Casa Mia

205 Main St, Hurleyville
(845) 434-8051

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gabriella Braga

Just ordered a chicken parm with a side of bolognese and received a whole entire PAN. God is good GOD IS GREATđŸ˜‚đŸ™đŸŒ two of the sweetest ladies working tonight as well, very welcoming and held the door for me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

anthony thomas duany

Italian sandwiches were good but no alcohol available

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Maxim Milo

Great place .

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Steve Balestrieri

Home Town feel and great food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

ANDREA AKDAS

Very large dishes. Food amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pam

Always wonderful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Natasha Rodriguez

Horrible service, I ordered buffalo wings and they gave my bbq wings and when I called they said they make their buffalo wings out of bbq sauce with a little bit of buffalo which is absolutely insane bc that is not at all the same as buffalo and they told me they could not switch them out bc “That’s what I asked for” spent $60 on crappy food. False advertisement!!!!

Mary Makovic

Very nice family place w great portions and great all around choice for Italian food and more.

Donna Lann

Ate there 3 days in a row while upstate visiting family. Had to get my NY Italian fix handled!! Casa Mia pasta dishes and pizza are amazing, should have brought home 10 to-go dishes of Rigatoni alla vodka!! My favorite! The host was amazing, really catered to us!! Will definitely be back by on out next trip up!! Thank you all so much!!!

SMOKEY

Strombolis are super good

Terence M. Perkins

The father/son duo are classy and warm-hearted....the father makes the best drinks and the son is a class act...like Dad

Danny G

Place has always been my favorite decor can use some upgrading but the food is out of this world excellent fresh and portions are huge better than any place in area

Darth Reign

Excellent food family style plates for most food I saw coming out everything looked really good and what we had was great my plate had a lot of scallops and shrimp. Veal Parmesan was really good to I recommend if your in the area

John Greenemeier (Jerseypilot83)

Completely rude people from the start! Walked in to pickup phone order and no one was around. I waited nearly 10 minutes. I eventually called the restaurant on the phone while I was there. Woman walked out and basically threw the order on the bar like she was irritated?! The total was $50! I was astonished at the price. Nearly double what I paid in the past at other Italian restaurants. They told me it was too late to change the order because it was already made. I know I could have walked out and not paid anything but I ended up paying because it was a cold night and was hungry. SOOO OVERPRICED and extremely shady establishment! Treating customers that way surely does NOT warrant return customers! I most def will NEVER GO HERE AGAIN! Just my 2 cents!

Maciek Bonar

Went for lunch, got two Margherita slices, garlic bread, and chocolate mousse slice.
Was charged double for pizza, and had to ask why I paid so much, my receipt wasn’t itemized, only had a total price.
Pizza was pretty oily. Garlic bread was barely toasted, felt soggy and tasted bland. Chocolate mousse was super sweet, all you could taste was sugar, I took two bites and threw it out. Only ate the pizza, but only because I had already taken insulin for it.
Don’t waste your time or money coming here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...