Magro's (VJ's) Restaurant

169 Utica St, Hamilton
(315) 824-0303

Recent Reviews

Jill McAllister

Always great food and better service! Can not wait until you open back up! We eat there 2-3 times a week!!

Daimon Lambert

great place, excellent food, and service. Hope to be able to return to try more of their dishes.

Denise Smith

The food was very good. We had a large group of hockey players and parents. The room downstairs was perfect, the service was awesome. Great place for us all to hang out between games. Thank you

Bill Gunthorpe

Very good food and service.

Barbara Bixby

Staff was friendly but the food was lacking. I had the fish dinner which included the salad bar..I chose the coleslaw which was quite warm and limp... unfortunately I could not eat it. The fish was overcooked and dry.. disappointing. Also ordered a slice of pepperoni and garlic pizza with hot wings. Waitress said no garlic available but cook would put garlic on a slice. Came back with a slice of cheese and another covered with raw garlic!! Wings were ok overlooking several pieces with the quills still in place! Roomy restaurant, but needs a good makeover!!

Mark Reed

I went there for lunch, great burger, good service

Denise Lodor Morris

Great service & food! Can’t rave enough about their Italian dishes & pizzas, the best around! Their Rueben is also a favorite!

Jenna L.

I would give 5 stars but I have to try other things from the menu first. So basically my mom is the hardest person to impress with food. The last 5 times we went out to eat she was NOT IMPRESSED WHAT SO EVER. We came here for a late dinner and she was impressed with pretty much everything we ate. She got a turkey dinner with mashed potatoes and vegetables. Said the mashed potatoes were "homemade" but commented "who puts garlic on their vegetables?!" And didn't eat those lol . I had a simple soup and salad combo. They give you the option to go up once to the salad bar or have unlimited (small price difference). I didn't want to overeat so I got a bowl of their homemade potato soup and a one- stop salad bar (and piled the hell out of my plate) was like $12.50. The salad was wicked fresh and the salad bar includes a few types of pastas, macaroni salad, lots of fresh veggies and fresh bread and butter. The soup was absolutely bomb. I would honestly go back just for the Soup. It was creamy and delicious. I also ordered a Slice of pizza. They make it New York style, very thin and crunchy- delicious! Probably one of the best slices I've had in upstate New York in awhile. This place is def a hidden gem in the middle of small-town Hamilton. They have a very good menu but it's Heavy on Italian food. Also specials everyday. I would 100% go back, probably the best option for dinner in the immediate area if you don't want to drive to cuse or new Hartford.

Cheryl Brown

Food was okay today. Server was less than adequate.

Juni Cohen

10/10 go back. Great place on a not great day.

Geoffrey Gerace

Good atmosphere, a good amount of options on the menu, and the bacon cheeseburger I had there was 7/10, I get one at every restaurant I go to. Other than that I thought the prices were fair and the wait staff were friendly. Great place in Hamilton to get a quick bite.

tracy kleist

Service great. Food meh. Salty burger meat. Watery alfredo way too much garlic. "Taco salad" with bagged round tortilla chips. No dressing. For the prices I'd expect more. For quality of food. Salad bar decent. Restaurant atmosphere needs a overhaul.

Lisa Pagliaro

Great local restaurant near Colgate University in Hampton NY. Excellent calzones and sandwiches at reasonable prices. Recommended by our shuttle bus driver when we asked where to stop for lunch!

Sarah Benedict

Lots of memories here. Spacious place to get together with family and great food

Jennie Ward

Great food and service!

Load More