Holtsville’s Sports Deli

1029 Waverly Ave, Holtsville
(631) 289-8878

Recent Reviews

J McA

This place was my go to for years but they have become seriously dissapointing over the past few months. They over charged me and the side of bacon is a shadow of its former self. I remember when a side of bacon from here was heaping and served 3 people now your lucky if it serves 2! ... guess its time to find a new deli..

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Chancellor Heilstrom

portion bacon has gone down, and the prices have gone up. use to get a full container of bacon, and now it's half the size and price is more.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Jason Grzymalski

Excellent selection of quality foods.Sandwiches and Eggs all day!!! Great homemade iced tea and brownies. It is immediately obvious upon entering why they've been open so long. Quality and cleanliness are paramount to a successful food service business and they know it. Delis come and go,but this place is staying. Practically a historical landmark.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Egg and Cheese

Daniel Fritzlo

They actually use 2 slices of cheese on breakfast sandwiches, so there no need to order extra cheese.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg Cheese on an Everything Bagel, Egg and Cheese

Thomas

Great egg sandwiches. Friendly staff. Love hitting up this spot after an overnight!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

M. Sluzynski

A tad on the expensive side, but excellent omelets and iced coffee to start the day.

Allison Nelson

We ordered from sports deli for our party this past Saturday and OMG! We have been going to and referring everyone here because they never ever disappoint! We ordered 6ft chicken hero 3ft eggplant and a large tray of fried chicken that everyone was raving about, all the food was gone (chicken first) and was just so delicious. Highly recommend this deli for any catering!

Tommy Puglia

Great owners great service in our

Philip John Schafmayer

I can not say enough about this place right here! This was my everyday spot for years when I lived on Waverly! I make sure to visit every time that I'm down on the island. 10 out of 10! The egg sandwichs are to die for.

chris evans

Good sandwich and has a drive through pick up window if you order ahead

John Mule

Prices constantly change. They tried to charge me the price of a hero for a roll. Mismanaged. I would not recommend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joseph C.

Place is Trash. Food is Garbage. Hope they go out of business. Or stay open and just serve people who are vaccinated.

Christopher Gioe

These guys are great. Always helpful. Never any issues with food or catering. Highly recommend.

Marisa Fedele

Ordered Italian, Chicken, and Veggie heroes for my son’s first birthday party. I sent my sister to pick it up the day of along with the salads it came with. To add to the fact the food was fresh and delicious as well as fairly priced, we both were so impressed with how helpful and kind the staff is! My dad owned delis for about twenty years and he repeatedly complimented the food, especially the fact the salads were homemade. We will definitely be using them for any future events!

joe “jnjscoots” james

Great deli, very clean , owner does his part is very respectful . All of the workers are awesome and very nice . 10/10

Load More