Service was great. Our table wasn't the best. We sat at the one with the couch and the guys were not comfortable. They had to sit way up to the the table to eat. You couldn't move the table closer to them. Fo not recommend sitting there. The food was very good.
Christine Alicia Marie Serach
I had a wonderful 50th Bridgerton-themed birthday party, and The Atrium was the perfect venue for the occasion. The Atrium Room was absolutely lovely — filled with natural light, even on a cloudy day. The dinner was delicious, and the outdoor patio seating added a charming touch. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making the evening flow smoothly. I couldn’t have asked for a better setting locally to celebrate such a special milestone!
Gianna Maria Guterl
We hosted our baby shower at the Stagecoach Inn and couldn’t have been happier with the experience! The staff was incredibly attentive and supportive from start to finish. They made sure we did as little as possible and truly allowed us to just enjoy the day. The food was absolutely incredible, and the venue itself is stunning. Beautifully kept and immaculate in every detail. We are so grateful for the amazing service and warm atmosphere. We will absolutely be coming back for future events!
Lisa
The oysters on the half shell were exceptional last night. Very fresh and plenty of oceanic liquor. The new drink cocktail menu was exciting and diverse. The steaks were very good! A perfect medium rare. Friendly and attentive staff as always.
Jon
Really great night out with the family. Great dinner while on vacation. Food was out of this world. Kids loved their meals too.
Joanne
Always delicious meal, attentive servers, beautiful cozy atmosphere. We look forward to our next meal at Stagecoach Inn.
Janna
Very pleasant and relaxing evening. Food was very well prepared, service unobtrusive and efficient. A very good experience.
Clennie Halcomb
Food was great. Service a little slow. Home of the two oz martini.
Joseph Delaney
Came here for my wife’s birthday dinner and unfortunately left more frustrated than full.
The table was wobbly from the start. No one fixed it despite the servers fighting to stabilize it while pouring water, so I had to fold my napkin to level it out myself midway through our dinner. Water was served warm—not room temp, warm. The ice from my soda melted immediately, which was just gross.
I ordered the short rib tacos as an appetizer and immediately regretted it. There was a massive glob of what I thought was cheese on top—turned out to be straight-up mayo. Not chipotle mayo, not remoulade (which the waitress told me after the fact)—just a mayonnaise mess that completely killed my appetite. None of that was listed in the menu description.
We noted in the reservation that it was a birthday dinner. Nothing was acknowledged—not even a “happy birthday.”
The one highlight: my wife said her pork chop was very good. But for the price point, “one good dish” isn’t enough to justify coming back. This was my second visit—the first time, I came with a group and was underwhelmed. Gave it another shot and walked away feeling the same. Not worth
Mary Beth Scalici
Celebrated our Anniversary and had a wonderful, relaxing overnight ❤️🍾🥂
Our servers could not have been better. The food was wonderful. The place is so pretty and lovely. All around great evening. We will definitely be retuning!
Marc
Everything was excellent from the moment we walked in the door until we left. The ambiance was great! The service was 5 star & the food was absolutely delicious!! We will certainly come back every time we are in Goshen!! One of the BEST restaurants we have ever been too
Amy
We dined at the Stagecoach for our anniversary. The staff made us feel like royalty! The food was amazing! We would recommend this place to anyone celebrating their special day!
Rosalia Riello-Viana
Wonderful overnight stay, clean, comfortable, excellent service. The dinner was OUTSTANDING. Wow so delicious and every bite made with love and care. Liddy our server was top notch. The continental breakfast was fantastic too!
Service was great. Our table wasn't the best. We sat at the one with the couch and the guys were not comfortable. They had to sit way up to the the table to eat. You couldn't move the table closer to them. Fo not recommend sitting there. The food was very good.
I had a wonderful 50th Bridgerton-themed birthday party, and The Atrium was the perfect venue for the occasion. The Atrium Room was absolutely lovely — filled with natural light, even on a cloudy day. The dinner was delicious, and the outdoor patio seating added a charming touch. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making the evening flow smoothly. I couldn’t have asked for a better setting locally to celebrate such a special milestone!
We hosted our baby shower at the Stagecoach Inn and couldn’t have been happier with the experience! The staff was incredibly attentive and supportive from start to finish. They made sure we did as little as possible and truly allowed us to just enjoy the day. The food was absolutely incredible, and the venue itself is stunning. Beautifully kept and immaculate in every detail. We are so grateful for the amazing service and warm atmosphere. We will absolutely be coming back for future events!
The oysters on the half shell were exceptional last night. Very fresh and plenty of oceanic liquor. The new drink cocktail menu was exciting and diverse. The steaks were very good! A perfect medium rare. Friendly and attentive staff as always.
Really great night out with the family. Great dinner while on vacation. Food was out of this world. Kids loved their meals too.
Always delicious meal, attentive servers, beautiful cozy atmosphere. We look forward to our next meal at Stagecoach Inn.
Very pleasant and relaxing evening. Food was very well prepared, service unobtrusive and efficient. A very good experience.
Food was great. Service a little slow. Home of the two oz martini.
Came here for my wife’s birthday dinner and unfortunately left more frustrated than full.
The table was wobbly from the start. No one fixed it despite the servers fighting to stabilize it while pouring water, so I had to fold my napkin to level it out myself midway through our dinner. Water was served warm—not room temp, warm. The ice from my soda melted immediately, which was just gross.
I ordered the short rib tacos as an appetizer and immediately regretted it. There was a massive glob of what I thought was cheese on top—turned out to be straight-up mayo. Not chipotle mayo, not remoulade (which the waitress told me after the fact)—just a mayonnaise mess that completely killed my appetite. None of that was listed in the menu description.
We noted in the reservation that it was a birthday dinner. Nothing was acknowledged—not even a “happy birthday.”
The one highlight: my wife said her pork chop was very good. But for the price point, “one good dish” isn’t enough to justify coming back. This was my second visit—the first time, I came with a group and was underwhelmed. Gave it another shot and walked away feeling the same. Not worth
Celebrated our Anniversary and had a wonderful, relaxing overnight ❤️🍾🥂
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious food and gorgeous atmosphere.
Our servers could not have been better. The food was wonderful. The place is so pretty and lovely. All around great evening. We will definitely be retuning!
Everything was excellent from the moment we walked in the door until we left. The ambiance was great! The service was 5 star & the food was absolutely delicious!! We will certainly come back every time we are in Goshen!! One of the BEST restaurants we have ever been too
We dined at the Stagecoach for our anniversary. The staff made us feel like royalty! The food was amazing! We would recommend this place to anyone celebrating their special day!
Wonderful overnight stay, clean, comfortable, excellent service. The dinner was OUTSTANDING. Wow so delicious and every bite made with love and care. Liddy our server was top notch. The continental breakfast was fantastic too!
Loading...