Best thin crust pizza you can get outside of New York City. generous size and inexpensive. Single slice for lunch or snack is huge. They have some seats but it’s really for takeout or delivery. Locally owned and not part of the chain that serves our area. Owners are great people, deeply involved in the community. They are always busy so call ahead.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stefan Baer
Went there around 6pm February 23, 2024. I got a couple of slices and let me tell you this is some of the best Brooklyn style pizza I’ve had in a long time. They even had a deal. You can even buy a small tub of blue cheese to dip the end of your crust in if you like. Yes I can definitely see why Geneva residents love this place so much. I will definitely be back ??
Mike Austin
Good food big xl
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, York Style Pizza
Michael Pane
Best pizza in Geneva, NY hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pizza
Amberly Stryker
I love there pizza but there service absolutely sucks just called to order dinner and they keep reading off my previous orders like are you serious I didn't ask what I ordered before and he constantly tryed convincing me to get the Xtra large pizza a two orders of wings all I wanted to know was the cheapest pizza and wing combo i dont need all that food thanks but no thanks im taking my business else where
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Lisa Smith
A great little place to get pizza or salad. Prices are pretty good too. Very friendly staff! We ate inside. Nice atmosphere. Will definitely go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled or Crispy Chicken
Andrea McKinney
Extremely disappointing! Place was filthy, sketchy unfriendly atmosphere, pizza was the greasiest I've ever had and they microwaved their slices.! Gross, couldn't eat it. ZERO
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Phinox legacy
Sweet and tangy wings fried hard ?❤️?
Thomas DiGiuseppe
What a fantastic slice of pizza. I grew up in NY but moved away a long time ago…Cams pizza brings me right back to the days of having a slice of cheese pizza and a soda. Simple yet delicious.
Cam's Pizzeria is a Super place to get a slice or two for lunch. The pizza is NOT over baked. My wife and I bought a slice of cheese pizza and their garlic, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza. These pieces were So Very Good. We will return for more.Parking: Free parking is available on several streets. You can't beat this deal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza Slice
Jeffrey Driscoll
I have gladly spent thousands of dollars at this place from the time I was able to earn my own money. I have had family send me this pizza when I was overseas and across the country. So many of my happy childhood moments were while sharing cam's pizza from this specific location with family. I have to get a few pizzas every time I'm back in town. I'm super lucky that my sons get to experience the same pizza that I grew up with.Thanks for the awesome pizza and awesome memories!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
tatteed
Tried calling, IG and no answer to constant busy signal; also, no option for online ordering in Geneva. Oh, whatever will I do? There are no other pizza places in Geneva, NY.
Service: 1
Dave M.
I would of have given 1 star for how the service has been the past year, but their pizza is my favorite pizza to eat. About a year ago i had an issue with them not making garlic pizza. But this last issue has me never wanting to spend another dollar in this establishment ever again. I grab a slice usually every week, per my usual I stepped in to grab a slice that I was yearning for. A guy taking my order which I didnt recognize says oh "we have a 5 dollar minimum for cards". I explained I never had this issue ever before. He says lemme see what I can do, he goes and grabs someone else. This guy comes over and says, yeah we can't do that for you. This just amazes me that they made such a big deal about this. I understand why they implemented this, but the way they should of dealt with this is they should have said, we can do this for you this one time but have to have a 5 dollar minimum in the future. This is the best way to handle the situation. Not only you get a sale but you maintain a customer. Now you lost a customer and will continue to get bad reviews from me.
Joshua B.
The food is really good; it is a normal small town pizza joint. I never have any problems ordering from here food-wise. The pizza is always good and they don't cheat you with their wings. From a flavor perspective, Cams in Geneva is top notch. It's everything else that has knocked them down to a 3 star rating. Where they lose two stars for me is that when you call and order, they always seem to be out of whatever you're looking for. The last time I ordered, I picked three appetizers before picking something actually in stock. I'm not sure if they sell out or if they don't update their menu but from an ordering standpoint, that is frustrating. It's also inconvenient that they seem to be the online Cams that doesn't have online ordering yet. While they are far the only restaurant without digital ordering (though that list is shrinking in 2023..), I have lived in areas that also have cams and you can always order online so you don't need to give your card over the phone. This also becomes challenging with their refunds: they "can't" give them. When we last ordered they forgot a portion of our order and couldn't refund it. They could only add it as a credit if we choose to eat there again. In a world and industry driven by ease of customer service, there seems to be a big breakdown in technology at this location. But please do know if you do get your food, it will be delicious, I will maintain the quality of food here is worth it.
