Waverly Deli

1100 Waverly Ave #3, Holtsville
(631) 475-1616

Recent Reviews

Jim V

Its a shame, this was once one of the best delis around, new owners are complete hacks, charging premium prices for low quality junk, no boarshead, disgusting gas station quality food, STAY AWAY, and slow service, sad

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nicole Rosenberg

Insane customer service!! I asked them to prepare a last minute tray of wraps to be sent to a friend that just lost a family member. I chose them because of their location to the family and their other reviews. The owner went above and beyond to communicate and sent a wonderful presentation to the family. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wrap

Ruth J.

Excellent service. The food is a little too salty for me but delicious. The staff is very nice.

Grace Miles

Such nice staff and the food is excellent!Vegetarian options: Many vegatarian options with lots of accommodationsDietary restrictions: Healthy optionsParking: lots of parkingKid-friendliness: Staff is so nice to children

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wrap, Sausage Egg & Cheese, Honey Mustard Chicken, Melted Mozzarella on a Hero, Grilled Chicken, Hero, Sausage, Peppers and Onions, Antipasto Salad, Muffins, The Krista, Chipotle Charger, Bacon Egg & Cheese, Egg & Cheese, Hash Brown, Sandwich on a Roll, Chicken Cutlet, Bec

Giovanni Bonilla

I always have to go to Wavely Deli for breakfast on my way to work when I go out that way. There is nothing like a good sausage, BEC sandwich, or on a everything bagel. Love how soft the bagle is. Definitely go if you're headed that way for breakfast.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lia Z.

Went on a Sunday and there was only two people up front and seemed like they were scrambling around to get things done. It took a while for the food to come so I was expecting the food to be hot. One sandwich tasted off but we weren't 100 percent sure if we were right or not. Another sandwich was barely warm and the third sandwich was the chicken and waffle. The chicken was blazing hot and the waffle was ice cold. Like still frozen cold. We also got soup which tasted off but it wasn't warm so I thought maybe it was because it wasn't hot. I asked them to heat it up and it did taste better after that. I was three quarters of the way through it and I found a large metal shaving in the soup. The iced tea tasted very strange like it had gone bad and we had to get a different drink because it seemed off in color and taste. We got a dessert and it looked like someone had already taken a bite out of it. Thankfully we were able to switch it for a different one. They said it was cut that way but it looked like someone took two spoonfuls out of it.

Brian B.

AMAZING DELI! I stop in whenever I'm in the area. Great food, ambiance and staff. Thanks guys!

Alex Hirsch

Been going here many times over the past year. Always has great food.

Erin F.

One stop shop: freshly made deli sandwiches and breakfast items, a fully loaded self serve coffee bar, slushees are also available. Reminds me of a Handy Pantry or seven eleven with a mom and pop feel. You can get anything from car essentials, air fresheners to toilet paper. There's also seating available so that's super convenient if your stopping in on the job. I initially wanted a Sausalito sandwich no luck they didn't have so I asked for Boarshead Buffalo chicken. Disappointed when I got home it was just regular when I got home and it their deli dressing was more like some kind mayo mixture I wasn't expecting. My fault I should have asked before hand I thought it would be something like Italian or vinaigrette.

Tony C.

Worst deli around. Ordered a sausage egg and cheese, gave me bacon. Tried eating it and it tasted like literal air - how does a BEC taste like air?? Like truly, how did they manage to cover up the taste of bacon, egg, cheese, and a roll, with the taste of air? I don't know whether to be impressed or offended.Also the iced tea was - it was a crappy sweet tea. Iced tea = iced tea, sweet tea = sweet tea. At least it tasted better than air

Annmarie S.

Rehans dirty little mind decided to raise his prices again! It's also so wrong that on the boards posted by the register the prices are different then what they ring up as. Disgusting prices, he better hope he's not in there when I am next.

Jes Smith

Ordered here 2 times with ubereats and both times order was wrong. Just really frustrated ordering a simple egg sandwich with no cheese only to have it caked in cheese each time. Wont be making a 3rd attempt

Taha Saddique

Best deli in the Area. Everything organized well. Best tasting sandwich’s

Kimberly Anne

I used to order from this local deli a lot but I have not been happy recently. The online ordering feature is great. I paid two dollars for a hash brown patty which was given to me in pieces and full of oil. I wanted to start eating my breakfast sandwich while returning home but it was not cut which I’ve never seen a bagel sandwich not cut before. The bagel my sandwich was on was just OK. Prices are fair.

phocused 247

Only getting 3 stars because they make a good egg sandwich, but when a deli can't tell the difference between potato and macaroni salad, better off choosing from the thousands of other places on long island!

Load More