Ordered sausage riggies mild, there was no heat whatsoever. They don't offer medium heat which is crazy being that in my experience majority of people order medium heat. They weren't bad, definitely needs more sauce and more spicy. I've ordered the pizza a couple times and it's good but it too needs more sauce. PIZZA ~3/5 RIGGIES ~ 2.5/5 Garlic bread~ 2.5/5 Side salad~ 1/5
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Heidi Linke
Parking: You're lucky to find parking close to the restaurant because they're always busy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pizza, Chicken Tenders, Stuffed Shells
corey cook
I've been frequenting Yeti's since I was a child, on and off for decades. It'd been a while since we had Yeti's and while looking for options one evening we spotted Yeti's was running a weekday special for a large white garlic pizza, perfect my favorite! When we called to order, a very nice young lady proceeded to take our order as we requested the garlic pizza special for $13-15(ish). At most joints, it's not uncommon to request additional toppings, so I politely asked if we could add some sliced tomatoes and ricotta cheese. As something like requesting added toppings isn't typically unusual, she said absolutely, albiet for an added charge of around $1 each topping, bringing the total to around $15-17, excelant! It wasn't 10 minutes later, I received a call back from the nice lady who took our order, hmm? She quickly apologized, then proceeded to tell me that the owner would not honor the special price if I wanted to add additional toppings, despite already agreeing to an upcharge for them, what!? I thought the situation was strange. Of course, I asked the young lady for an explanation. She too thought this was unusual, considering people request added toppings, albeit for an extra fee, all the time! She then told me if I wanted the pizza with the added toppings, I would need to pay full price equating to roughly $23-24! I reluctantly obliged. Confused by what just happened, my significant other agreed, this was definately unusual. We finally arrived at Yeti's to grab our pizza. Admittedly, I wasn't too happy about the situation but given past experiences, my expectations for the pizza would be worth it. We arrived home maybe 5 minutes later and proceeded to start digging in when it became very obvious something wasn't right with our order. The pizza was ice cold and hard! To top it off, after inspecting a slice, it seemed as if the pizza was made as a plain white, garlic, then retroactively added the requested sliced tomatoes and ricotta cheese on as an afterthought!? Keep in mind, my original order, the waitress originally quoted me would've cost around $15, I ultimately paid $24. At the very least, I expected the pizza be fresh, really? In that moment, already feeling annoyed, I felt disrespected and scammed! I'm not typically the type of person to be petty, but this was unacceptable! It's sad because this place use to be pretty great and my last Yeti's pie was unbelievably disappointing and over priced! The no special price if you want toppings is wild! I order specials from Ed's in little Falls all the time with additional toppings for approximately $1 each. Never have I been denied a special price when I request to add additional toppings for a slight upcharge. I thought it was very unprofessional to call us back and change the price after already agreeing.
Note, this all took place around the end of September, 2024.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Diane Curry
If you leave hungry it's your own fault... Run by very pleasant people.
Parking: Round to back of building.
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp is on front of house/building
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: lg Cheese Pizza Baked Lasagna Chicken Riggies
Bill Buddenhagen
Very good pizza and service
Allen Williams
The best Chicken righties anywhere. Hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Riggies
Karen Gordon
Perfect road trip lunch experience. Great service and the bread will change your life.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan playz
Absolutely amazing pizza will go there every time we are at the Koa camping
Spaghetti diner was terrible. Could barely cut the meatball and the pasta was way over cooked. Not the way it use to be.
Leta Resolve
I have loved growing up with their freshly made Italian-American foods. The upside down pizza is classic. Hoping these guys will remain in good standing for years to come!
Parking: They own a parking lot behind the building.
Kid-friendliness: The waitress brought out some picture books for my 7 month old. I am grateful for their thoughtfulness!
Have been a customer for nearly 50 years and my most recent visit did not disappoint. I was born around here and my family moved away when I was pretty young, but I’ve never been back to Herkimer without at least grabbing a pizza at Yetty’s. Added some riggies and wings to the take-out order this time and everything was FANTASTIC! Great pepper flavor in the riggies and don’t sleep on the garlic bread. It was my wife’s first time here. She’s not easy to impress with pizza and pasta, but thought the food was great and really appreciated your extra-friendly service when picking up the order. Thanks for continuing to deliver the goods after so many years. See y’all again in a few years!
Parking: They have a side door where you drive up to grab take-out orders.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pizza, Chicken Riggies
The best Chicken Riggs EVER!!!
