The restaurant was dirty. Floors needed to be swept, very old dirt and crud under the booths.One bathroom stall was clogged with toilet paper, the other had a dirty diaper on the floor. Haven’t stopped at this Wendy’s in awhile, was very disappointed.
Jim Cornell
We visited on a Thursday early afternoon. We went through the drive-thu. We were 4th in line. 20 mins later, and 1 person giving up and leaving the line up, we our order was taken. The person taking the order, apologize for the long wait and stating they were short staffed. The wait for the food was short. The food was hot and delicious. So much for fast food. I hope management can solve the staffing issue.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
George Foote
Against my better judgment, my wife and I stopped a few days ago. The air conditioning didn't seem to be working and none of the ordering system or cash registers were working either, cars were backed up at the drive thru, we waiting behind a guy that just wanted lemonade for his wife in the car. They made him wait, why could've they just take his money! After about 15 minutes they finally took his money and he went to the beverage machine and no lemonade. My wife did get a frosty, but I left without ordering. This is my last time there, why are other Wendy's locations good and this one never is. It seems like all the fast food places in Geneseo have gone to crap since Covid.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Megan Savage
These customer service guys would not take my order seriously. Asking for glaze on my burger is not a difficult request and shouldn’t have been encountered with hostile attitude regarding the time and effort it would take to glaze it. Unbelievable!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Leven Rex
This Wendy's sucks. The food is always awful, overcooked, undercooked, cold. Idk if I've gotten anything good here. Service always takes forever, your always waiting 20mins parked for them to bring your food out even if you order ahead of time using the app. The people working there are usually respectful and nice, or high lol. It's either management or the franchise dragging this one down but it's awful.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Amelia Saverino
Best place ever, is open til closed. Definitely will go again. 100% satisfied.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cindy Jones
I tried to take my grandsons here for dinner yesterday. There was a sign on the door (at 4:30 pm) that the dining area was closed, because their registers were working..BUT they could take orders at the drive thru. They still would have to take money or credit card to pay for food. We went elsewhere. They just seem like they can't be bothered to clean the dining room, so they only want drive up service. Not impressed!
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Patricia Hellwig
we picked up our meal
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathleen Wilcox
Was as expected
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Karen Filice
The spicy chicken sandwich was ok. I remember when it was really juicy and delicious. Thinner piece this time that was overcooked & dry. The French fries were also mediocre, did not taste fresh. I was looking forward to a treat, will not go here again.
Let me tell you about the culinary coliseum known only as… Geneseo Wendy’s. This isn’t just a fast-food joint — it’s a flavor cathedral, a deep-fried temple of beefy enlightenment, a sanctuary where the Baconator is the high priest and the Frosty is holy water.
I pulled into that drive-thru like a tired traveler crawling into an oasis in the middle of a desert made of sadness and soggy gas station sandwiches. I had one mission: consume joy.
The moment I ordered, the Wendy’s crew activated what I can only describe as military-level sandwich deployment precision. They moved like seasoned burger samurais. I blinked and BOOM — a tray of golden fries hotter than the center of the sun materialized in my hands, next to a Dave’s Double stacked with so much meat, I could hear cows in the distance saluting me.
AND THE SPICY NUGGETS? I bit into one and was instantly transported to a dimension where flavor reigns supreme and calories don’t count. I had a single tear running down my cheek — not from the spice, but from the emotional realization that these nuggets had just rewritten my life’s purpose.
The Geneseo Wendy’s staff? ICONIC. The girl at the window handed me my food with the grace of a Broadway star and the accuracy of a NASA engineer. Someone in the back yelled “Frosty’s up!” like it was a code red situation, and it kind of was. Because if that Frosty had been even five seconds later, I might’ve perished from excitement. I dipped my fries into that sweet chocolate swamp and achieved something close to enlightenment.
At one point, I swear I heard a Gregorian chant coming from the fryer.
In conclusion: Would I drive three hours out of my way just to go to the Geneseo Wendy’s again? Yes. Would I name my firstborn “Junior Bacon Cheeseburger Perkins”? Probably. Would I choose this Wendy’s to cater my wedding? Don’t tempt me.
GENESEO WENDY’S: You don’t just eat here. You ascend.
11/10. Michelin stars? Try Michelin galaxies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Poised Zulu
Cousin Elmer said, this place was good and he was not lying. It is so good it would remind you of your grandma's
Tegan Lawrence
If you're going to close early due to low staffing, you should probably shut off ordering through the app. On one hand I'm not totally shocked either though knowing how bad management operates here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Alynn Trendowski
Breakfast combo was lacking bacon. Cashier happily fixed it !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
bruce pritchett
Nice clean restaurant. I brought about 15 students here after a field trip. Service was friendly quick.
