I LOVE the white pizza. I’m visiting from out of state for a week and have ordered it twice. It’s even great the next day warmed up for breakfast. The crust is chewy, but not soft. The pasta was perfectly al dente.
Food: 5
Johnny Overmind
While buying a personal pie at the register the employee asks me whether I'm using cash or card to pay. Keep in mind that the display facing me on the register says $15.76 already... So after telling him cash he mentions that I'll be getting "cash discount" and presses a couple of buttons on the register and then tells me the price of the pie is $15.76... I was fine with the price but he didn't have to pretend that I was receiving a discount. The pizza was good but I'd rather not do business with someone who is just going to needlessly lie to me.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Ricky Gonzalez
Over the years, I have learned to be leery with Pomodoro's. It's like rolling the dice. Sometimes the food is good, sometimes the food is not good. You take your chances. Late January 2024 was the last straw for me. A family member got severely sick from a regular pizza pie delivered locally. I and others in the same household did not eat the pizza, thinking we could save it for the next day. I, however, have experienced food poisoning firsthand from time to time over the years from Pomodoro's. Consistency in food quality is simply not there. Again, my experience over the years. My comments do not reflect one or two bad occasions. I have to question appropriate food storage, freshness quality, and kitchen practices. Reading through the other comments posted here, it struck me how minimal, indeed, very little, the number of responses from the owner. Good or bad comments from Facebook, Google, or other. I am an 18 year long resident of the same local village supporting local businesses. Please consider good consistent food quality via kitchen practices, and please connect with your customers and your local community via social media often.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Vree Imports
Great Pizza! Grandma pies are amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
FPV - Mgunit13
First off, the service here is terrible. We were seated quickly, but 10 minutes later and no one came to the table, so I went up to order an appetizer to the counter and tried ordering drinks too and out server behind counter said he would be right over to take our orders. He then came over 5 minutes later with just the mozzarella sticks and asked us what we wanted for main meal, then walked away, and I said "excuse me sir, what about our drinks, you never asked us, and that's usually the first thing you do" he looked mad that I said this. 2nd off, the main meals were ridiculous! I ordered Italian Sub for $9.40 and no lie, it was worse then me making my own sub, it was very dry bread with no maynoisee, pepper, salt all missing, barely any lettuce and the whole thing was a mess, the oil and vinegar was black and not good at all (I would of been better with an Walmart sub) see my pictures. 3rd off never saw a Stromboli this flat and small, and it was hard as a rock, for $8. Then 4th off look at that spaghetti dinner with chicken, their was no chicken at all almost, and it looked like can of watered down spaghetti sauce from a can, for $17. I was absolutely disappointed, especially for a place that's Italian. I would not recommend this place to anyone. The prices are outrageous for poor food and service. I believe the reviews are fake, or people don't know what good Italian food is, Brennies is definitely a better option. The pictures tell all!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sid P.
Mike needs to stick to pizza and not make comments about my friends work and my plumbing work Needs to wash his hands after playing w his bunghole that shit doesn't burn off
Barron Rockwell
Specialty pizzas are great. Also recommend their chicken francese
Spence Rogers
Great food, great service, great local New York atmosphere. Gluten free options if that is your thing. Strombolis, New York pizza and Sicilian pizza were part of the menu. Good select of great tasting unique brews. German beer. Highly recommend.
Jessica Cruz-Strika
$15 Ceasar salad was a house salad with raw bread and some cheese thrown on top. Wasn't expecting much but fifteen dollars for this?!
Excellent pizza with a thin, chewy crust (the way it's supposed to be!)
Food: 5
Kate Bloss
We have dined in here, ordered take out and ordered catering for family parties and we have never been let down. The food and service have always been great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Barkman
I often stop there on my way to the walkway and never knew they delivered after finding out they do I gave it a try they told me 45 and arrived in 30 of course the food was great But it arrived early and hot and the delivery person was great Kudos and I'll be ordering again
Food: 5
Service: 5
Teresa Waldow
Fabulous pizza! Great servers! Their cauliflower pizza is fantastic!Dietary restrictions: Perfect gluten free cauliflower crust pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Toni Sterling
Stopped here for a quick bite. Their pizza is very delicious! The thin crust is nice and crispy. Decent amount of tables inside and a few outside. The girl at the counter was very nice. The bathroom was clean. Would reccomend.
