Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

75 Lake Ave, Hilton
(585) 392-5555

Recent Reviews

Bailey Pittman

Normally I don’t write reviews but the fellas working tonight were phenomenal and helpful. So glad we have a spot in town where the people actually care about the products and the customers. Thanks fellas & Salvatores ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Salvatore Strauss

Have tried multiple subs from there. Always terrible and seems the bread and toppings aren't fresh and thrown together.

James White

Pizza has gone from being decent to i would rather throw a frozen tonys pizza in the

Food: 2

Caryn A

It's ok pizza. There is no shortage of pizza choices in Hilton, and the only thing that makes this one stand out is the outdoor seating and beer.

Brent Knapp

Unfortunately this is another business that won’t make it in Hilton. I have been to many Salvatore locations and this by far is the worst. The first time I went, I ordered 2 subs on a Wednesday night. Myself and my girlfriend waited 45 minutes and then asked for an update on our order. We were told 5 more minutes. 20 minutes after that, I asked again. I was told that they didn’t even see my order. The girl at the desk proceeded to dig through the garbage to find it. She found it and then told me it should be ready in 20 minutes. An hour and a half we waited in the restaurant for only 2 subs. Cold subs by the way. Today, we tried again. Two subs, fries and pickle chips. Timing wasn’t bad. We ordered online this time. I called 30 minutes after ordering to verify that the food was ready. I was told 15 more minutes. No big deal, it’s a Friday night. I go to pick up the order and we are missing the pickle chips. Not fried pickles but pickle slices on the side for our subs. I was told that they don’t do that there and they could credit us the $2.00 in the next couple days. Really? You put pickles in a cup and take my $2.00, it can’t be much easier. I’m done with this location. The subs are ok but the management or lack of, is terrible and the employees need to be trained. I give it 1 more year max if the business stays run like this.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Joaunna Bixby

I ordered 4 subs and an order of fries and they charged me for all. However once I got my order home I discovered an entire sub was missing from my order. This isn’t the first time it’s happened to me from this place either. I think their $10 Thursday sub deals are excellent but when I have to go back because a sub is missing it kind of ruins the family dining together. Their staff definitely needs to pay attention to their job.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Fries

Tim Williams

Just ordered a Chicken Charlie pizza from the Hilton Location. Absolutely Amazing. A picture couldn't describe how perfectly baked it is .Great Job !!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Favorite Pizza

Samantha Schubbe

Whenever we call for orders the phone girl Alexus is so cheerful and nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Greg Blythe

Great daily specials, otherwise a bit on the expensive side. Tasy food, good

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheeseburger

Patrick Gillespie

Great pizza and a small area to eat inside, which I did. I will go back..

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Salad

Lisa Williams

The employees were very friendly. My food was given to me burnt so I called once I saw it and had a new sub delivered to me which was delivered for no charge which was a pleasant gesture. That new sub was burnt as well. I will never order from this location again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Erich Shipman

This place bussin, slaps so hard frfr on g no cap. In all honesty tho my btother past away earlyer this week an we wanted to honor him by getting cartering from his favoirt pizza place. They were closed bt this place was a pretty sick sub. Would eat again. Rip Jim.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Moc’s RC

Many times have we ordered for delivery and it is constantly late. People who answer the phones rarely know how to do anything and never know what's going on with the food until the ask someone. It seems like it's ran by teenagers. Writing this review after being to 35 to 45 minutes and now being told deliveries are taking 1.5 hours. Tonight was probably my last order from here which is unfortunate because salvatores is usually my favorite pizza place.

Food: 5

Service: 1

Elebration -

Pizza and Wings were slamming! I've been here a few times and they really stepped up their game. Wings were crispy, pizza was perfect, compliments to the cook!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Josephine D.

Awesome service and location with great food!! their outdoor patio and bar is very inviting. There is a giant outdoor connect four game that our family loves.

Load More

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

75 Lake Ave, Hilton, NY 14468
(585) 392-5555