There is too much butter for a plain bagel or everything bagel. There's enough butter for two bagels.
Food: 1
Raymond Dewey
Nice traditional LI bagel shopGood
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Stephen Finkelstein
Very clean. Very pleasant staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
Carlene Toron
They have nice tuna salad and excellent egg salad. Easy parking, as it's in a shopping center.
Heriberto Hernandez
Great staff, clean place, fresh bagels this is one of the best bagels store that I been to in along time highly recommend
Frank Caria
Have been there several times but went today and the egg salad bought tasted bad and kept that taste for several hours. Got a bagel as well with cream cheese and spit it out because the cream cheese was definitely spoiled. Not sure if the total fridge section was down or something but to have two things both spoiled was not a good experience. Will not be back.
Frank C.
Have been there several times but went today and the egg salad bought tasted bad and kept that taste for several hours. Got a bagel as well with cream cheese and spit it out because the cream cheese was definitely spoiled. Not sure if the total fridge section was down or something but to have two things both spoiled was not a good experience. Will not be back.
Lauren U.
Went here for lunch, tried to order multiple items. They claimed they ran out of lettuce? I ended up ordering the tuna salad, tasted okay. Next thing you know, I am in the bathroom for hours the rest of the day. We went with multiple people and they claimed they did not feel well either and they ordered different things.
Rebecca Johnsamson
I love magic bagels and all that work there are super friendly, fast service with lots of smiles , my favorite breakfast place ???❤️❤️❤️❤️
Hailoua Sali
Store is really clean and the service is pretty good , new owner was nice and made the store look clean and organized definitely recommended
Payed way too much for a bottle of flat seltzer, a bottle of water, coffee that was light, and a tuna bagel that was ok.
Lexi C
Updated 12/28/22:I really enjoyed there veggie tuna on a whole wheat wrap and it’s a big wrap too you get a lotEarly December 2022 Review:Bagels are crunchy slightly hard on the outside and soft in the inside, good texture combination - I liked the vegetable cream cheese as well. Cons: they’re understaffed so it’s always a wait
Lexi Christensen
Updated 12/28/22:I really enjoyed there veggie tuna on a whole wheat wrap and it’s a big wrap too you get a lotEarly December 2022 Review:Bagels are crunchy slightly hard on the outside and soft in the inside, good texture combination - I liked the vegetable cream cheese as well. Cons: they’re understaffed so it’s always a wait
Alan
Delicious lox bagel with onion and tomato. Super fresh and tasty.
Bart Charkow
Long story short, ignored for 10 minutes, order that was placed was made incorrectly, bagels tasteless and chewy, not sure how this place is still in business. Unfortunate.
There is too much butter for a plain bagel or everything bagel. There's enough butter for two bagels.
Food: 1
Nice traditional LI bagel shopGood
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Very clean. Very pleasant staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
They have nice tuna salad and excellent egg salad. Easy parking, as it's in a shopping center.
Great staff, clean place, fresh bagels this is one of the best bagels store that I been to in along time highly recommend
Have been there several times but went today and the egg salad bought tasted bad and kept that taste for several hours. Got a bagel as well with cream cheese and spit it out because the cream cheese was definitely spoiled. Not sure if the total fridge section was down or something but to have two things both spoiled was not a good experience. Will not be back.
Have been there several times but went today and the egg salad bought tasted bad and kept that taste for several hours. Got a bagel as well with cream cheese and spit it out because the cream cheese was definitely spoiled. Not sure if the total fridge section was down or something but to have two things both spoiled was not a good experience. Will not be back.
Went here for lunch, tried to order multiple items. They claimed they ran out of lettuce? I ended up ordering the tuna salad, tasted okay. Next thing you know, I am in the bathroom for hours the rest of the day. We went with multiple people and they claimed they did not feel well either and they ordered different things.
I love magic bagels and all that work there are super friendly, fast service with lots of smiles , my favorite breakfast place ???❤️❤️❤️❤️
Store is really clean and the service is pretty good , new owner was nice and made the store look clean and organized definitely recommended
Restaurantji Recommends
Payed way too much for a bottle of flat seltzer, a bottle of water, coffee that was light, and a tuna bagel that was ok.
Updated 12/28/22:I really enjoyed there veggie tuna on a whole wheat wrap and it’s a big wrap too you get a lotEarly December 2022 Review:Bagels are crunchy slightly hard on the outside and soft in the inside, good texture combination - I liked the vegetable cream cheese as well. Cons: they’re understaffed so it’s always a wait
Updated 12/28/22:I really enjoyed there veggie tuna on a whole wheat wrap and it’s a big wrap too you get a lotEarly December 2022 Review:Bagels are crunchy slightly hard on the outside and soft in the inside, good texture combination - I liked the vegetable cream cheese as well. Cons: they’re understaffed so it’s always a wait
Delicious lox bagel with onion and tomato. Super fresh and tasty.
Long story short, ignored for 10 minutes, order that was placed was made incorrectly, bagels tasteless and chewy, not sure how this place is still in business. Unfortunate.