Mr Pot Pie

141 Buffalo St, Hamburg
(716) 202-1717

Recent Reviews

Dark Knight

Great food wonderful friendly service shepards pie is excellent not crazy about shepards pie have mushrooms in it I still buy it again to

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MIke Lembke

Excellent breads. Pot pies are very good . Soups are very good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood Pot Pie, Chicken Pot Pie, Chicken Broccoli and Cheddar Pot Pie

Robin East

Very courteous employees. Can’t wait to eat my Chicken Pot Pie!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Donna Bielecki

Live these pot pies. We love them all.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie, Shortbread Cookies, Chicken Broccoli and Cheddar Pot Pie

Kate C

Picked up a pot pie and pierogies today. The cheese pierogies are DELICIOUS and sold at a great price (11.50 for 6- yes, I promise that’s a good price) AND they were buy 3 get one free. Everyone is always so friendly and my daughters got a free cookie today! Pot pies are handmade and frozen, always delicious.

TheBigtood

Pies are okay but very expensive.

J K

Four stars is based on the fudge, I had three kinds... praline, chocolate walnut, and strawberry. All of them were great. The pierogies I got which were potato/ cheddar, and sauerkraut/mushroom, were ok. Thin dough, kinda bland, the potato cheddar filling was also lacking in flavor. The sauerkraut filling was flavorful. I much prefer pott's deli pierogies. Texture was decent.

Jennifer Frysz

The soups here never disappoint, nor the pierogi or almond roll or cheese danish. You must absolutely go there. You will not be disappointed. At least try the soups!!!

995evr

Perfect for seniors with lots of time on their hands to just wait for the oven to do its work. Put them in and in an hour you have a good meal for 3. Their wraps, cookies, loaf breads, and almond rings are good too. Soups so so depending on what the flavor of the day is. Chil and seafood chowder my favorites soups...

Zach b

I love pot pie, and these pot pies are especially good. They have a huge variety of items to choose from and its all great.

Buffalo Chicken

All I got was a loaf of French bread(a wonderful thing!!!). I had a Chicken pot pie over the winter which was also very nice!

Greg Krause

Great pot pies. I've tried most of them and never disappointed.

Rainer Hoeglmeier

The almond ring is amazing you won't regret it

Matt Pierson

I was introduced to this establishment not that long ago and have only had their classic chicken pot pie but it was delicious and I'll definitely be having it again soon.

James Cunningham

The 2 ladies that work there were very nice and helpful and I can't wait to get another pie or any of their baked goods.

Load More