I ordered a turkey sub tonight for the first time. I was hesitant because I hate shredded lettuce. Well, it was delicious. One of the best I've ever had ! I highly recommend this place. The pizza is delish as well and u can actually buy a few wings if u only prefer several. How great, huh ? Thx!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ed
PAY ATTENTION- I will say this for everyone in the back! For good NY pizza, the sauce is NOT supposed to be sweet! I recently moved to the area and there is nothing around (beside one of the Duffs) that have regular pizza sauce. This place is the closest to a regular NY pizza taste. The "sweet sauce" thing they have going on in the area blows my mind(step away from the sugar). I would say this pizza is pretty good, however there needs to be a better balance of cheese to sauce ratio. Either slightly less on cheese, or more on the sauce. I will continue to order from this spot to have a regular cheese pizza, which is apparently hard to come by. [Side note, if you leave a review- leave a solution] <-read that again. Rant over.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Neal Ginsberg
I've been there twice now. Food has been good and very good service. I hope it does better than its predecessors.
They’ve done a nice job making the place look nicer than it’s predecessor. I’d imagine it would be hard not to be compared however.
My friends supreme sub looked fantastic and he said it was great. My other friend said his sub was OK, but that the slice of pizza he had was fantastic. I was craving a chicken finger sub for a few weeks and I’ve noticed a lot of places are putting less chicken fingers on there subs, but that was not the case with bullseye. But I’m ahead of myself. Rewinding back to being at the counter, the way the specials were listed was confusing. The person ordering before me also seemed confused, so I’m not alone. He was charged wrong, it seems and argued that the board indicated it should be cheaper. Same happened to me. The impression I got was that a half sub & fries was $7 (which is a really good deal considering prices these days). It also appeared to indicate a whole sub was $7 (which didn’t make sense to me). It also says lunch specials come with a drink. So I saw a half chicken finger sub was $8. I didn’t want to argue and I wasn’t thirsty so I just said “I’ll just take a half sub, nothing else”. My total was over $10 and she handed me a cup. I said “is this mine?” She said “yes.” Confused, I went and got myself a drink and sat down. I figured “maybe she rang me up for the lunch special anyway.” I got half a sub delivered to my table but no fries. So…no lunch special? No matter. My friend handed me the take out menu which made way more sense. Don’t think the lady at the counter was confident, however.
Anyway, the half chicken finger sub was more than enough and had two good fingers on it. It definitely was more hearty than most places have been lately. However the fingers tasted either overcooked or they were cooked in grease that was not very fresh (I used to work at a pizza shop). So the taste of the fingers was not great and later I did not feel well, at all.
I will stop back sometime soon though, as their supreme steak sub looked delicious, as did their pizza.
Also not sure what is up with their website, but it doesn’t seem to be working for placing online orders.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Anesha Kalicharan
They are new in the area so we thought we would give it a try since my daughter came from LA and was having friends over. Stick to who u know! Bread sticks were just a thin pizza base that was rock hard. Noone ate it. The pizzas had NO taste. I offered everyone salt and pepper flakes which everyone jumped at but was to polite to say anything prior. It had NO TASTE! Never again!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Joe Berner
My wife and I discovered this restaurant today and are so glad that we tried it for lunch. Everything we ordered was excellent including the delicious pizza, the salad, and the wings. For a pizzeria, their menu is extensive. Besides pizza and wings, they have subs, fries, cajun fries, tacos, a wide variety of salads to choose from, and much more. They even offer a fish fry dinner if you're not in the mood for pizza. The service is great, the workers are more than friendly, and the prices are very reasonable. Whenever we happen to be in their area we will definitely be stopping in again. Bullseye Pizza nails the target!
Mandy
The food is good, the prices are reasonable, and the staff is so friendly.
Bullseye Pizza stands out for its exceptional convenience, delectable food, and outstanding service. The location is easily accessible, making it a perfect choice for both dine-in and takeout. The menu offers a variety of delicious pizzas, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The service is consistently excellent, with Amy being particularly notable for her friendly demeanor and excellent customer service skills. Her attentiveness and warmth significantly enhance the dining experience. Overall, Bullseye Pizza is a top choice for anyone seeking great food and impeccable service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Christopher Mekker
The best pizza in Getzville!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
E Mattioli
No pizza at lunch time. No air conditioning, no ice. Apathetic staff.
Ordered a cheese pizza and cheese and pepperoni. About an average Buffalo pizza. Not as good as Besta in that location was. Too saucy, too cheesey (for a non-extra cheese pie), not baked enough (no crispness or body to bottom crust).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
William Priester, Jr.
Got a couple C&P slices for lunch, lowest price you'll see for decent fresh-made typical Buffalo-style pizza.
