My friend and I chose this place for an early dinner. We had been a little stressed out due to looking for a missing phone and decided a nice sit down meal being waited on would be welcome. We enjoyed our time here as well as our meal. I had a small plate baked fish meal and it was delicious! The wifi worked well, too! Service was friendly and efficient. Our server went out of her say to make our change in quarters which we needed.
LoveTravelling52
Chose to have dinner here based on previous reviews. It was just so-so. Fried shrimp was the frozen variety, not freshly breaded. Salad I had before my meal was in a tiny bowl, with only light colored lettuce. Nothing else in the salad. Coconut cream pie was frozen type also. The chocolate cake was cold, so it had no taste. The restaurant is old and could use many updates. The waitresses were nice, but would not return.
Robert G
We've eaten here several times. Had cottage on Keuka. Most recently met several friends. Enjoyed the food. Service was excellent. Crowded, but folks were friendly and respectful. Food and drinks are reasonable. Spaghetti sauce was a little sweet for me, but many may like it. Nice place in a beautiful area with several great wineries, particularly Yates Cellars nearly on 14A.
C276XVdavidr
Exactly what to expect from a 1960’s restaurant. Warm atmosphere good food. Great cocktail. Service great !! The name says it all.
2reasons2fret
We received prime rib and salmon, both were over cooked. It’s was ok. I don’t think we will order from there again This is during the pandemic so that might be the reason.
86324Anonymous
Antique Inn is a restaurant with a country theme, There was only one other couple in the restaurant, filled with local artifacts. It was a surprise to find the restaurant almost empty on a Saturday night because there was a turkey raffle at the local fire hall. That was good for us because we had a table with another couple next to the fireplace. This is western New York, so there is an American flag next to the fireplace. The food was excellent. The pasta dishes, chicken, and fish were all excellent. So were the desserts. The service was excellent.
Donna G
Dated & tired decor. Food expensive for what you receive. Only third time here in 20 years of living in Penn Yan. Still a disappointment but now more money.
Mitchallan
What a surprise!! Needed to find a place for good take out food. With an extended family of 11, 3 of which are under 6, well we wanted to relax in the lake house. Passed a dozen times, but no one I know ever ate there. Well, we ordered 8 different entries to go. Each had a salad with choice of dressing and 2 sides. Everything was labeled and organized perfectly. On top of that every meal was delicious. They even put a surprise of 2 deserts in that we all tasted. Thank you so much Jenny. We will be back. This is Penn Yan's best kept secret. OH, BTW excellent prices.
Homebody44
If you’re looking for gourmet grub, get back in the BMW and keep driving. This lake region is chockablock with elegant eateries. On the other hand if you’re hankering for fresh ingredients, prepared with skill and care, efficient and friendly service in a uniquely decorated atmosphere, you’re in the right place. My wife’s crab cake sandwich and my liver and onions exceeded our expectations.
Laura G
Great food! Great service! Great prices! Nice atmosphere! Away from all the hussle and bussle of town and well worth the drive.
The food was great and the service excellent. Don’t let the size of the building fool you, it’s plenty roomy inside. I had the stuffed flounder and it was practically stuffed with a large crab cake. My husband had the veal parmigiana and said the sauce was very tasty. They give the table a carafe of water and with your entree you get a salad or soup, a starch and a veggie and dinner rolls.
BoleynMom
The Antique Inn is a nice family restaurant. The food is good. They have lots of seafood options, prime rib, pasta and sandwiches. The service is friendly and prompt. The owner, Jennie, has been there 41 years. It needs a bit of updating and the prices are higher than I would expect for the area, but I definitely recommend it. We go every year on our visit to Keuka Lake.
Jon H
Really good food with friendly service. Homemade! Variety! Good service! A great place for lunch or dinner if you are in the area.
nanaxoxoxo
We stopped at the Antique Inn on our way into Penn Yan. We had a very good sandwich- corned beef, swiss cheese on rye. The meat was very fresh, little fat. The bread was very fresh and the service was superb. We did not order dessert but the owner brought us a small dish of butterscotch pudding with half a chocolate chip cookie. The pudding was homemade- best I ever had. She did not charge us at all for the dessert- just told us it was a great ending to a meal:) Would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone traveling thru the Penn Yan area.
jbkal1
Great food and service. My husband order steak with side of pasta. He said the steak was done perfect and the pasta sauce was awesome. I had the baked Haddock and it was not over cook. The waitress was a help with the menu and sweet.
