Nina's Custard
2577 Millersport Hwy, Getzville
(716) 636-0345
Customers' Favorites
Vanilla Custard with Sprinkles
Large Size Hot Fudge
Hamburger and Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Grasshopper Sundae
Chicken Sandwich
Twist Softserve
Chicken Fingers
Ice Cream Cone
Caramel Sundae
Dogs
Hot Dog
Footlong Dog
Texas Cheese Foot Long
Texas Dog
Cheese Dog
Texas Footlong
Texas Cheese Dog
Cheese Footlong
Kosher Dog
Burgers
Cheeseburger
Garden Burger
1\2 Lb Cheeseburger
Jalapeno Burger
1\2 Lb Mama's Burger
Mamas Burger
1\2 Lb Texas Burger
Hamburger 1/2LB
Chili Burger
1\2 Lb Chili Burger
Hamburger
1\2 Lb Jalapeno Burger
Chicken Burger
Texas Burger
Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Salad Sand.
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Italian Sausage
Chicken Finger Sand.
Panini - Veggie
Panini - Cheese
Panini - Tuna
Fish Sandwich
Roast Beef
Panini - Chicken
Panini - Meat
Tuna Sandwich
Kids
Kids Cheeseburger
Kids Chicken Fingers
Kids Grilled Cheese
Kids Hot Dog
Kids Hamburger
Sides
Macaroni & Cheese
Tuna macaroni Salad
Soup - Bowl
Side Cheese
Side Dressing
Garlic Toast
Peppers And Onions
Soup - Quart
Potato Chips
Apple Sauce (Side)
Roll
Gluten free roll
Extra Piece Chicken
texas sauce
double extra peppers and onions
extra lettuce
extra tomato
Fryer
Straight Fries
Onion Rings
Criss Cut Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried Dough
Chicken Fingers - 3
Chicken Fingers - 7
Pizza Logs
Sweet Potato Fries
Novelty
Pint - Custard
Quart - Custard
Pint - Dole
Quart - Lemon Ice
Ice Cream Sandwich
Waffle Chocolate Dipped Cone
Pint - Lemon Ice
Turtle Bar
Cookie
Quart - Dole
Waffle Plain Cone
Nina Bar
Waffle Choc Nuts Or Sprinkles
Quart - Fat Free, No Sugar
Pint - Fat Free No Sugar
Ice Cream Sandwich - 6 Pack
Brownie
Extra Cone
Combo Meals
Burger Combo
Hot Dog Combo
Chicken Finger Combo
Fish Sandwich Combo
Chicken Sandwich Combo
1/2 Panini Combo
1/2 Panini and Soup
Regular
Shake - Regular
Shake - Regular - Malted
Float - Regular
Soda - Ice Cream - Regular
Soda - Regular
Cup Water
Apple Juice
Milk
Milk - Chocolate
Large
Shake - Large
Shake - Large - Malted
Float - Large
Soda - Ice Cream - Large
Soda - Large
Baby
Shake - Baby
Milk - Chocolate
Milk
Bottle Water
Bottled Beverages
20 oz Bottles
Bottle Water
Frappucino
rasp ice tea
Hot Drinks
Hot Chocolate
Coffee
Coffee - Decaf
Cappuccino
Tea - Hot
Salad
Mama Rose's Salad
Romaine, mixed greens and iceburg lettuce with chopped egg, swiss cheese and homemade dressing
GreekSalad
House Salad
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Ice Cream Modifiers
Cookie Dough
Sprinkles - Rainbow
Peanut Butter Cup
Sprinkles - Chocolate
Sundae Sauce
Wow Cow
M&M's
Vanilla/Flavored Yogurt
Pecans
Chocolate Chips
Oreo's
Peanut Butter
Gummy Bears
Whipped Cream
Kit Kat
Cherry
Bananas
Marshmallow
Snickers
Reese's
Dip - Cherry
Almonds
Heath Bar
Dip - Chocolate
Pineapple
Strawberry
Blueberry
Raspberry
Brownie
Peanut Butter Cup
Chopped Nuts
Spanish Nuts
Photos
+35 photos
+34 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
With all the times I have gone to Nina's with family and friends they never disappointed. It is so sad to see the place that was my go-to ice cream place after concerts or games. I have made so many memories here. There food and ice cream always hit different. I wish you the best of luck in your retirement. You have made so many people happy over the years so, thank you so much. ❤️
December 2024
Best brownie sundae in Western New York! They make sure the brownies are warm and gooey, every time. Another favorite is the chicken salad with waffle fries, very flavorful and crunchy respectively.
December 2024
My mom just moved right around the corner and we came in to try the ice cream hoping we found our new "spot" and we definitely did!! The service was wonderful, there were three people and they were all super friendly and patient, answered a few of our questions and made some recommendations. There was four of us and we got four different things, pineapple custard, caramel apple Sundae ,Reese's Sundae and a turtle Great prices, great sizes (we all got kids sizes...
October 2024
You May Also Like
Burger King - 2515 Millersport Hwy
![]()
Burgers, Fast Food
John & Mary's Millersport - 2363 Millersport Hwy
![]()
American, Fast Food
CHINESE COOKERY - 2355 Millersport Hwy
![]()
Chinese, Soup, Seafood, Vegan, Vegetarian