did the one thing they’re in business for, right. The one good thing was the workers were friendly. You guys can’t serve that. Try it, yourselves. I would have rather had a frozen pizza. You need to take a look at what you’re serving. We aren’t picky, this was Unbelievable .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Yum ! Pizza and wings crust and sauce were amazing! I like thick crispy crust that stands up to the weight of the toppings! And crispy wings that weren't dried out.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Chicken Wings
Sheet pizza done to our requests.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Wings, Pepperoni Pizza
Been coming here since 2010 and still the best pizza joint in Geneseo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pizza
Very good. The calzone was huge and really full. Everyone who had pizza in my group said the crust was great. Guy working there was friendly.
Restaurantji Recommends
LOVE this place! Excellent food, service, and people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Sadly this place has gone down hill. Wing sauce was really lacking... no Buffalo favor or body at all. And the sheet pizza hardly any pepperoni except for the couple pieces they dumped a pile on. This was a childhood treat that is not the same anymore!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
I was told they don't take phone orders except for Saturday and Sunday. They don't offer their pizza / wing combos on line . I was told over the phone how to do this , which probably took longer than it would than to have just taken my order. I hung up the phone and dialed j and t pizza where they take phone orders !!!!!!! Lost my business
Slice of pizza was warm not hot the pepperoni was not cooked and the dough was soggy and tough
What happened to the pizza I grew up on?I have consumed 100's of pizza Paul's pizzas since the late 80's. It has been a year or two since I had the chance to stop in. Stopped in today and the pizza was thick and doughy. You guys had the BEST thin crust pizza! Why did you mess with perfection?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5