My friend and I chose this place for an early dinner. We had been a little stressed out due to looking for a missing phone and decided a nice sit down meal being waited on would be welcome. We enjoyed our time here as well as our meal. I had a small plate baked fish meal and it was delicious! The wifi worked well, too! Service was friendly and efficient. Our server went out of her say to make our change in quarters which we needed.
Chose to have dinner here based on previous reviews. It was just so-so. Fried shrimp was the frozen variety, not freshly breaded. Salad I had before my meal was in a tiny bowl, with only light colored lettuce. Nothing else in the salad. Coconut cream pie was frozen type also. The chocolate cake was cold, so it had no taste. The restaurant is old and could use many updates. The waitresses were nice, but would not return.
We've eaten here several times. Had cottage on Keuka. Most recently met several friends. Enjoyed the food. Service was excellent. Crowded, but folks were friendly and respectful. Food and drinks are reasonable. Spaghetti sauce was a little sweet for me, but many may like it. Nice place in a beautiful area with several great wineries, particularly Yates Cellars nearly on 14A.
Exactly what to expect from a 1960’s restaurant. Warm atmosphere good food. Great cocktail. Service great !! The name says it all.
We received prime rib and salmon, both were over cooked. It’s was ok. I don’t think we will order from there again This is during the pandemic so that might be the reason.
Antique Inn is a restaurant with a country theme, There was only one other couple in the restaurant, filled with local artifacts. It was a surprise to find the restaurant almost empty on a Saturday night because there was a turkey raffle at the local fire hall. That was good for us because we had a table with another couple next to the fireplace. This is western New York, so there is an American flag next to the fireplace. The food was excellent. The pasta dishes, chicken, and fish were all excellent. So were the desserts. The service was excellent.
Dated & tired decor. Food expensive for what you receive. Only third time here in 20 years of living in Penn Yan. Still a disappointment but now more money.
What a surprise!! Needed to find a place for good take out food. With an extended family of 11, 3 of which are under 6, well we wanted to relax in the lake house. Passed a dozen times, but no one I know ever ate there. Well, we ordered 8 different entries to go. Each had a salad with choice of dressing and 2 sides. Everything was labeled and organized perfectly. On top of that every meal was delicious. They even put a surprise of 2 deserts in that we all tasted. Thank you so much Jenny. We will be back. This is Penn Yan's best kept secret. OH, BTW excellent prices.
If you’re looking for gourmet grub, get back in the BMW and keep driving. This lake region is chockablock with elegant eateries. On the other hand if you’re hankering for fresh ingredients, prepared with skill and care, efficient and friendly service in a uniquely decorated atmosphere, you’re in the right place. My wife’s crab cake sandwich and my liver and onions exceeded our expectations.
Great food! Great service! Great prices! Nice atmosphere! Away from all the hussle and bussle of town and well worth the drive.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was great and the service excellent. Don’t let the size of the building fool you, it’s plenty roomy inside. I had the stuffed flounder and it was practically stuffed with a large crab cake. My husband had the veal parmigiana and said the sauce was very tasty. They give the table a carafe of water and with your entree you get a salad or soup, a starch and a veggie and dinner rolls.
The Antique Inn is a nice family restaurant. The food is good. They have lots of seafood options, prime rib, pasta and sandwiches. The service is friendly and prompt. The owner, Jennie, has been there 41 years. It needs a bit of updating and the prices are higher than I would expect for the area, but I definitely recommend it. We go every year on our visit to Keuka Lake.
Really good food with friendly service. Homemade! Variety! Good service! A great place for lunch or dinner if you are in the area.
We stopped at the Antique Inn on our way into Penn Yan. We had a very good sandwich- corned beef, swiss cheese on rye. The meat was very fresh, little fat. The bread was very fresh and the service was superb. We did not order dessert but the owner brought us a small dish of butterscotch pudding with half a chocolate chip cookie. The pudding was homemade- best I ever had. She did not charge us at all for the dessert- just told us it was a great ending to a meal:) Would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone traveling thru the Penn Yan area.
Great food and service. My husband order steak with side of pasta. He said the steak was done perfect and the pasta sauce was awesome. I had the baked Haddock and it was not over cook. The waitress was a help with the menu and sweet.
Loading...