Wise Guys

11187 NY-54, Hammondsport

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Carrie N Ron Stiles

Ordered 3 large pizzas for our office today for delivery over a $60 order and they don’t deliver past Simmons Rockwell Dealership ~ that we actually can see from our office/parking lot. Crazy and rude customer service!! Not to go above and beyond for any business to help out your business!! Obviously you have enough customers to support your business and don’t need any more.. ✌️out

bowercc

If want to sit back and enjoy your time at the lake and want quick and easy meal pick up a pizza or wings

Dawn Nieman Tighe

Wise Guys catered our lunch 3 days in a row. Food was excellent and service was great! Chicken garlic Pizza is a must have .... when I visit Hammondsport again.

Mtjc67

Did takeout for a speciality pizza and a hoagie. The garlic chicken white pizza was delicious - I added broccoli. Sure there was a bit of grease, so I absorbed some with a napkin! The hoagie had plenty of meat, but was lacking in the crusty rolls we like - still tasty. Saturday during not so busy season - order at least 45 minutes to 1 hour before you want to eat.

Jennifer Marie

my daughter and I went here for my first time! we had a calzone each and they were delicious and huge.. had to take 2/3 home each for lunch and dinner the next day. definitely recommend their calzones! lots of toppings inside too...

Jennifer Chissom

my daughter and I went here for my first time! we had a calzone each and they were delicious and huge.. had to take 2/3 home each for lunch and dinner the next day. definitely recommend their calzones! lots of toppings inside too...

thomasmC3313LE

Food was horrible and extremely overpriced. Pizza grease went through cardboard and stained my clothes.

Dan Smith

Pizza so good we cross state lines for it!

JBWD123

Delicious personal pizzas with loads of toppings! We highly recommend this restaurant for its great pizza.

Dakit55

We were hungry for pizza and our hotel recommended Wise Guys. Glad we took their advice. Since it was a Friday night, they were doing a lot of takeout orders. We ate at the restaurant. The staff was very friendly and the pizza crust was done crispy, the way we like it! Very good pizza.

apmcpm

We get pizza here when we are in the area to visit the wineries. It is also very, very good and is the best we've had in the area. The toppings are high quality and the sauce and crust are very good.

Leah P. W. Lewis

Oh my goodness! One of the best fish fry's in the area! Love that you can pick between fries and mac and cheese! The cole slaw was amazing!

22maryellenc

We had not planned on pizza for dinner, but on a Tuesday nigh in Hammondsport almost everything was closed. However, the pizza was tasty (just a little greasy) and there were tables outdoors for social distancing.

Bill R

Ordered a calzone and a bottle of Pepsi for delivery only to be told It did not meet their minimum for delivery. In spite of the fact that the menu said the delivery minimum was $15 was told the $20 was the minimum. They suggested I add some garlic bites, which I did. AND THAT BROUGHTTHE ORDER TO $32, WUITE A LEAP! To make mattes worse the food was LOUSY and their attitude EVEN WORSE. tHEY REALLY SEE THE TOURISTS COMING AND TAKE FULL ADVANTAGE! Rotten way to do business!!!

671caitlynl

Friend and I got carry out salads for lunch. Chicken caesar salad had shredded chicken that was almost grilled flavored. Same with steak! Big lettuce, big peppers and big flavor! Reasonably priced for amount of salad in container. Will be back again.

Loading...