Love the vibe of the place. Very fast service and the slice of white pizza was great size and delicious.
Johanna Falber
Excellent food. The sauce is phenomenal. Their Cesar salad is made with a home made dressing on the side - yes! Their meatballs are delish. Service is friendly, fast. They’re very customer service oriented. Went there today w my son and the young lady behind the counter is adorable and accommodating. I told her I wanted the Disney villians poster hanging up by the rest rooms and she laughed and said she would be sure to tell the owner. She never said, ok crazy lady. 😂 EXCELLENTall the time, NEVER had a bad experience or even a flaw, even when I Door Dash.
Lyz Heldewig
Amazing pizza with interesting toppings! The wraps and sandwiches from here are delicious as well!
Ca
Pizza was soft but fine until I found a hair baked under the cheese.
Bob1513
Just like all the other pizza around the area, nice people and service but just not very good food. I’m starting to think that maybe I don’t actually like pizza? Can’t find anything good around here. Tomatoes on chicken bacon ranch pizza? 😂
Jason Zambrzycki
I've had a couple of really good slices from here while waiting for car work across the street. Ordered a whole pie today for the first time and it was atrocious. Poorly spun dough, pale white throughout as if it was barely baked, swamped in sauce/cheese. Hopefully this was a one-off, even additional time in my oven at home couldn't save it.
Richard Fulton
Every time I pass this place, I need to stop in.
This restaurant is UNDERRATED! Affordable & Amazing Gourmet Food, and Pizza Pies. Great Drink Selection. Top Tier ingredients. This place has a nice 90s classic-modern family atmosphere. The desserts are great, too. I recommend the Chocolate Mousse or Tiramasu!
Oswaldo and Panda are amazing people. Thank you for having me.
stb NY444
Very good pizza. I’m from out of town so not sure compare to other in the area but compared to my area in Corning ny it was very very good pizza. Got the regular plain pie and tomato pie. Both awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
david gonzalez
Parking: This place is Awesome great atmosphere. And let's not forget the food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
William
Pizza quality has declined in the past few months seems theres a lack of pride in their product
So unfortunate I do not like giving bad reviews but when the cost of food is astronomical it’s important to get quality food we purchased two slices of pizza today and it was horrible soggy crust crazy amount of cheese it was un edible .. very disappointing
Food: 2
Al Stout
I really do love Goshen Pizza. The tomato pie there is best in the county and get one every so often. However today I ran into two problems. I called in for a small tomato pie like I have many times in the past. I then received a return phone call and I was asked if I wanted a bruschetta pizza. I said no and repeated I wanted a tomato pie. When I arrived I told person behind the counter I ordered a small tomato pie. This man told me he had a small cheese pizza for me and not a tomato pie. He tried telling me the difference and I said I know the difference but I asked for a tomato pie. While he offered to make a tomato pie for me I didn’t want to wait 20 minutes for it. I’ve had their regular cheese pizza and it is typically good also. When I got home with the pizza, it was clearly undercooked. No crisp at all. This never happened before. Looking at review pictures before writing this each pizza clearly has a crisp, well done crust. Is this place under new management/ownership? Again, I truly love this place and have gotten food catered from here and recommend the place. I hope this experience I had today is a one off experience. I know this place can do better
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
jessica brown
Well let's get the Name clear first. It's Goshen pizza "Tomato Pie" AND It is out of this world CRAZY DELICIOUS. I mean I have never in my life went to a pizza place that serves you food that tastes like you're at a 5 star restaurant. The foods that good!!! ALL OF IT. Everything is SOO FRESH AND YOU CAN IMMEDIATELY TELL THEY LIVE FOR COOKING!! I have 4 different pizza places where I live and I literally will travel the 30 minutes to come here instead. Go here, you won't be disappointed 👏
Love the vibe of the place. Very fast service and the slice of white pizza was great size and delicious.
Excellent food. The sauce is phenomenal. Their Cesar salad is made with a home made dressing on the side - yes! Their meatballs are delish. Service is friendly, fast. They’re very customer service oriented. Went there today w my son and the young lady behind the counter is adorable and accommodating. I told her I wanted the Disney villians poster hanging up by the rest rooms and she laughed and said she would be sure to tell the owner. She never said, ok crazy lady. 😂 EXCELLENTall the time, NEVER had a bad experience or even a flaw, even when I Door Dash.
Amazing pizza with interesting toppings! The wraps and sandwiches from here are delicious as well!
Pizza was soft but fine until I found a hair baked under the cheese.
Just like all the other pizza around the area, nice people and service but just not very good food. I’m starting to think that maybe I don’t actually like pizza? Can’t find anything good around here. Tomatoes on chicken bacon ranch pizza? 😂
I've had a couple of really good slices from here while waiting for car work across the street. Ordered a whole pie today for the first time and it was atrocious. Poorly spun dough, pale white throughout as if it was barely baked, swamped in sauce/cheese. Hopefully this was a one-off, even additional time in my oven at home couldn't save it.
Every time I pass this place, I need to stop in.
This restaurant is UNDERRATED! Affordable & Amazing Gourmet Food, and Pizza Pies. Great Drink Selection. Top Tier ingredients. This place has a nice 90s classic-modern family atmosphere. The desserts are great, too. I recommend the Chocolate Mousse or Tiramasu!
Oswaldo and Panda are amazing people. Thank you for having me.
Very good pizza. I’m from out of town so not sure compare to other in the area but compared to my area in Corning ny it was very very good pizza. Got the regular plain pie and tomato pie. Both awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Parking: This place is Awesome great atmosphere. And let's not forget the food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Pizza quality has declined in the past few months seems theres a lack of pride in their product
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza ever shout-out to panda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So unfortunate I do not like giving bad reviews but when the cost of food is astronomical it’s important to get quality food we purchased two slices of pizza today and it was horrible soggy crust crazy amount of cheese it was un edible .. very disappointing
Food: 2
I really do love Goshen Pizza. The tomato pie there is best in the county and get one every so often. However today I ran into two problems. I called in for a small tomato pie like I have many times in the past. I then received a return phone call and I was asked if I wanted a bruschetta pizza. I said no and repeated I wanted a tomato pie. When I arrived I told person behind the counter I ordered a small tomato pie. This man told me he had a small cheese pizza for me and not a tomato pie. He tried telling me the difference and I said I know the difference but I asked for a tomato pie. While he offered to make a tomato pie for me I didn’t want to wait 20 minutes for it. I’ve had their regular cheese pizza and it is typically good also. When I got home with the pizza, it was clearly undercooked. No crisp at all. This never happened before. Looking at review pictures before writing this each pizza clearly has a crisp, well done crust. Is this place under new management/ownership? Again, I truly love this place and have gotten food catered from here and recommend the place. I hope this experience I had today is a one off experience. I know this place can do better
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Well let's get the Name clear first. It's Goshen pizza "Tomato Pie" AND It is out of this world CRAZY DELICIOUS. I mean I have never in my life went to a pizza place that serves you food that tastes like you're at a 5 star restaurant. The foods that good!!! ALL OF IT. Everything is SOO FRESH AND YOU CAN IMMEDIATELY TELL THEY LIVE FOR COOKING!! I have 4 different pizza places where I live and I literally will travel the 30 minutes to come here instead. Go here, you won't be disappointed 👏
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Greek Salad, Chicken Wings, Pie, Wings, Margherita, Sauce, Buffalo Wings, Slice of Pizza, Pizza Slice, Goshen Salad, Neapolitan Pizza, Garlic Knots
After a delicious slice of pizza, I had the best view ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie, Wings
Loading...