Shelly's Sweet Shoppe

624 Titus Ave, Irondequoit
(585) 467-9222

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amanda Vallet von Rathonyi

Shelly did a beautiful job on the cookie cakes I ordered! I’m a big fan of cookie cake, and this was the best I’ve ever had. Beautiful presentation and attention to detail as well. Thank you, Shelly!

Alyssa Cala

Shelly❤️❤️ She is a beautiful lady with an amazing personality! I have ordered through Shelly at least 10 times now! Her cookies are out of this world. The detail on the cut outs are immaculate. Her cupcakes are so tasty and everything is baked with love. The confetti cookies and red velvet cookies are my favorite treat ever!!!!

Ashley Bank

Everything was delicious and tasted fresh. 10/10 would recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maria Harris

Shelly helps make our holidays & special occasions end on a sweet note!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Sklenar

I have been getting sweets from Shelly’s for over a year now. The quality is always top notch. The atmosphere is warm, welcoming and clean. The service is great. I recommend SSS to anyone wanting/or needing a treat. You can’t go wrong!
Kim

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Winona Miller-Webb

I give a 2 srar for food being that I bought 2 frosted sugar cookies. The flavor of the cookies were excellent how ever the cookie was very thin and the frosting was thicker then the cookies. For that I would never return. I paid over 5.00 for them and was very disappointed with my purchase. I hope in the future you make your cookies thicker.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 4

Levi

So delicious I got a cookie cake for a birthday and it was rich and creamy.

Parking: Enough spots

Kid-friendliness: Amazing towards kids

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Levi Nagle

So delicious I got a cookie cake for a birthday and it was rich and creamy.

Parking: Enough spots

Kid-friendliness: Amazing towards kids

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

CHARLES WILCOX

Shelly is very accommodating and helpful. she helped us figure out the best option for our cookie tray to satisfy everyone from 5 yrs old to 73, so we were very happy we found her sweet shoppe and will be back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Leah Colon

The wife and i love coming to this place it’s always welcoming and all the sweets in this shop always taste fresh!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bar Cookies

Tessa Ryan

Shelly is always my go to for any baked goods! I have gone to her numerous times for larger work events and everything is always wonderful. She even fit me in for a last minute order, couldn't have been more grateful. Not only do the cupcakes taste amazing but they are decorated so nicely too! Thank you Shelly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes

Tyson

Shelly is amazing. Peanut butter bars with chocolate top layer are to die for.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christine Brockman

We ordered cupcakes and cookies for my daughter’s graduation party. I was setting up for the party and running all over. My ex husband notified someone at the business I’d be there right at close. I got there at 2:07. I was greeted by a miserable woman. I felt terrible and apologized. She said nothing. Gave me my cookies. When I returned back to get my cupcakes she was outside w them and handed them to me. I said thank you and apologized again. She said nothing at all to me. Just rudeness over being 7 minutes late. I know everyone has things to do. But this is a place of business who “should” pride themselves, I would think, on customer service. Although the baked goods are great, I will get them elsewhere for future parties.

Emily Bonsignore

I brought their key lime bars to a party and they were a huge hit! The shop even cut them into smaller pieces to make them shareable. Everyone was asking where they were from! Great baked goods and customer service!!!

Heather Horn

My daughter says "this was more good than anything!" The desserts we bought here were delicious. The owner was very sweet and made our experience fun!

Loading...