Pizza is always good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I LOVE the white pizza. I’m visiting from out of state for a week and have ordered it twice. It’s even great the next day warmed up for breakfast. The crust is chewy, but not soft. The pasta was perfectly al dente.
Food: 5
While buying a personal pie at the register the employee asks me whether I'm using cash or card to pay. Keep in mind that the display facing me on the register says $15.76 already... So after telling him cash he mentions that I'll be getting "cash discount" and presses a couple of buttons on the register and then tells me the price of the pie is $15.76... I was fine with the price but he didn't have to pretend that I was receiving a discount. The pizza was good but I'd rather not do business with someone who is just going to needlessly lie to me.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Over the years, I have learned to be leery with Pomodoro's. It's like rolling the dice. Sometimes the food is good, sometimes the food is not good. You take your chances. Late January 2024 was the last straw for me. A family member got severely sick from a regular pizza pie delivered locally. I and others in the same household did not eat the pizza, thinking we could save it for the next day. I, however, have experienced food poisoning firsthand from time to time over the years from Pomodoro's. Consistency in food quality is simply not there. Again, my experience over the years. My comments do not reflect one or two bad occasions. I have to question appropriate food storage, freshness quality, and kitchen practices. Reading through the other comments posted here, it struck me how minimal, indeed, very little, the number of responses from the owner. Good or bad comments from Facebook, Google, or other. I am an 18 year long resident of the same local village supporting local businesses. Please consider good consistent food quality via kitchen practices, and please connect with your customers and your local community via social media often.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great Pizza! Grandma pies are amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First off, the service here is terrible. We were seated quickly, but 10 minutes later and no one came to the table, so I went up to order an appetizer to the counter and tried ordering drinks too and out server behind counter said he would be right over to take our orders. He then came over 5 minutes later with just the mozzarella sticks and asked us what we wanted for main meal, then walked away, and I said "excuse me sir, what about our drinks, you never asked us, and that's usually the first thing you do" he looked mad that I said this. 2nd off, the main meals were ridiculous! I ordered Italian Sub for $9.40 and no lie, it was worse then me making my own sub, it was very dry bread with no maynoisee, pepper, salt all missing, barely any lettuce and the whole thing was a mess, the oil and vinegar was black and not good at all (I would of been better with an Walmart sub) see my pictures. 3rd off never saw a Stromboli this flat and small, and it was hard as a rock, for $8. Then 4th off look at that spaghetti dinner with chicken, their was no chicken at all almost, and it looked like can of watered down spaghetti sauce from a can, for $17. I was absolutely disappointed, especially for a place that's Italian. I would not recommend this place to anyone. The prices are outrageous for poor food and service. I believe the reviews are fake, or people don't know what good Italian food is, Brennies is definitely a better option. The pictures tell all!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike needs to stick to pizza and not make comments about my friends work and my plumbing work Needs to wash his hands after playing w his bunghole that shit doesn't burn off
Specialty pizzas are great. Also recommend their chicken francese
Great food, great service, great local New York atmosphere. Gluten free options if that is your thing. Strombolis, New York pizza and Sicilian pizza were part of the menu. Good select of great tasting unique brews. German beer. Highly recommend.
$15 Ceasar salad was a house salad with raw bread and some cheese thrown on top. Wasn't expecting much but fifteen dollars for this?!
Food: 1
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent pizza with a thin, chewy crust (the way it's supposed to be!)
Food: 5
We have dined in here, ordered take out and ordered catering for family parties and we have never been let down. The food and service have always been great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I often stop there on my way to the walkway and never knew they delivered after finding out they do I gave it a try they told me 45 and arrived in 30 of course the food was great But it arrived early and hot and the delivery person was great Kudos and I'll be ordering again
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fabulous pizza! Great servers! Their cauliflower pizza is fantastic!Dietary restrictions: Perfect gluten free cauliflower crust pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped here for a quick bite. Their pizza is very delicious! The thin crust is nice and crispy. Decent amount of tables inside and a few outside. The girl at the counter was very nice. The bathroom was clean. Would reccomend.
Food: 5