Where to start…. The restaurant was not even a third full and we waited an hour and twenty mins for our food. During that time the waitress came up one time and asked if we wanted a refill. Once the food came it got worse. The chicken wings were just warm and rubbery. All three burgers were over cooked. All the sides were cold. I asked for med rare and got a burnt well done burger that was very dry. The fettuccine Alfredo Was so bitter. It tasted like sour milk. We had to take it up to the waitress who was at the bar talking because she did not come and check on us. She was very rude and said it’s just the lemon juice. I ordered their moose burger. It said it came with gravy. The waitress asked if I wanted it on my fries as well. I said sure. Then got a $1.25 charge for it. I was just confused as why they say it comes with it and then charge. Ultimately this was a really bad experience. I had been there before many years ago and it was much better. We will not be back any time soon.
LJ Metzger
We drove over an hour to try them out. I don't know if it was an off night or what, but service was very slow, everything was extremely salty, my beef tips were extremely tough with no flavor other than salty, an older waitress and older bartender spent over 20 minutes gossiping about some Drew and another waitress while beers sat empty, and everything was over priced. There was a young thin bartender girl that was very friendly and actually waited on people, but my cherry lime smash drink from her being off was either her being new with no one to help her or the bar's recipe being pretty bad. The beer selection, ranch, fries, were good. The moose track burger was okay, but bland and salty. We're in no rush to drive over an hour again and waste over an hour sitting and spend around $100 again on such a so so underwhelming experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Selena Falk
Place was really good! Food was amazing, best buffalo chicken wrap I’ve had! Damn good burger cooked straight to specifications. The pub pretzels are awesome! We were well taken care of! The family bathroom has an actual changing table and pad! Would 100 percent recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kenn Burdick
Their burger game is STRONG, one of the best burgers in Hornell. But today I had a hankering for a REUBEN, and my wife and I are soooo glad I did! The absolute BEST REUBEN either of us has ever had! It's not the deli corned beef you would get at most diners. It's juicy AND creamy, with a grilled seedless marble rye bread. Wayyy better than our expectations. So now we have a new favorite reuben spot!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blue Cheese Bacon Cheeseburger, Irish Gate Burger, Wednesday Night Burger Special
Rick Baker
Friendly staff, had a Dublin Gate Burger - very good burger with huge tater tots. Dirty Martini was an interesting drink as it had everything bagel on the rim with blue cheese stuffed olives.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tater Tots
Matthew Spoth
Delicious food at good prices with downstairs and upstairs seating
Parking: Across the street from a YMCA with a large parking lot
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramps
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Eldridge
Incredible late lunch on 8/21! Waitress was charming and attentive. The Irish Onion soup was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
BemorGuy
GREAT pub! Great burger choices and all of them delicious. The employees seem to genuinely enjoy working there. My only fault, we were there during the local Irish Festival, but I couldn't get an Irish ale.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
kate hannum
We were passing through town staying at the Best Western and asked for a recommendation for dinner. Chris told us that Paddy's Pub was a very good place to go and we are so happy we took his advice. Everything about the dinner, blackened shrimp Alfredo, Caesar salad, cottage cheese and the pinot noir were top notch. Our server Stephanie was a real gem. We have decided to make this our annual stop on our way up to Lake Sacandawga every summer. Thank you Paddy's Pub and thank you Stephanie.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Suave Sultan
The food was very tasty and the staff were very friendly. I ordered a beef on weck and it was amazing! It also seemed like a lot of locals also come here, so you know it’s good!
Parking: There’s a large lot behind the building with free parking.
I ordered a child's meal for my 2 year old grandson and it took 40 minutes for a grilled cheese and French fries and it was not that busy. Also I ordered a medium burger that came well done. And my drink from the bar tasted too sour.
Ann Tobias
We stopped in to have lunch. We moved out of the area so we have not been to Paddy's in a while. It was so good. I got a Jack Daniels burger and John got the cheese steak with the peppers. Everything was very good. The burger was cooked perfectly and had good flavor. It was nice to see how busy the place was for a weekday lunch.
Janie DeAngelis
Such a sweet, pretty little place. Clean. Family friendly. And the food was AMAZING!!!!!!!
Vegetarian options: They didn't have many but they were more than willing to accommodate my order sans meat. Our server/bartender was lovely and attentive. 10/10 this place is the cutest little "hole in the wall" I've been to in a very long time. And the tortilla chips are AWESOME
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sándwich & Tots
Denise Adderly
Great food. Food was always hot and delicious. Staff was wonderful and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish Fry
Cory&Jen Mills
We absolutely love this place!!! Amazing food and great service!!
