Hillsdale House
2634 NY-23, Hillsdale
(518) 325-7111
Customers' Favorites
Trio Tapenade Platter
Mac and Cheese
Fish and Chips
Pulled Pork
Side Salad
Brisket
Pizza
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Unexpected gem. They were able to sit us (6) on a Saturday night without a reservation which I’m thankful for. Our server was great - didn’t catch her name but she was nice and helpful. The food tho - was not sure what I was expecting ordering pasta at a pub but the pasta and meatballs were amazing. Will definitely come here again when I’m in town next year!
Always have a great time going here for dinner. We usually get the same waitress. (Can't for the life of me remember her name but she is also a teacher outside of waitressing and she deserves a raise) service is always great, food is amazing, atmosphere is inviting. We love it.
A mixed experience, with highs and lows.
Highs:
Our server was great and she did the best she could. The garlic knots were the best we’ve ever had. The cocktails were good.
Lows:
Bar service was S L O W.
Mac and cheese was flavorful but VERY dry.
Will give it another shot but will order pizzas next time.
Highs:
Our server was great and she did the best she could. The garlic knots were the best we’ve ever had. The cocktails were good.
Lows:
Bar service was S L O W.
Mac and cheese was flavorful but VERY dry.
Will give it another shot but will order pizzas next time.
You May Also Like
Roe Jan Brewing Co. - 32 Anthony St
![]()
Brewpubs, American, Brewery, Pet Friendly
Four Brothers Pizza Inn - 2828 NY-23
![]()
Pizza, Salad