This is by far my most favorite ice cream shop. They're always very busy and it's for all the best reasons: food quality is amazing, portion sizes are ideal, service is very quick, and staff is very friendly and welcoming! There's a very large variety of menu choices! I recommend this location to anyone. I promise you, it'll be worth it
Macarty Plaza
Love this place
Emyth Brenn De Luney
Come back next year! It is delicious!
Mary Kowalik
Absolutely love this place! It's been around forever and the quality hasn't changed, it's delicious! 3 generations of my family have ate here. Prices are reasonable. Located close to the beach. Perfect way to end your day while there!
DARYL WILLIAM POST
Great staff great customer service better choices then any other ice cream place
Mary Crossley
Unique combinations on the traditional sundae line. Very good.
Dustin Long
If you go to Frosty Treat and leave unsatisfied, that is your fault! What makes it unique (besides the great prices) is all of the special choices they have. My wife and I love the "Buried Treasure". It's a tall cup with Reese's pieces at the bottom, complete with peanut butter sauce, ice cream, and hot fudge. There are healthier options with yogurt as well, and traditional choices like shakes and cones. There is something for everyone here! A WNY must-visit!
Ray Logan
Great place!! So many choices!! Something for everyone
Oleg S.
This was our first time at this ice cream place and we were pleasantly surprised by so many choices and great quality ice cream. Will definitely return.
Brenda Prigg
Best iceream! They are always nice, best ice ever.7/2023 the prices are always great. People are always super friendly and helpful. The best ice cream. I can't say enough about how good it is and how great the people are.
Always lots of choices for a nice treat. Our dog always has a pup cup with a milk bone in it.
James Gardner
A nice little ice cream stop. The prices are great! Plenty of options.
Don Moore
Best selection of specialty sundaes I have ever seen
Sharon K.
This family-owned walk-up ice cream stand is legendary for its creative sundaes and very reasonable prices.Cash only! "Form two lines" - but take time to consider the multitude of color images of their sundae creations displayed in the windows.Soft serve custard, hard scoop varieties, with vegan, no-sugar and non-dairy choices available, as well as creative Kiddie sundaes - and Pup Cups for canine friends. Sizes from 1 ounce Taste, to generous Small, through Bucket size. They'll combine any crumble, crunch, or topping you desire. Try their hot peanut butter sauce, a crowd pleaser.
The ogre
They make their stuff to look like the picture.....did not let us down! Hands down the best ice cream spot in the area
This is by far my most favorite ice cream shop. They're always very busy and it's for all the best reasons: food quality is amazing, portion sizes are ideal, service is very quick, and staff is very friendly and welcoming! There's a very large variety of menu choices! I recommend this location to anyone. I promise you, it'll be worth it
Love this place
Come back next year! It is delicious!
Absolutely love this place! It's been around forever and the quality hasn't changed, it's delicious! 3 generations of my family have ate here. Prices are reasonable. Located close to the beach. Perfect way to end your day while there!
Great staff great customer service better choices then any other ice cream place
Unique combinations on the traditional sundae line. Very good.
If you go to Frosty Treat and leave unsatisfied, that is your fault! What makes it unique (besides the great prices) is all of the special choices they have. My wife and I love the "Buried Treasure". It's a tall cup with Reese's pieces at the bottom, complete with peanut butter sauce, ice cream, and hot fudge. There are healthier options with yogurt as well, and traditional choices like shakes and cones. There is something for everyone here! A WNY must-visit!
Great place!! So many choices!! Something for everyone
This was our first time at this ice cream place and we were pleasantly surprised by so many choices and great quality ice cream. Will definitely return.
Best iceream! They are always nice, best ice ever.7/2023 the prices are always great. People are always super friendly and helpful. The best ice cream. I can't say enough about how good it is and how great the people are.
Restaurantji Recommends
Always lots of choices for a nice treat. Our dog always has a pup cup with a milk bone in it.
A nice little ice cream stop. The prices are great! Plenty of options.
Best selection of specialty sundaes I have ever seen
This family-owned walk-up ice cream stand is legendary for its creative sundaes and very reasonable prices.Cash only! "Form two lines" - but take time to consider the multitude of color images of their sundae creations displayed in the windows.Soft serve custard, hard scoop varieties, with vegan, no-sugar and non-dairy choices available, as well as creative Kiddie sundaes - and Pup Cups for canine friends. Sizes from 1 ounce Taste, to generous Small, through Bucket size. They'll combine any crumble, crunch, or topping you desire. Try their hot peanut butter sauce, a crowd pleaser.
They make their stuff to look like the picture.....did not let us down! Hands down the best ice cream spot in the area