Jay's Deli
534 NY-32, Highland Mills
(845) 928-2803
Customers' Favorites
Grilled Cheese with Melted American Cheese Choice of Bread
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Chicken Wings 10 Pieces
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Large Tossed Salad
Home Fries Small
Egg on a Roll
Eggplant Hero
Pastrami
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Jays Deli provided the best experience for the movie I was on. Colleen, Zee, Phil, Cal, Kim and everyone there always made me feel welcomed when I called or stopped by. Next time I’m in Highland Mills New York I’ll be stopping by asap. Thank you so much!
Great atmosphere, friendly service and the food 💯 I order Chicken cutlet with American cheese bacon with lettuce tomato Russian dressing on a seeded hero, and macaroni salad is my favorite.
I came here with my family for the first time and was blown away. The interior was so clean! They were so helpful with the high tech coffee bar and they had so many products to choose from. I was also very surprised by the spacious dining room tucked away to the side. It was a great experience and the food was delicious! Will go back again!
You May Also Like
Tacos Express - 514 NY-32
![]()
Mexican, Coffee & Tea, Tacos
Mario's - 503 NY-32
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Lounges