Sinfully Sweet

17 S Main St, Homer
(607) 543-4568

Recent Reviews

H MS

Absolutely delicious and very reasonably priced!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Morgan

Friendly staff and the best peanut butter cookies I’ve ever had!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Doug Benson

Over priced, limited choices, did not honor a promotion they had offered.

Mary Fisher

Amazing treats and kind employees. My favorite place to go!

Rachelle Walsh

Best peanut butter cookies around!

michelle doolittle

I would give 5 stars but I only bought a couple of things and they put it in a bag and to pay was requested a tip...guess I have tip fatigue unless it's true service. Treats were good. Also, I spent 22.74 on just a few single items.

SoundScience AR

Very sweet little place. It has a wonderful small town vibe in a very positive way. We sampled several baked goods. All of them were fresh and flavorful. Staff was wonderful and very welcoming. Will definitely stop by next time we are in the area. Turnovers were delightful.

Sandra Putnam

Quaint, delightful ambiance with staff that were a treasure! Delicious treats & drinks!

Dennis-Sharon Rhine Grimes

Wonderful service! A delicious chicken wrap! Great iced tea! Hillcrest Dairy chocolate milk (the best!)!! Samples of their excellent new dairy-free ice cream!! And their chocolate truffles?!? Oh, my, they are AMAZING!!!!! Thank you, ladies! What a delightful experience!

Sweet Pea

Inconsistent baked goods. Half moon cookie base was like a dry old biscuit. Some items are nice and fresh. Others are stale and old. Staff is nice.

Lisa Kreimeyer

Love all of the lunch sandwiches, soups and of course the sweets !!

Holly Manns

Your cheesecake is amazing! Adorable store with friendly & excellent service! Yesterday was the first time we went in there & we will be back for sure?

Ava G.

This is a wonderful little gem in Homer! Their brownies are generously sized and delicious! My absolute favorite is the peanut butter frosting brownie. I also tried a mint buttercream topped brownie. They have so many options. They also have coffee and you can ask for flavored creamer. There is an area to sit and chat as you enjoy your treats as well.

Karen E.

Great place. Delicious baked good. Love to get a coffee and a sweet treat. The staff are super nice and helpful!

Zachary Lang

Has a great selection of tasty treats! Wonderful little place, regular food and soups are great too!

Load More