Firehouse Bagels

1018 Waverly Ave, Holtsville
(631) 569-4693

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ang

Gas station bagels but somehow terrible coming from a bagel shop. Cheaply made mediocre taste and probably very cheaply mass produced.

Food: 1

John

Better bagels across the street. I wouldn't get sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Everything's Eventual

16.33 for 2 bagles w/ cc and bacon is absolutely wild. She asked twice my order, and still got it wrong. Never coming back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

matthew ostroy

Bought a "buttered roll" from a 7-11 from this bagel store. Very weird, NASTY MYSTERIOUS taste .Not doing it again. The photos of the store literally look like a garbage dump.

Jason

The bagels are look werid and they taste gross and taste like a gas station bagel

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

M Ricketts

Very dirty. Wish I got a picture of the flies crawling on the bagels. Very poor service with a bad attitude. This was definitely my last time going there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Naftalie Wischenka

It's ok place for good and fast breakfast

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Chris C

I guess they've started selling their bagels in gas stations and 7-11's now. I usually get a bagel with my coffee at sevs in the morning, and I noticed recently (within the last month or two, that I noticed anyway) that the packaging for the bagels looked different. I didn't really give it much more than a quick glance until I found the first hair on my bagel... long, black hair... I'm blonde and short haired. Ok, it happens, no big deal. Until I found one on a second bagel the next day, AT A DIFFERENT 7-11! This one was baked in, too. Like, seeds were popping off as I pulled the hair, it was under them. Gross, but maybe bad luck.... then I found another one today, a week after the last one... so that's 3 out of 8 bagels with long, black, nasty hairs in them. I'm done. No more firehouse bagels for me.

Food: 1

JucSITY BEATZ

I have had many bacon and eggs on a everything bagel... Good prices and fast service

Garry Fernando

Bagel here are the worst and when I mean WORST you better believe it I have seen lot dirty places and stale bagels but this place beaten all others record .they beaten so much that I jad to review it

Pratap Sehgal

Bagel here are the worst and when I mean WORST you better believe it I have seen lot dirty places and stale bagels but this place beaten all others record .they beaten so much that I jad to review it

Tejas Singh

My bagel was so good. It was enough to fill me up. The staff members were very kind. I had a salted bagel from this store and it was perfection. The diversity of the breakfast meal was amazing. I even found Japanese Cheetos! Overall, I had a great experience and would love to come back next time.

Eric

Don’t know how this place is still open. $22 for 3 egg sandwiches, nothing special. Supposed to come with small juice. Bagel was not that good. Expected small O.J with sandwich for $7 B.E.C handed me a kids juice box lol. Overpriced, owners must not be struggling though Tesla charging in the back.

Jon Colt

Just tried to go get a bagel place looks closed up for some time, might be closed permanently

Aiden White

Good bagels and really nice people love this place

Loading...