La Nonna's Pizzeria

I never received a delivered pizza as piping hot as the one La Nonna delivered to us tonight. It was as if just came out of the oven. And it was absolutely delicious.

I just came home from there to eat (and write this review). I ordered a Buffalo chicken wrap and chicken cutlet slider, and it’s horrendous! I gave them 1 star for presentation in store, and for attending to me (decent service).

The “Buffalo” wrap is anything but Buffalo. It’s dry grilled chicken, with a sliver of tomato. It’s piping hot, so the wrap completely falls apart on the first bite. There’s zero kick or Buffalo on this and has no other flavor (chicken isn’t seasoned). I used *at least* 20 paper towels as I was eating standing up, because it would have fallen all over me had I not. Unless you plan on eating this with a fork and knife, and changing your clothes before dining…. Don’t order this wrap! Please. Thank god I didn’t plan on eating this in the car, as that’s 100% out of the question.

The slider… I have no opinion yet, as I’ve yet to bother. Worst $17 I’ve spent, and will never go back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Ordered a family deal two large pizza 12 garlic knots and a 2 litter for 42$ I was told over the phone had about 69$ in my account once I got there to tap pay for the food price was 47$ which was okay I figured taxes no big deal so I tap pay and the payment comes back declined canceled he says it’s on my bank end an I have to wait for the money tomorrow it happens all the time just pay again and I will receive the money tomorrow I only had 69$ in my account to feed my family till pay day tomorrow long story short I got no pizza the man guessing the owner had no remorse left with no food and no money to buy more food just the hope of wait till tomorrow for my money to go back into my account this is ridiculous and very unfair if your machine does this all the time maybe have a sign or have a better paying system where peoples money is not on hold till the next day because your system declined the transaction which had sufficient funds to process now my kids get no pizza and can’t even go out and order some where else because my money is now on hold pending

Good pizza tonight after a long wet trip to JFK and back.

Hands-down, the worst food I ever ate in my life

Everything I ordered literally had to go back and the people had the biggest attitude I ever seen. There was literally a pubic hair on my pizza. I paid $147 plus $30 tip. I took my family of six here and I would’ve got better pizza if I ordered Domino’s, I’m begging people not to go here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I had a personal pizza of the Baked Ziti Round Pie and it was delicious! The sauce is flavorful and the cheese pull was pretty good! I asked for utensils with my order but didn't receive them (this was a Grub Hub order), or the ice I asked for - but that's alright. Overall I'll definitely order here again, very good crust and decent quality ingredients.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie

Great pizza pies. Trust me I’m a foodie

The buffalo chicken pizza is different than most others and I find it enjoyable. Regular pizza is also good. Place gets very busy, no problems with service. Place is expensive but what isn’t?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Artichoke Spinach Pizza, Regular Slices, Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice, Pie

Ordered a pie with half onion and half olive and six garlic knots. The food was good but the price was insane. $34.02 for a single topping no meat pie and 6 knots. We won't be back unless we hit the lotto. Plenty of other pizzerias in the area.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

My go to pizzeria in the area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Specialty slices are great. Always

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Decent pizza spot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Ordered a delivery… food never came… we called the restaurant who insisted it was delivered and refused to refund our large order. The food was either delivered to the wrong address or never came, either way, pure incompetence on the restaurant who refused to stand by their service. Never again.

I ordered to specialty slices. The girl put them in the oven went to help someone else. Comes back to help my wife. Puts two slices of specialty pizza in the oven for her. Seemed to forget about my slices. Takes mine out at the same time as my wife's. They were burnt! She wrapped them up and gave them to me anyway.

Food: 1

Service: 1

One of the best pizza places on Long Island! The dough is delicious, and ingredients fresh and high quality. Service was attentive and wonderful. I’m a new customer and will be back many many times. Thank you to La Nonna’s!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5