Captain's Cafe

368 Exchange St, Geneva
(315) 759-6045

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Hope Brown

This place feels like home. The service is amazing and the food is even better! Highly recommend the breakfast!

Sue Green

Attentive service, happy clientele. Hearty portion size.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew Phillips

We had a great breakfast here, we tried some flavor combinations we don't see very often and the shredded corned beef omelet was fantastic! Blueberry pumpkin pancakes were rich and sweet, and the homemade maple whipped cream waffles were full of lovely warming spices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Serretti

Spent three days on Seneca Lake and ate breakfast here all three days. The food is amazing and the staff is super friendly. We are now spoiled and ruined for another breakfasts out. Yes it was that good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Max S

Great food & great service

Juniper Hampy

The homemade shredded brisket was amazing! Delicious coffee and a friendly server. What could be any better to get the day started?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Betsy Russell-Orr

Excellent service, great menu and delicious food! Our new favorite!

Victoria Bayle

Delicious breakfast, great portions, fresh ingredients- it wasn't our first choice in the area, but we didn't want to wait 45+ minutes for other options. We were seated and provided drinks quickly, great meal selection, and simple, yet delicious food. Only 2 servers working and maybe one other busser/helper.
Hot coffee, hot food, clean restroom = a great way to start my Sunday.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Leslie Barr

Never eat at this restaurant. We were told to sit anywhere we pleased. Then our food order was taken. We were asked to move to another table to accommodate another party. Then 90 minutes later we were told our food order was swept under other orders. As we watched people get served food that came in after us. Service was horrible can't even rate it really. OH!! FYI We are African American, so not sure if this was the reasoning behind such Terrible service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Megan Veglia

My husband and I stopped in here on our way to a wedding. This is the cutest little family run cafe. The food was incredible. My husband got a wrap and said “this is the best wrap I’ve ever had” (and he is a VERY tough critic). They chatted with me, heard that I was pregnant, and gave my husband a “new dad” coffee mug. We plan on stopping back here on our way back to the airport!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacob Deal

When visiting downtown Geneva, stopping by here will not disappoint. Delicious food, wonderful atmosphere, and amazing service! Stopped by the other breakfast spots nearby and had to go back here before leaving. 10/10 would visit again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

iMarco

If I could give more than five stars, I absolutely would. This café is everything you want in a local spot — warm, welcoming, and full of heart. From the moment you walk in, the staff greet you like an old friend. There’s a genuine kindness and attentiveness here that you just don’t find everywhere. You can tell they truly care about their guests and take pride in what they do.

Our waitress, J, truly made the experience even better. She was incredibly attentive, pleasant, and thoughtful throughout our visit. She checked in on us just the right amount, made great recommendations, and had such a positive, welcoming attitude that it instantly brightened the whole meal. You can tell she genuinely enjoys what she does and cares about her customers.

The food? Incredible. Every dish tastes like it was made with love — fresh, flavorful, and comforting, just like a home-cooked meal. Whether it’s breakfast, lunch, or just a coffee break, everything comes out perfectly prepared and beautifully presented. You can feel the attention to detail in every bite.

The atmosphere is another reason this place stands out. It’s cozy, relaxed, and full of positive energy — the kind of spot where you instantly feel comfortable enough to stay awhile. Whether you’re here to catch up with friends, get some work done, or just enjoy a quiet moment to yourself, it fits every mood.

This café has become one of my absolute favorites. Between the incredible food, the welcoming staff, and the homey vibe, it’s the kind of place you find yourself coming back to again and again. Highly, highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Krysten Zavistoski

Best breakfast in downtown geneva. The pumpkin waffle was delicious. All staff and the owner were wonderful. Service was quick. The coffee is great. We tried water street and grounded but made sure to get back to captains because of the food, staff and atmosphere. Definitely recommend for a delicious breakfast with a cup of coffee or cappuccino.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

bill Glitch

We went for breakfast. There was no wait. The staff was friendly. My wife had the low cal fritatta and I have the breakfast garbage plate. Both were delicious and filling. The prices are pretty good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Malory Matje

Nice place and excellent service but disappointing breakfast.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Loading...