Godfather's Hideout

211 Protection Ave, Herkimer
(315) 983-2526

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Erika Lehner-Skermont

Came in Friday evening. Restaurant had a nice ambiance. Beautiful fire place with Christmas trees and Christmas music playing. My husband and I both got riggies. He got chicken, I got shrimp. Food was delicious! Reasonably priced and a generous portion. Service was excellent! Our waitress was attentive and efficient. Would recommend and return.

Brian

Warm, inviting and comfortable. Excellent food and outstanding value. Dinning room was clean, service was impeccable. This was our first time going but will definitely not be our last.

Leida Furmanski

Godfather's Hideout, never ceases to amaze with their great delicious tasting food❣️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ben Skibinski

Great food and an awesome staff.

Matt Campbell

Weird Hours but awesome food and service 🐕‍🦺

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul Rose

Excellent meal 10 of 10 .....Service was 12 of 10!! Young lady had a few tables going and she didn’t miss a beat. Very courteous and professional!

Obed Lozada

I ordered chicken riggies there and it was the worse.I got pasta.No chicken, no garlic bread.No salad and I pay 22dollars😫

Food: 1

Service: 3

Hannah

The Carbones provided an excellent birthday dinner with outstanding customer service and quality food!

Savannah Trunzo

Really cute place and good prices too!! Food was great! I got riggies with no meat!

Recommended dishes: Chicken Riggies

dorothy pohleven

I was visiting from out of town and I was so very impressed with every aspect of my dining experience. I had never eaten Reggie’s before and that sauce was amazing as well as the meatballs! I want to know if I can buy some sauce and have it shipped? The wait staff was also very pleasant and very efficient. We were a big party and they couldn’t have been more accommodating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

david gutowski

We went to Godfather's Hideout for Dinner. The restaurant is beautiful and the food is great! The menu is fairly small as everything is homemade. It basically consists of Italian dishes.....Greens, Riggies, Parmesan, etc. They do have specials. We certainly will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beth

Reservations are a big help!! Very popular venue. Staff is wonderful...very attentive. The menu is smart...stick to what you do best. Also, appreciate the ability to order a small order...which still was more than enough for lunch the next day. I had riggis with shrimp...delicious. Ordered medium “heat” and it was seasoned perfectly. My pet peeve is food that comes up warm not hot. Food came out hot!! This order was cooked to perfection. The pasta wasn't “hammered”. We ordered two of the drink specials...excellent! No room for dessert but will leave room next time. Selections looked amazing. Another plus...this won't bust your budget. Will surely be returning to Godfather's Hideout!

Justin Bruce

The atmosphere is amazing, great service, great food! I highly recommend!

Michelle Neverusky-Brindeau

Best Riggies! Wonderful food and service…Bravo!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

GW W

We ordered takeout for a party. Riggies and pulled pork were very good but shells with broccoli were kind of bland.
Delivery was very good and on time as with the setup.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...