I ordered a turkey sub tonight for the first time. I was hesitant because I hate shredded lettuce. Well, it was delicious. One of the best I've ever had ! I highly recommend this place. The pizza is delish as well and u can actually buy a few wings if u only prefer several. How great, huh ? Thx!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
PAY ATTENTION- I will say this for everyone in the back! For good NY pizza, the sauce is NOT supposed to be sweet! I recently moved to the area and there is nothing around (beside one of the Duffs) that have regular pizza sauce. This place is the closest to a regular NY pizza taste. The "sweet sauce" thing they have going on in the area blows my mind(step away from the sugar). I would say this pizza is pretty good, however there needs to be a better balance of cheese to sauce ratio. Either slightly less on cheese, or more on the sauce. I will continue to order from this spot to have a regular cheese pizza, which is apparently hard to come by. [Side note, if you leave a review- leave a solution] <-read that again. Rant over.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
I've been there twice now. Food has been good and very good service. I hope it does better than its predecessors.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Supreme Sub, Wings
They’ve done a nice job making the place look nicer than it’s predecessor. I’d imagine it would be hard not to be compared however.
My friends supreme sub looked fantastic and he said it was great. My other friend said his sub was OK, but that the slice of pizza he had was fantastic. I was craving a chicken finger sub for a few weeks and I’ve noticed a lot of places are putting less chicken fingers on there subs, but that was not the case with bullseye. But I’m ahead of myself. Rewinding back to being at the counter, the way the specials were listed was confusing. The person ordering before me also seemed confused, so I’m not alone. He was charged wrong, it seems and argued that the board indicated it should be cheaper. Same happened to me. The impression I got was that a half sub & fries was $7 (which is a really good deal considering prices these days). It also appeared to indicate a whole sub was $7 (which didn’t make sense to me). It also says lunch specials come with a drink. So I saw a half chicken finger sub was $8. I didn’t want to argue and I wasn’t thirsty so I just said “I’ll just take a half sub, nothing else”. My total was over $10 and she handed me a cup. I said “is this mine?” She said “yes.” Confused, I went and got myself a drink and sat down. I figured “maybe she rang me up for the lunch special anyway.” I got half a sub delivered to my table but no fries. So…no lunch special? No matter. My friend handed me the take out menu which made way more sense. Don’t think the lady at the counter was confident, however.
Anyway, the half chicken finger sub was more than enough and had two good fingers on it. It definitely was more hearty than most places have been lately. However the fingers tasted either overcooked or they were cooked in grease that was not very fresh (I used to work at a pizza shop). So the taste of the fingers was not great and later I did not feel well, at all.
I will stop back sometime soon though, as their supreme steak sub looked delicious, as did their pizza.
Also not sure what is up with their website, but it doesn’t seem to be working for placing online orders.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
They are new in the area so we thought we would give it a try since my daughter came from LA and was having friends over. Stick to who u know! Bread sticks were just a thin pizza base that was rock hard. Noone ate it. The pizzas had NO taste. I offered everyone salt and pepper flakes which everyone jumped at but was to polite to say anything prior. It had NO TASTE! Never again!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
My wife and I discovered this restaurant today and are so glad that we tried it for lunch. Everything we ordered was excellent including the delicious pizza, the salad, and the wings. For a pizzeria, their menu is extensive. Besides pizza and wings, they have subs, fries, cajun fries, tacos, a wide variety of salads to choose from, and much more. They even offer a fish fry dinner if you're not in the mood for pizza. The service is great, the workers are more than friendly, and the prices are very reasonable. Whenever we happen to be in their area we will definitely be stopping in again. Bullseye Pizza nails the target!
The food is good, the prices are reasonable, and the staff is so friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Wings, Chicken Fingers
Bullseye Pizza stands out for its exceptional convenience, delectable food, and outstanding service. The location is easily accessible, making it a perfect choice for both dine-in and takeout. The menu offers a variety of delicious pizzas, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The service is consistently excellent, with Amy being particularly notable for her friendly demeanor and excellent customer service skills. Her attentiveness and warmth significantly enhance the dining experience. Overall, Bullseye Pizza is a top choice for anyone seeking great food and impeccable service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The best pizza in Getzville!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
No pizza at lunch time. No air conditioning, no ice. Apathetic staff.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great owner! Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a cheese pizza and cheese and pepperoni. About an average Buffalo pizza. Not as good as Besta in that location was. Too saucy, too cheesey (for a non-extra cheese pie), not baked enough (no crispness or body to bottom crust).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Got a couple C&P slices for lunch, lowest price you'll see for decent fresh-made typical Buffalo-style pizza.
This place rules
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Waste of money…garbage
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...