Quick stop on our way through, got a turkey club and it was awesome. The sub rolls are amazing! Will definitely order from here again when visiting Honeye!
Anthony Legend
Hands down the best pizza I have ever hadThe crust is amazing love the
Top Shelf has been a staple for us for two years. Recently, their pizza has gone WAY downhill. The pizza dough seems different and less flavorful. The dough is too thin in the middle, too thick on the outside. The toppings look like they were thrown by the handful in the middle, contributing to a soggy center, and pieces that can't be picked up and eaten. We kept trying over the last few months, but in my book, this means three strikes, and you're out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
518lauriek
We were staying down the road at an AIRBNB for a weekend and were told to get pizza from top shelf it's the best in the area, which we were hoping was true. I ordered a large cheese, pepperoni and hot pepper pizza which was moderately priced., on Sept 23rd at 7:30 p.m. There was a girl cooking the pizza's and it smelled great when I walked into get my pizza. It was not ready so I of course waited. I asked for my crust to be well done. When it was ready she handed me the box which was pretty heavy. I got back to the house and we dove in as we were starved, we both like thin crust but I myself like the thicker crust as I like to dip it in Frank's hot sauce. The crust was super thick, it was golden brown but when my husband cut the crust closer to the outside edge the dough in the middle was still a bit wet and raw, big disappointment as it smelled so good when I walked in. The inner pat of the pizza was cooked enough as the crust was much thinner in towards the middle. I did not feel like driving all the way back and I did not call to complain as we are from out of town and if he had offered me a coupon to use at another time we live over 2 hours away. I ended up putting the pizza in the oven to finish baking the crust so it was edible. If the girl cooking wasn't sure if it was done, I would rather have it a bit over cooked than under cooked. I was so looking forward to trying it but what a bummer !!!! Make sure you ask for it well done, the subs and wings looked good though.
Darlene Alexander
This place has the best Buffalo pizza in the whole region... love it with the celery!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
barbara franklin
It looks like a hole in the wall. The staff is great as is the pizza!!! Huge slices and very cheap!!! Fresh and delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Carlin
They have the best slices. They're big, affordable, and have a wide range of options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carol Wittman
Ordered a pizza a couple of days ahead, and it was ready on time as promised. It was for a picnic lunch and everyone enjoyed it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
anne gleason
I love this place!!!! Great pizza!!! Don't listen to the bad coomants!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Shirley Hocking
Ordered for the 1st time today. Med with thin crust & 2 toppings. The flavor was good with plenty of all toppings. However, it seems that to make a "thin" crust they just pulled all the dough out to the sides, leaving an uncooked, very soft center - it just flopped & hung down when picked up - and lots of extra dough around the edge. Then they slid the hot, medium pizza into a small box - sliding the toppings all to one side & folding one side over on itself. I thought the box looked too small for a medium and I guess I really should have looked before leaving. When my husband went to take a slice out of the box, it just slid off the crust and onto the other pieces. He wouldn't eat it. I won't order pizza there again.
Food good, pricing good. Had to call 2x, someone picked up phone and hung it up. When I picked up, a worker was just standing in front of the counter blocking the table with napkins, etc. Place needs a little update, so does the parking lot (drive carefully).
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Gregg Sourbeck
Visiting the area and stopped in. Staff was very warm and personable. Pizza had great crisp and flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Les Gales
Great pizza and wings. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
sarah Chapin
They made me my favorite special garlic pizza absolutely perfect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Schaefer
Subs are packed full of meat, perfect rolls, nicely dressed - every time ?
Quick stop on our way through, got a turkey club and it was awesome. The sub rolls are amazing! Will definitely order from here again when visiting Honeye!
Hands down the best pizza I have ever hadThe crust is amazing love the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch, Mozzarella Sticks, Sauce, Buffalo Pizza, Onion Rings, Pepperoni Pizza, Sausage, Garlic Bread, Wings, Chicken Bacon, Steak Bomber
Top Shelf has been a staple for us for two years. Recently, their pizza has gone WAY downhill. The pizza dough seems different and less flavorful. The dough is too thin in the middle, too thick on the outside. The toppings look like they were thrown by the handful in the middle, contributing to a soggy center, and pieces that can't be picked up and eaten. We kept trying over the last few months, but in my book, this means three strikes, and you're out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
We were staying down the road at an AIRBNB for a weekend and were told to get pizza from top shelf it's the best in the area, which we were hoping was true. I ordered a large cheese, pepperoni and hot pepper pizza which was moderately priced., on Sept 23rd at 7:30 p.m. There was a girl cooking the pizza's and it smelled great when I walked into get my pizza. It was not ready so I of course waited. I asked for my crust to be well done. When it was ready she handed me the box which was pretty heavy. I got back to the house and we dove in as we were starved, we both like thin crust but I myself like the thicker crust as I like to dip it in Frank's hot sauce. The crust was super thick, it was golden brown but when my husband cut the crust closer to the outside edge the dough in the middle was still a bit wet and raw, big disappointment as it smelled so good when I walked in. The inner pat of the pizza was cooked enough as the crust was much thinner in towards the middle. I did not feel like driving all the way back and I did not call to complain as we are from out of town and if he had offered me a coupon to use at another time we live over 2 hours away. I ended up putting the pizza in the oven to finish baking the crust so it was edible. If the girl cooking wasn't sure if it was done, I would rather have it a bit over cooked than under cooked. I was so looking forward to trying it but what a bummer !!!! Make sure you ask for it well done, the subs and wings looked good though.
This place has the best Buffalo pizza in the whole region... love it with the celery!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It looks like a hole in the wall. The staff is great as is the pizza!!! Huge slices and very cheap!!! Fresh and delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have the best slices. They're big, affordable, and have a wide range of options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a pizza a couple of days ahead, and it was ready on time as promised. It was for a picnic lunch and everyone enjoyed it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this place!!!! Great pizza!!! Don't listen to the bad coomants!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Ordered for the 1st time today. Med with thin crust & 2 toppings. The flavor was good with plenty of all toppings. However, it seems that to make a "thin" crust they just pulled all the dough out to the sides, leaving an uncooked, very soft center - it just flopped & hung down when picked up - and lots of extra dough around the edge. Then they slid the hot, medium pizza into a small box - sliding the toppings all to one side & folding one side over on itself. I thought the box looked too small for a medium and I guess I really should have looked before leaving. When my husband went to take a slice out of the box, it just slid off the crust and onto the other pieces. He wouldn't eat it. I won't order pizza there again.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Food good, pricing good. Had to call 2x, someone picked up phone and hung it up. When I picked up, a worker was just standing in front of the counter blocking the table with napkins, etc. Place needs a little update, so does the parking lot (drive carefully).
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Visiting the area and stopped in. Staff was very warm and personable. Pizza had great crisp and flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and wings. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
They made me my favorite special garlic pizza absolutely perfect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Subs are packed full of meat, perfect rolls, nicely dressed - every time ?