Where to start…. The restaurant was not even a third full and we waited an hour and twenty mins for our food. During that time the waitress came up one time and asked if we wanted a refill. Once the food came it got worse. The chicken wings were just warm and rubbery. All three burgers were over cooked. All the sides were cold. I asked for med rare and got a burnt well done burger that was very dry. The fettuccine Alfredo Was so bitter. It tasted like sour milk. We had to take it up to the waitress who was at the bar talking because she did not come and check on us. She was very rude and said it’s just the lemon juice. I ordered their moose burger. It said it came with gravy. The waitress asked if I wanted it on my fries as well. I said sure. Then got a $1.25 charge for it. I was just confused as why they say it comes with it and then charge. Ultimately this was a really bad experience. I had been there before many years ago and it was much better. We will not be back any time soon.
We drove over an hour to try them out. I don't know if it was an off night or what, but service was very slow, everything was extremely salty, my beef tips were extremely tough with no flavor other than salty, an older waitress and older bartender spent over 20 minutes gossiping about some Drew and another waitress while beers sat empty, and everything was over priced. There was a young thin bartender girl that was very friendly and actually waited on people, but my cherry lime smash drink from her being off was either her being new with no one to help her or the bar's recipe being pretty bad.
The beer selection, ranch, fries, were good. The moose track burger was okay, but bland and salty.
We're in no rush to drive over an hour again and waste over an hour sitting and spend around $100 again on such a so so underwhelming experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Place was really good! Food was amazing, best buffalo chicken wrap I’ve had! Damn good burger cooked straight to specifications. The pub pretzels are awesome! We were well taken care of!
The family bathroom has an actual changing table and pad!
Would 100 percent recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their burger game is STRONG, one of the best burgers in Hornell. But today I had a hankering for a REUBEN, and my wife and I are soooo glad I did! The absolute BEST REUBEN either of us has ever had! It's not the deli corned beef you would get at most diners. It's juicy AND creamy, with a grilled seedless marble rye bread. Wayyy better than our expectations. So now we have a new favorite reuben spot!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blue Cheese Bacon Cheeseburger, Irish Gate Burger, Wednesday Night Burger Special
Friendly staff, had a Dublin Gate Burger - very good burger with huge tater tots. Dirty Martini was an interesting drink as it had everything bagel on the rim with blue cheese stuffed olives.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tater Tots
Delicious food at good prices with downstairs and upstairs seating
Parking: Across the street from a YMCA with a large parking lot
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramps
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible late lunch on 8/21! Waitress was charming and attentive. The Irish Onion soup was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
GREAT pub! Great burger choices and all of them delicious. The employees seem to genuinely enjoy working there. My only fault, we were there during the local Irish Festival, but I couldn't get an Irish ale.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were passing through town staying at the Best Western and asked for a recommendation for dinner. Chris told us that Paddy's Pub was a very good place to go and we are so happy we took his advice. Everything about the dinner, blackened shrimp Alfredo, Caesar salad, cottage cheese and the pinot noir were top notch. Our server Stephanie was a real gem. We have decided to make this our annual stop on our way up to Lake Sacandawga every summer. Thank you Paddy's Pub and thank you Stephanie.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was very tasty and the staff were very friendly. I ordered a beef on weck and it was amazing! It also seemed like a lot of locals also come here, so you know it’s good!
Parking: There’s a large lot behind the building with free parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered a child's meal for my 2 year old grandson and it took 40 minutes for a grilled cheese and French fries and it was not that busy. Also I ordered a medium burger that came well done. And my drink from the bar tasted too sour.
We stopped in to have lunch. We moved out of the area so we have not been to Paddy's in a while. It was so good. I got a Jack Daniels burger and John got the cheese steak with the peppers. Everything was very good. The burger was cooked perfectly and had good flavor. It was nice to see how busy the place was for a weekday lunch.
Such a sweet, pretty little place. Clean. Family friendly. And the food was AMAZING!!!!!!!
Vegetarian options: They didn't have many but they were more than willing to accommodate my order sans meat.
Our server/bartender was lovely and attentive. 10/10 this place is the cutest little "hole in the wall" I've been to in a very long time.
And the tortilla chips are AWESOME
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sándwich & Tots
Great food. Food was always hot and delicious. Staff was wonderful and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish Fry
We absolutely love this place!!! Amazing food and great service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...