HAMBURG John & Mary's

40 Buffalo St, Hamburg
(716) 648-4750

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Care

Why on earth would you put soggy salad and chicken in a paper container that ended up soggy and falling apart in my salads? Any other time salads come in a plastic container. The chicken was disgusting, covered in a ton of spices. I order 2 times a week from this place but not anymore.

Food: 1

Rebecca Geercken

What happened to this place? $15.00 for a horrible steak sub... This place really went downhill in quality. Horrible service from miserable employees not to mention the woman on the grill has no clue how to cook steak. It's just gross. . Never again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

severin ryan

just wanted a slice, the ones in the rotator were clearly from when they opened. asked if they could possibly make a new pizza, got absolutely disrespected by the woman working. decided to still try the pizza, when i got it it was awful. so dry and burnt. the pepperoni was charcoal. and yet, the middle of the pizza had soggy dough. i couldn't chew through the crust it was so hard. had a hard time snapping it with my hands.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jim Salhany

Delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew Wawrzyniec

Staff was very pleasant. Subs were excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Oneil

Lots to choose from and good prices

Jon Klaybor

One of the great sub places left! Reasonable prices.

ZZZED

One Star - Avoid at All Costs

My recent visit to John and Mary's was nothing short of a disaster. We waited over an hour for our food, and when it finally arrived, it was clear that the kitchen staff had completely phoned it in. My dish was bland and undercooked, while my companion's meal was overcooked and dry. The service was inattentive, and the overall atmosphere was depressing. Save yourself the time and money – there are far better dining options in town.

Fin

Best food place ever it’s amazing and I love it and it’s amazing and I love it

Michael Lowe

Wish it were closer to home.

Ron Jenna

I love it here! The employees are great especially the manager Shauna! She is amazing and always treats me very very well. All the stars! Ignore the others go to John & Mary's! Tell Shauna I said hi!

Alan Krinickas

In town for work from Eastern Tennessee.Ordered a small supreme for delivery. I'm in the middle of the greatest pizza I've ever had. Service was friendly and fast. I'd recommend this place to anyone! Keep up the good work y'all !

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nycki R

It's a casual family restaurant serving buffalo style pizza, wings, subs, burgers, wraps, salads, tacos, fried foods, milkshakes, etc. You seat yourself indoors or outdoors, it has an indoor window where you order and another window where you pick up your food and you fill your own fountain drinks which my son loves. He also loves the traditional ice cream display case where you choose which flavor(s) you want, then you get to watch the employee scoop them it up and plop it into your cone or dish. Good food, decent prices, quick and friendly service, optional outdoor seating, very clean & well kept. It's been a family and wallet friendly, quick service staple in the heart of the Village of Hamburg, for as long as I can remember (1990ish) but probably much longer.

Parking: Parking lot free & is located on both sides and in the back of the building. There is also free street parking in front & a huge free parking to the left & rear of the restaurants lot that is shared by multiple businesses. The short route to this lot has stairs so it's not wheelchair accessible, the longer route to this lot does not have stairs and is wheelchair accessible

Kid-friendliness: They have a kids menu with a decent amount of options & reasonable prices. My son loves the traditional ice cream display case where you choose which flavor(s) you want, then you get to watch the employee scoop them it up and plop it into your cone or dish and the fill your own fountain drink dispenser where he can try out different flavor combinations. He calls his favorite combo Logan-stary-onade

Wheelchair accessibility: It's located on the ground floor with an outdoor parking lot that is level with the doors.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Craneman 17

Friendly staff...quick service and delicious food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Sj Camp

I just got takeout but the food was excellent. And when we picked it up, they were pleasant and helpful.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ham Sub, Wings, Pizza, Chicken Finger Sub

Loading...