My husband and I went to Mayers winery in Hilton yesterday and had a wonderful experience. I had some soup and it was delicious. This is a very friendly place and has a warm cozy feeling inside. The smell of the fire is amazing. So glad we found this gem of a place. I highly recommend this place for a nice get away.
Sara Pabon
Really nice spot that can accommodate large groups. Fish fry and lobster bisque were delicious. Dave made us feel right at home. Will definitely be back.
Janice Hawley
On 2.23.24 we drove from Batavia. We arrived at 4:30 and they had no cook and didn't know when one would be in. Terrible service. A long drive and no food. Very disappointing ?!!!!!!
Debra Wagner
This place is amazing. Well-worth the drive from Lewiston area. Wines are great.
Scott Martin
Great place! Got waited on by the owner. Excellent Chocolate Porter. Food was exceptional. Highly recommend the charcuterie board.
Jill Anne
Enchanting! This Winery is beautiful and charming. A Sunday afternoon Open Mic on the Patio under red umbrellas surrounded by lovely foliage was my introduction to Mayers Lake Ontario Winery. Wonderful vibe , foodOwner and Staff! Food is also excellent I would say this is a must-visit place!
jerry franklin
Delicious Friday fish fry!!Great service and atmosphere..A hidden gem serving a nice selection of ciders.
Jason Phillips
All of the ciders and food were amazing! Super cool relaxed spot to hang out!
bishops h
I would put 0 star if I could. I ordered 2 enolmatic bottle fillers on 12/15/21 for $578. It's been 17 months and i still haven't receive them or a refund. I call this theft. I talked to someone who never gives his name and he said multiple times he will send them and they will lose money because they are now more money to buy. Who's fault is that. He said he is really busy. Come on. He is such a liar. Well he told me last time they will be sent to me by 4/15/23. Of course another lie. If you want to talk to the biggest liar ever call 815-368-8313. If you deal with this winery and you called this number you know you are going to get screwed. Don't order anything online or spend a dime with these crooks.
Meagan Oas
There’s no wine menu. They claim it’s constantly changing, which isn’t the case. The wines have always been the same. They have 3 beers from a “local brewery” but when we asked what brewery it was, she stated she didn’t know. And didn’t even try to find out. I’m sure that local brewery wouldn’t be pleased to know their beers aren’t being advertised. Over half of the items on the menu aren’t available. But we weren’t told that when we were handed the menus. Wait time on the food was insane and they were not busy. We watched people wait over 20 minutes for a “flight” of wine. Again, no wine menu to pick their wines from! The location and atmosphere are the best. But they need better staff that has more knowledge.
Charming hidden gem we discovered by chance on a motorcycle ride. Very friendly staff more than willing to accommodate your every request. Delicious pizza from the kitchen!! Tasty cider and wines too!
Brenda B.
Went for music. Music was great. Unfortunately I can not say the same about the food. I ordered a pizza and they say it's wood fired. It was not. It seemed like a shell with cheap toppings. Not worth the price for sure. I will not be getting the pizza again. Some people there got other food that looked ok but it's expensive. My pizza and drink came to over $35 bucks and that was before tip. Waitress was nice and efficient. Just not worth the price.
Bishops H.
I would put 0 star if I could. I ordered 2 enolmatic bottle fillers on 12/15/21 for $578. It's been 17 months and i still haven't receive them or a refund. I call this theft. I talked to someone who never gives his name and he said multiple times he will send them and they will lose money because they are now more money to buy. Who's fault is that. He said he is really busy. Come on. He is such a liar. Well he told me last time they will be sent to me by 4/15/23. Of course another lie. If you want to talk to the biggest liar ever call 815-368-8313. If you deal with this winery and you called this number you know you are going to get screwed. Don't order anything online or spend a dime with these crooks.
Eileen Fichter
My husband, daughter, and I went in for wine and pizza. We met the Owner Dave who was absolutely wonderful. The atmosphere was perfect and the staff and patrons were friendly and fun. We had wine tastings and a nice dinner, Dave interacted with us throughout our time there and personally did our tasting. Everything was excellent and the Chef was very nice. We bought 5 bottles of wine and can not wait to go back!
