Excellent fresh pizza. Homemade sauce and great crust. I had the chicken parmigiana slice and my husband had the pepperoni, sausage, and bacon...huge and delicious..we could barely finish them! Staff very friendly and professional.
Enrico P.
The only item we order here is spectacular; a plain XL pizza. No other size works somehow, it must be the XL, and it's amazing. Pizza heaven. The pie is huge - I have to tilt it to get it thru the doors in my home! But the crust, the sauce and the cheese-to-sauce-to-crust ratio is perfect.
Brian Smith
I can't believe I've never stopped by here, this place is the bomb. Lasagna slice is great!
Suzanne R.
We ordered delivery, so this is based on our experience. Our order was suppose to arrive by 8:40. Called at 8:55 & told we live far (10 minutes away) but order should be there in 10 minutes, so fine OK. 25 minutes later called again & was told again they were busy and we live far but should be there any minute. We waited over 90 minutes for food to arrive and we don't live far - we live in White Plains. We were missing 2 side orders from our order. We ordered gnocchi, which was good. Portobello pasta & added chicken to it which needed more sauce, because after the chicken was finished you were left with sad little pasta (according to my daughter). Chicken Frances was good. Biggest disappointment was Chicken Scarpariello. It was mixed in the pasta in the container and it was mostly pasta in the container. Pasta should have been served on the side like other restaurants do. My husband prefers FF with his scarp and I had ordered him FF so having to contend with an overflowing dish with pasta (that he didn't want) did not make for a pleasant meal. There was very little chicken in the scarpariello as a result. Desserts were OK. Will we order delivery from here again? No. Spending over $100, It was not worth waiting over 90 minutes for mediocre food. I'm sure it's great for pizza. We like to try out new places because this is how we find our tried and true go to places, sadly this one didn't make it.
Murad R.
Sadly its time to change. Over and hour and a half for a pie. Gave them 3 chances. They used to be great.
Lauren P.
Arthur Avenue has been our go-to delivery place throughout the pandemic and it's consistently good. At most restaurants, there are a few menu items we go back to, but here we order a lot of different things off the extensive menu and always love what we get. A few favorites: eggplant roll (which is very full of eggplant, as opposed to some places where pizza rolls are mostly bread and cheese), personal-size speciality pizzas (perfect to share), tortellini soup, antipasto salad, and chicken scarpariello. Once or twice when we ordered delivery, they forgot an item (it happens), but then they offered to bring it or discount our next order. I'm surprised by the bad reviews.
Jay Dee
Delicious!
J. Ford
Food is pretty good. I had a Sicilian slice and it was huge. Filled me up. Prices are reasonable. I'd go back again.
Joe Genuario
Great pizza
Lisa Sunshine-Mandel
Very friendly excellent pizza and food not too expensive
Great food great service a piece of little Italy in Westchester
Cheryl Berent
This Nona raves about “Grandma’s Pizza”, thin-crust basic margherite That tomato ? base & that cheese (someone makes it homemade!). Put a ribbon on the box and beautiful enough to deliver as a gift. One slice won’t be enough!(Scroll photos till you see the closeup square of basil on cheese)If you need a hearty big slice, crave a chewy perfectly browned crust, just enough oil drip, covered with lots of veggies or white pizza we say ?.Outside table big enough for a box. We feel embarrassed we didn’t wipe our crumbs off the table, bring your own wipes DIY, where your mask ? to talk when not eating, although they do comply with health regs. Put out a tip jar, chef!. Chilly in the shade after 4pm; our fam is from MN, put on ski pants! Bring a better knife (skinny plastic not good and yes, some people eat pizza with a knife and fork). #20 bus goes by here.
Lew Giordano
Nice pizza,very friendly
Tsehai Lewis
They have the BEST pizza!! The cheese is really good, taste better than your average pizzeria. The salads are always super fresh and the staff are so nice!! This is my pizza spot!
Wayne M.
