Pizza was good. It was my first time eating New York pizza and I am from the Midwest. I do prefer the Chicago deep dish style. But this was good too.
Hannah Reece
A Slice of Hamilton’s Heart ♥️ Tucked into the heart of Hamilton is a local gem, serving up more than just great pizza, serving the community for 30 years. Open six days a week, this spot has become a second home for many. The menu is classic, comforting, and consistently delicious, but what really sets this place apart is the man behind it. The owner Mike is the kind of hardworking, dedicated person who puts his soul into every slice, every order, every conversation. I just want to make sure this incredible legacy doesn’t go unnoticed. Hamilton wouldn’t be the same without it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Cozza
Food is outstanding!! Friendly staff. Vodka riggies. Antipasto. And classic plain pizza was a hit for our family. Don’t forget to grab a bucket of blue cheese dressing. You will thank me later
Blake Condolora
Great pizza , sometimes you just have to keep it simple is the key ! Delicious pepperoni pizza ! pricing is on point with Syracuse pizzerias was hot was on time , definitely try them
Dylan Donovan
Trying to get a quick slice of pizza sat and waited 20 minutes not worth the time
Samantha Cross
Good food, always busy. I usually call an hour before I want dinner. Wait time usually 30-40 minutes. Foods Always hot and fresh
Mie chelle
Yummmmm!! I absolutely love the classic panini and my son and I both enjoy the pizza!! It is thin crust and tasty. They are always very kind when we go there.
Mariah Hamilton
Called in a pick up order for 10 hot wings, extra crispy. Wings were fresh, piping hot and super crispy upon arrival. I have to say these are absolutely the BEST wings I’ve had! I’ll definitely be back very soon. Thank you!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
elite9800
Pizza is good probably the best in Hamilton. It's pricey for pizza but that's the Biden economy for you ?
We hired Oliveri's to cater an event for the Colgate University men's soccer match at home. We were very happy with how it all turned out and the efficiency with which it was all handled. Food was delicious and well received by the players ?Thank you ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
mikki harris
I’ve been waiting to try these sandwiches since my boyfriend told me about them when we first started dating. They were sooo freaking good! I ate the whole thing so fast and I’d go back there in a heartbeat. Everyone was nice and accommodating - I literally called to see what kind of bread they used because it blew me away. You just don’t find sandwiches like that everywhere around here. We had the lupo and the capri ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MJ
Would like to thank you for being honest about your pricing situation. Good pizza, I give it a 7.1. I would like just a few extra shavings of mozzarella. College kids are poor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza
K S
Not sure what happened. The first few times we went, we loved the food. Everything seemed made with care. This time, the pizza was terrible. There was a ton of unsauced areas, cheese wasn't evenly applied, the whole thing was dry and awful. The pasta we got was still great. We also noticed that there was maybe a price increase? The prices on the website don't match even close to what we were charged. We understand costs are going up, but we just wish we knew what the price was before placing the order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Vodka Riggies
Dane
A nice little pizza / sub shop right in the heart of downtown Hamilton. A handful of tables inside, but they do a lot of take out orders. The subs are large and the sausage sub I had was very large and filled with a lot of sausages, it was great. The inside is more interesting than your typical pizza joint, with a lot of sports memorabilia, specifically boxing.
Parking: Parking is available on the street which is free but can be difficult to find a spot.
Great pizza and service. Cool small town gem.
Pizza was good. It was my first time eating New York pizza and I am from the Midwest. I do prefer the Chicago deep dish style. But this was good too.
A Slice of Hamilton’s Heart ♥️
Tucked into the heart of Hamilton is a local gem, serving up more than just great pizza, serving the community for 30 years. Open six days a week, this spot has become a second home for many. The menu is classic, comforting, and consistently delicious, but what really sets this place apart is the man behind it. The owner Mike is the kind of hardworking, dedicated person who puts his soul into every slice, every order, every conversation. I just want to make sure this incredible legacy doesn’t go unnoticed. Hamilton wouldn’t be the same without it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is outstanding!! Friendly staff. Vodka riggies. Antipasto. And classic plain pizza was a hit for our family. Don’t forget to grab a bucket of blue cheese dressing. You will thank me later
Great pizza , sometimes you just have to keep it simple is the key ! Delicious pepperoni pizza ! pricing is on point with Syracuse pizzerias was hot was on time , definitely try them
Trying to get a quick slice of pizza sat and waited 20 minutes not worth the time
Good food, always busy. I usually call an hour before I want dinner. Wait time usually 30-40 minutes. Foods Always hot and fresh
Yummmmm!! I absolutely love the classic panini and my son and I both enjoy the pizza!! It is thin crust and tasty. They are always very kind when we go there.
Called in a pick up order for 10 hot wings, extra crispy. Wings were fresh, piping hot and super crispy upon arrival. I have to say these are absolutely the BEST wings I’ve had! I’ll definitely be back very soon. Thank you!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Pizza is good probably the best in Hamilton. It's pricey for pizza but that's the Biden economy for you ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
We hired Oliveri's to cater an event for the Colgate University men's soccer match at home. We were very happy with how it all turned out and the efficiency with which it was all handled. Food was delicious and well received by the players ?Thank you ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been waiting to try these sandwiches since my boyfriend told me about them when we first started dating. They were sooo freaking good! I ate the whole thing so fast and I’d go back there in a heartbeat. Everyone was nice and accommodating - I literally called to see what kind of bread they used because it blew me away. You just don’t find sandwiches like that everywhere around here. We had the lupo and the capri ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Would like to thank you for being honest about your pricing situation. Good pizza, I give it a 7.1. I would like just a few extra shavings of mozzarella. College kids are poor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Not sure what happened. The first few times we went, we loved the food. Everything seemed made with care. This time, the pizza was terrible. There was a ton of unsauced areas, cheese wasn't evenly applied, the whole thing was dry and awful. The pasta we got was still great. We also noticed that there was maybe a price increase? The prices on the website don't match even close to what we were charged. We understand costs are going up, but we just wish we knew what the price was before placing the order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Vodka Riggies
A nice little pizza / sub shop right in the heart of downtown Hamilton. A handful of tables inside, but they do a lot of take out orders. The subs are large and the sausage sub I had was very large and filled with a lot of sausages, it was great. The inside is more interesting than your typical pizza joint, with a lot of sports memorabilia, specifically boxing.
Parking: Parking is available on the street which is free but can be difficult to find a spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...