Great place for New York style pizza. Very good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Best thin crust pizza you can get outside of New York City. generous size and inexpensive. Single slice for lunch or snack is huge. They have some seats but it’s really for takeout or delivery. Locally owned and not part of the chain that serves our area. Owners are great people, deeply involved in the community. They are always busy so call ahead.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went there around 6pm February 23, 2024. I got a couple of slices and let me tell you this is some of the best Brooklyn style pizza I’ve had in a long time. They even had a deal. You can even buy a small tub of blue cheese to dip the end of your crust in if you like. Yes I can definitely see why Geneva residents love this place so much. I will definitely be back ??
Good food big xl
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, York Style Pizza
Best pizza in Geneva, NY hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pizza
I love there pizza but there service absolutely sucks just called to order dinner and they keep reading off my previous orders like are you serious I didn't ask what I ordered before and he constantly tryed convincing me to get the Xtra large pizza a two orders of wings all I wanted to know was the cheapest pizza and wing combo i dont need all that food thanks but no thanks im taking my business else where
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
A great little place to get pizza or salad. Prices are pretty good too. Very friendly staff! We ate inside. Nice atmosphere. Will definitely go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled or Crispy Chicken
Extremely disappointing! Place was filthy, sketchy unfriendly atmosphere, pizza was the greasiest I've ever had and they microwaved their slices.! Gross, couldn't eat it. ZERO
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sweet and tangy wings fried hard ?❤️?
What a fantastic slice of pizza. I grew up in NY but moved away a long time ago…Cams pizza brings me right back to the days of having a slice of cheese pizza and a soda. Simple yet delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Cam's Pizzeria is a Super place to get a slice or two for lunch. The pizza is NOT over baked. My wife and I bought a slice of cheese pizza and their garlic, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza. These pieces were So Very Good. We will return for more.Parking: Free parking is available on several streets. You can't beat this deal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza Slice
I have gladly spent thousands of dollars at this place from the time I was able to earn my own money. I have had family send me this pizza when I was overseas and across the country. So many of my happy childhood moments were while sharing cam's pizza from this specific location with family. I have to get a few pizzas every time I'm back in town. I'm super lucky that my sons get to experience the same pizza that I grew up with.Thanks for the awesome pizza and awesome memories!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried calling, IG and no answer to constant busy signal; also, no option for online ordering in Geneva. Oh, whatever will I do? There are no other pizza places in Geneva, NY.
Service: 1
I would of have given 1 star for how the service has been the past year, but their pizza is my favorite pizza to eat. About a year ago i had an issue with them not making garlic pizza. But this last issue has me never wanting to spend another dollar in this establishment ever again. I grab a slice usually every week, per my usual I stepped in to grab a slice that I was yearning for. A guy taking my order which I didnt recognize says oh "we have a 5 dollar minimum for cards". I explained I never had this issue ever before. He says lemme see what I can do, he goes and grabs someone else. This guy comes over and says, yeah we can't do that for you. This just amazes me that they made such a big deal about this. I understand why they implemented this, but the way they should of dealt with this is they should have said, we can do this for you this one time but have to have a 5 dollar minimum in the future. This is the best way to handle the situation. Not only you get a sale but you maintain a customer. Now you lost a customer and will continue to get bad reviews from me.
The food is really good; it is a normal small town pizza joint. I never have any problems ordering from here food-wise. The pizza is always good and they don't cheat you with their wings. From a flavor perspective, Cams in Geneva is top notch. It's everything else that has knocked them down to a 3 star rating. Where they lose two stars for me is that when you call and order, they always seem to be out of whatever you're looking for. The last time I ordered, I picked three appetizers before picking something actually in stock. I'm not sure if they sell out or if they don't update their menu but from an ordering standpoint, that is frustrating. It's also inconvenient that they seem to be the online Cams that doesn't have online ordering yet. While they are far the only restaurant without digital ordering (though that list is shrinking in 2023..), I have lived in areas that also have cams and you can always order online so you don't need to give your card over the phone. This also becomes challenging with their refunds: they "can't" give them. When we last ordered they forgot a portion of our order and couldn't refund it. They could only add it as a credit if we choose to eat there again. In a world and industry driven by ease of customer service, there seems to be a big breakdown in technology at this location. But please do know if you do get your food, it will be delicious, I will maintain the quality of food here is worth it.