Big disappointment,dried out meatball, stale untoasted bread,no sauce,eggplant not breaded,,will cook it myself next tine,will NEVER return!!!
Excellent fresh pizza. Homemade sauce and great crust. I had the chicken parmigiana slice and my husband had the pepperoni, sausage, and bacon...huge and delicious..we could barely finish them! Staff very friendly and professional.
The only item we order here is spectacular; a plain XL pizza. No other size works somehow, it must be the XL, and it's amazing. Pizza heaven. The pie is huge - I have to tilt it to get it thru the doors in my home! But the crust, the sauce and the cheese-to-sauce-to-crust ratio is perfect.
I can't believe I've never stopped by here, this place is the bomb. Lasagna slice is great!
We ordered delivery, so this is based on our experience. Our order was suppose to arrive by 8:40. Called at 8:55 & told we live far (10 minutes away) but order should be there in 10 minutes, so fine OK. 25 minutes later called again & was told again they were busy and we live far but should be there any minute. We waited over 90 minutes for food to arrive and we don't live far - we live in White Plains. We were missing 2 side orders from our order. We ordered gnocchi, which was good. Portobello pasta & added chicken to it which needed more sauce, because after the chicken was finished you were left with sad little pasta (according to my daughter). Chicken Frances was good. Biggest disappointment was Chicken Scarpariello. It was mixed in the pasta in the container and it was mostly pasta in the container. Pasta should have been served on the side like other restaurants do. My husband prefers FF with his scarp and I had ordered him FF so having to contend with an overflowing dish with pasta (that he didn't want) did not make for a pleasant meal. There was very little chicken in the scarpariello as a result. Desserts were OK. Will we order delivery from here again? No. Spending over $100, It was not worth waiting over 90 minutes for mediocre food. I'm sure it's great for pizza. We like to try out new places because this is how we find our tried and true go to places, sadly this one didn't make it.
Sadly its time to change. Over and hour and a half for a pie. Gave them 3 chances. They used to be great.
Arthur Avenue has been our go-to delivery place throughout the pandemic and it's consistently good. At most restaurants, there are a few menu items we go back to, but here we order a lot of different things off the extensive menu and always love what we get. A few favorites: eggplant roll (which is very full of eggplant, as opposed to some places where pizza rolls are mostly bread and cheese), personal-size speciality pizzas (perfect to share), tortellini soup, antipasto salad, and chicken scarpariello. Once or twice when we ordered delivery, they forgot an item (it happens), but then they offered to bring it or discount our next order. I'm surprised by the bad reviews.
Delicious!
Food is pretty good. I had a Sicilian slice and it was huge. Filled me up. Prices are reasonable. I'd go back again.
Great pizza
Very friendly excellent pizza and food not too expensive
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food great service a piece of little Italy in Westchester
This Nona raves about “Grandma’s Pizza”, thin-crust basic margherite That tomato ? base & that cheese (someone makes it homemade!). Put a ribbon on the box and beautiful enough to deliver as a gift. One slice won’t be enough!(Scroll photos till you see the closeup square of basil on cheese)If you need a hearty big slice, crave a chewy perfectly browned crust, just enough oil drip, covered with lots of veggies or white pizza we say ?.Outside table big enough for a box. We feel embarrassed we didn’t wipe our crumbs off the table, bring your own wipes DIY, where your mask ? to talk when not eating, although they do comply with health regs. Put out a tip jar, chef!. Chilly in the shade after 4pm; our fam is from MN, put on ski pants! Bring a better knife (skinny plastic not good and yes, some people eat pizza with a knife and fork). #20 bus goes by here.
Nice pizza,very friendly
They have the BEST pizza!! The cheese is really good, taste better than your average pizzeria. The salads are always super fresh and the staff are so nice!! This is my pizza spot!
Big disappointment,dried out meatball, stale untoasted bread,no sauce,eggplant not breaded,,will cook it myself next tine,will NEVER return!!!