New Hall Diner

4856 NY-14A, Hall
(585) 526-2075

Recent Reviews

SnowyandSniggles

We go to the dinner a few times a month. It never disappoints. Even short staffed, there is always a smile and the best service possible. But we really come for the food. There are so many delicious items it is hard to choose: the best pancake you’ll ever eat, the grits chorizo bowl is savory and spicy, and the French toast bake sumptuously yummy. And if all else fails, a hangry man will do the trick! Thanks to Tam for the consistently best breakfast in the FL!

Michele Lambert Bates

Excellent food. Friendly atmosphere. Attentive staff. Highly recommend

Patricia Wurstner

Small, but one of the best diners in the Finger Lakes. Often crowded, but well worth the wait. They have an eclectic menu with a large daily special board. Their food is always good, the staff is exceptional.

Kelly Rose

Locally sourced products. Excellent food, excellent service. Unique dishes. Classic dishes. Small and quaint. Friendly staff!

Mike Smith

Great food - most of it locally sourced. Friendly staff. Don't expect a quick bite. Slow down, enjoy the company and the food.

NICOLE NILES

Just had a delicious grass fed burger and house chips for lunch. They support several local farms and businesses like rise and shine bread, bostrom farms, bedient farms etc. Everything is fresh like their homemade jams and baked goods. Aside from home fries you can order a root vegetable version or even parsnip fries instead of French fries. So many options you won't be disappointed. The rustic vintage decor really brings back the nostalgia. The staff and owner are very friendly. Highly recommend giving them a try if you're in the area.

Mary Elizabeth

This place is something reminiscent to Luke's of Gilmore Girls. It is a small charming place with fantastic food that is homemade and worth the wait!! The two ladies that were running it when we were there know all of the regulars and everyone seems like family. I love the names of the breakfast items and the specials!! Hands down the BEST home fries I have ever had!!

clint simmons

This place is amazing! A new favorite definitely! It is small and out of the way, but if you enjoy exploring, wandering, and finding hidden gems, then for sure wander out to Hall, ny. The diner is quaint, clean and cozy. The wait staff is warm, friendly and attentive. We felt welcomed immediately. I had scrambled eggs, pancakes and bacon. Food was delicious and servings hearty. Bacon was crisp--exactly as i had asked for! And there was a continual flow of good coffee. Go. Go this weekend. Ill see you there.

Adam Geibel

5 stars isn't enough, the food, atmosphere, employees, EVERYTHING was perfect for a sunday breakfast. Highly highly recommend!

Jim Stenzel

Breakfast sandwich was very good. Good quality products. The bread is amazing. Fast service

D T

Such a delicious experience! The food was wonderful, the portions were sizeable, and the hosts were so welcoming. The restaurant offers gluten free toast and home made items such as hot sauce and jam! Such a little homey gem!

Kelly Rose-Hixon

I'd give this place 10 stars if possible. Unique down home cooking with customer service that goes above and beyond. Innovative and classic dishes give this hidden gem superiority.

Kim Miller

What a phenomenal find. Small local diner diner with phenomenal breakfast menu. We can’t wait to go back the next time we are in the area.

Katherine Granado

The loveliest scramble and house made strawberry jam?! Staff were incredibly kind, welcoming environment and the best cup of coffee

David Wurman

Awesome breakfast. Great food, and terrific service.

Load More