My husband and I went to Mayers winery in Hilton yesterday and had a wonderful experience. I had some soup and it was delicious. This is a very friendly place and has a warm cozy feeling inside. The smell of the fire is amazing. So glad we found this gem of a place. I highly recommend this place for a nice get away.
Really nice spot that can accommodate large groups. Fish fry and lobster bisque were delicious. Dave made us feel right at home. Will definitely be back.
On 2.23.24 we drove from Batavia. We arrived at 4:30 and they had no cook and didn't know when one would be in. Terrible service. A long drive and no food. Very disappointing ?!!!!!!
This place is amazing. Well-worth the drive from Lewiston area. Wines are great.
Great place! Got waited on by the owner. Excellent Chocolate Porter. Food was exceptional. Highly recommend the charcuterie board.
Enchanting! This Winery is beautiful and charming. A Sunday afternoon Open Mic on the Patio under red umbrellas surrounded by lovely foliage was my introduction to Mayers Lake Ontario Winery. Wonderful vibe , foodOwner and Staff! Food is also excellent I would say this is a must-visit place!
Delicious Friday fish fry!!Great service and atmosphere..A hidden gem serving a nice selection of ciders.
All of the ciders and food were amazing! Super cool relaxed spot to hang out!
I would put 0 star if I could. I ordered 2 enolmatic bottle fillers on 12/15/21 for $578. It's been 17 months and i still haven't receive them or a refund. I call this theft. I talked to someone who never gives his name and he said multiple times he will send them and they will lose money because they are now more money to buy. Who's fault is that. He said he is really busy. Come on. He is such a liar. Well he told me last time they will be sent to me by 4/15/23. Of course another lie. If you want to talk to the biggest liar ever call 815-368-8313. If you deal with this winery and you called this number you know you are going to get screwed. Don't order anything online or spend a dime with these crooks.
There’s no wine menu. They claim it’s constantly changing, which isn’t the case. The wines have always been the same. They have 3 beers from a “local brewery” but when we asked what brewery it was, she stated she didn’t know. And didn’t even try to find out. I’m sure that local brewery wouldn’t be pleased to know their beers aren’t being advertised. Over half of the items on the menu aren’t available. But we weren’t told that when we were handed the menus. Wait time on the food was insane and they were not busy. We watched people wait over 20 minutes for a “flight” of wine. Again, no wine menu to pick their wines from! The location and atmosphere are the best. But they need better staff that has more knowledge.
Restaurantji Recommends
Fun times with live music. Really good fish fry!
Charming hidden gem we discovered by chance on a motorcycle ride. Very friendly staff more than willing to accommodate your every request. Delicious pizza from the kitchen!! Tasty cider and wines too!
Went for music. Music was great. Unfortunately I can not say the same about the food. I ordered a pizza and they say it's wood fired. It was not. It seemed like a shell with cheap toppings. Not worth the price for sure. I will not be getting the pizza again. Some people there got other food that looked ok but it's expensive. My pizza and drink came to over $35 bucks and that was before tip. Waitress was nice and efficient. Just not worth the price.
I would put 0 star if I could. I ordered 2 enolmatic bottle fillers on 12/15/21 for $578. It's been 17 months and i still haven't receive them or a refund. I call this theft. I talked to someone who never gives his name and he said multiple times he will send them and they will lose money because they are now more money to buy. Who's fault is that. He said he is really busy. Come on. He is such a liar. Well he told me last time they will be sent to me by 4/15/23. Of course another lie. If you want to talk to the biggest liar ever call 815-368-8313. If you deal with this winery and you called this number you know you are going to get screwed. Don't order anything online or spend a dime with these crooks.
My husband, daughter, and I went in for wine and pizza. We met the Owner Dave who was absolutely wonderful. The atmosphere was perfect and the staff and patrons were friendly and fun. We had wine tastings and a nice dinner, Dave interacted with us throughout our time there and personally did our tasting. Everything was excellent and the Chef was very nice. We bought 5 bottles of wine and can not wait to go back!