Love the upside down pizza they make
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pizza
Ordered sausage riggies mild, there was no heat whatsoever. They don't offer medium heat which is crazy being that in my experience majority of people order medium heat. They weren't bad, definitely needs more sauce and more spicy. I've ordered the pizza a couple times and it's good but it too needs more sauce.
PIZZA ~3/5
RIGGIES ~ 2.5/5
Garlic bread~ 2.5/5
Side salad~ 1/5
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Parking: You're lucky to find parking close to the restaurant because they're always busy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pizza, Chicken Tenders, Stuffed Shells
I've been frequenting Yeti's since I was a child, on and off for decades. It'd been a while since we had Yeti's and while looking for options one evening we spotted Yeti's was running a weekday special for a large white garlic pizza, perfect my favorite! When we called to order, a very nice young lady proceeded to take our order as we requested the garlic pizza special for $13-15(ish). At most joints, it's not uncommon to request additional toppings, so I politely asked if we could add some sliced tomatoes and ricotta cheese. As something like requesting added toppings isn't typically unusual, she said absolutely, albiet for an added charge of around $1 each topping, bringing the total to around $15-17, excelant! It wasn't 10 minutes later, I received a call back from the nice lady who took our order, hmm? She quickly apologized, then proceeded to tell me that the owner would not honor the special price if I wanted to add additional toppings, despite already agreeing to an upcharge for them, what!? I thought the situation was strange. Of course, I asked the young lady for an explanation. She too thought this was unusual, considering people request added toppings, albeit for an extra fee, all the time! She then told me if I wanted the pizza with the added toppings, I would need to pay full price equating to roughly $23-24! I reluctantly obliged. Confused by what just happened, my significant other agreed, this was definately unusual. We finally arrived at Yeti's to grab our pizza. Admittedly, I wasn't too happy about the situation but given past experiences, my expectations for the pizza would be worth it. We arrived home maybe 5 minutes later and proceeded to start digging in when it became very obvious something wasn't right with our order. The pizza was ice cold and hard! To top it off, after inspecting a slice, it seemed as if the pizza was made as a plain white, garlic, then retroactively added the requested sliced tomatoes and ricotta cheese on as an afterthought!? Keep in mind, my original order, the waitress originally quoted me would've cost around $15, I ultimately paid $24. At the very least, I expected the pizza be fresh, really? In that moment, already feeling annoyed, I felt disrespected and scammed! I'm not typically the type of person to be petty, but this was unacceptable! It's sad because this place use to be pretty great and my last Yeti's pie was unbelievably disappointing and over priced! The no special price if you want toppings is wild! I order specials from Ed's in little Falls all the time with additional toppings for approximately $1 each. Never have I been denied a special price when I request to add additional toppings for a slight upcharge. I thought it was very unprofessional to call us back and change the price after already agreeing.
Note, this all took place around the end of September, 2024.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
If you leave hungry it's your own fault...
Run by very pleasant people.
Parking: Round to back of building.
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp is on front of house/building
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: lg Cheese Pizza Baked Lasagna Chicken Riggies
Very good pizza and service
The best Chicken righties anywhere. Hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Riggies
Perfect road trip lunch experience. Great service and the bread will change your life.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely amazing pizza will go there every time we are at the Koa camping
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Spaghetti diner was terrible. Could barely cut the meatball and the pasta was way over cooked. Not the way it use to be.
I have loved growing up with their freshly made Italian-American foods. The upside down pizza is classic. Hoping these guys will remain in good standing for years to come!
Parking: They own a parking lot behind the building.
Kid-friendliness: The waitress brought out some picture books for my 7 month old. I am grateful for their thoughtfulness!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Mixed Sub, Upside Down Pizza, Chicken Tenders, Cannoli, Chicken Riggies
Best food. Waitress Katrina amazing
Parking: Small area
Wheelchair accessibility: Does have a ramp but yightbfut in door
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Yettis Pizza, Chicken Wing Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Veal Parmesan, Chicken Tenders, Carrot Cake, Chicken Wings
Best lasagna ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have been a customer for nearly 50 years and my most recent visit did not disappoint. I was born around here and my family moved away when I was pretty young, but I’ve never been back to Herkimer without at least grabbing a pizza at Yetty’s. Added some riggies and wings to the take-out order this time and everything was FANTASTIC! Great pepper flavor in the riggies and don’t sleep on the garlic bread. It was my wife’s first time here. She’s not easy to impress with pizza and pasta, but thought the food was great and really appreciated your extra-friendly service when picking up the order. Thanks for continuing to deliver the goods after so many years. See y’all again in a few years!
Parking: They have a side door where you drive up to grab take-out orders.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pizza, Chicken Riggies
Loading...