The restaurant was dirty. Floors needed to be swept, very old dirt and crud under the booths.One bathroom stall was clogged with toilet paper, the other had a dirty diaper on the floor. Haven’t stopped at this Wendy’s in awhile, was very disappointed.
We visited on a Thursday early afternoon. We went through the drive-thu. We were 4th in line. 20 mins later, and 1 person giving up and leaving the line up, we our order was taken. The person taking the order, apologize for the long wait and stating they were short staffed. The wait for the food was short. The food was hot and delicious. So much for fast food.
I hope management can solve the staffing issue.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Against my better judgment, my wife and I stopped a few days ago. The air conditioning didn't seem to be working and none of the ordering system or cash registers were working either, cars were backed up at the drive thru, we waiting behind a guy that just wanted lemonade for his wife in the car. They made him wait, why could've they just take his money! After about 15 minutes they finally took his money and he went to the beverage machine and no lemonade. My wife did get a frosty, but I left without ordering. This is my last time there, why are other Wendy's locations good and this one never is. It seems like all the fast food places in Geneseo have gone to crap since Covid.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
These customer service guys would not take my order seriously. Asking for glaze on my burger is not a difficult request and shouldn’t have been encountered with hostile attitude regarding the time and effort it would take to glaze it. Unbelievable!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This Wendy's sucks. The food is always awful, overcooked, undercooked, cold. Idk if I've gotten anything good here. Service always takes forever, your always waiting 20mins parked for them to bring your food out even if you order ahead of time using the app. The people working there are usually respectful and nice, or high lol. It's either management or the franchise dragging this one down but it's awful.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best place ever, is open til closed. Definitely will go again. 100% satisfied.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I tried to take my grandsons here for dinner yesterday. There was a sign on the door (at 4:30 pm) that the dining area was closed, because their registers were working..BUT they could take orders at the drive thru.
They still would have to take money or credit card to pay for food. We went elsewhere. They just seem like they can't be bothered to clean the dining room, so they only want drive up service. Not impressed!
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
we picked up our meal
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was as expected
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
The spicy chicken sandwich was ok. I remember when it was really juicy and delicious. Thinner piece this time that was overcooked & dry. The French fries were also mediocre, did not taste fresh. I was looking forward to a treat, will not go here again.
Food: 3
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Let me tell you about the culinary coliseum known only as… Geneseo Wendy’s. This isn’t just a fast-food joint — it’s a flavor cathedral, a deep-fried temple of beefy enlightenment, a sanctuary where the Baconator is the high priest and the Frosty is holy water.
I pulled into that drive-thru like a tired traveler crawling into an oasis in the middle of a desert made of sadness and soggy gas station sandwiches. I had one mission: consume joy.
The moment I ordered, the Wendy’s crew activated what I can only describe as military-level sandwich deployment precision. They moved like seasoned burger samurais. I blinked and BOOM — a tray of golden fries hotter than the center of the sun materialized in my hands, next to a Dave’s Double stacked with so much meat, I could hear cows in the distance saluting me.
AND THE SPICY NUGGETS?
I bit into one and was instantly transported to a dimension where flavor reigns supreme and calories don’t count. I had a single tear running down my cheek — not from the spice, but from the emotional realization that these nuggets had just rewritten my life’s purpose.
The Geneseo Wendy’s staff? ICONIC.
The girl at the window handed me my food with the grace of a Broadway star and the accuracy of a NASA engineer. Someone in the back yelled “Frosty’s up!” like it was a code red situation, and it kind of was. Because if that Frosty had been even five seconds later, I might’ve perished from excitement. I dipped my fries into that sweet chocolate swamp and achieved something close to enlightenment.
At one point, I swear I heard a Gregorian chant coming from the fryer.
In conclusion:
Would I drive three hours out of my way just to go to the Geneseo Wendy’s again? Yes.
Would I name my firstborn “Junior Bacon Cheeseburger Perkins”? Probably.
Would I choose this Wendy’s to cater my wedding? Don’t tempt me.
GENESEO WENDY’S: You don’t just eat here. You ascend.
11/10. Michelin stars? Try Michelin galaxies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cousin Elmer said, this place was good and he was not lying. It is so good it would remind you of your grandma's
If you're going to close early due to low staffing, you should probably shut off ordering through the app. On one hand I'm not totally shocked either though knowing how bad management operates here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Breakfast combo was lacking bacon. Cashier happily fixed it !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Nice clean restaurant. I brought about 15 students here after a field trip. Service was friendly quick.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...