Carleton Avenue Deli

64 Carleton Ave # E, Islip Terrace
(631) 581-0444

Recent Reviews

Felix Garcia

Thumbs

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael S.

I had a case around the corner at the 1st District Court in C.I. and had to wait for 2nd call. I stopped in here for lunch. I ordered a boring bacon egg and cheese sandwich. While I was waiting I was reading over all the specialty sandwiches they make, and I wish I would've done so before I ordered. Everything sounded amazing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Michael Scaringe

I had a case around the corner at the 1st District Court in C.I. and had to wait for 2nd call. I stopped in here for lunch. I ordered a boring bacon egg and cheese sandwich. While I was waiting I was reading over all the specialty sandwiches they make, and I wish I would've done so before I ordered. Everything sounded amazing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Ashley

Never

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Leah Besserman

They catered a party for my community. We ordered quite a few 6' subs. Everything was included in the price (salads, condiments and all paper goods). The food was delicious and we will use them again.

Thomas Halpin

Good food and they try to make it even better for you. Worth the visit, good people work there

Tri Z.

My favorite deli !! The menu is extensive and everything on it is delicious! I'm a fan of their egg sandwiches and the Ruben. The owners, Bob & John, along w the entire crew are friendly and the service is excellent!! Looking forward to my next visit to this Class A deli !

Nikole Waring

Non of the employees in back wear gloves. There is cross contamination everywhere. I was very disappointed to see this.

Joseph Cappellino

The catering is top notch at a fair price. We have used them several times without any issues.I come in several times a week. The staff is amazing, and the egg sandwiches are awesome. Also, this is the only place we get potato salad.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gina Goldberg

Some great food here! Always fresh and the staff is always friendly.

Krissy S

We had catering for a Funeral and all the food and service was wonderful. Thank you!

Mikey ponyboy2992

I've been going, to this deli since I was a kid .there customer service is amazing, all there products are fresh daily .they do not play around .

Lori Cooper

Excellent food and lovely service, can’t recommend enough!!

mikayla5230

this is one of the best delis on long island. I have never been disappointed in the food quality and the service here. The prices were on point and the workers made me feel so welcomes. 10/10 would recommend for everyone of all ages.

Jules R

Went here for 1st time last week and still aggravated I wasted $ there. Really annoyed I was lied to when I asked specifically before ordering if the tomato soup was actually made there or if it was just "Campbells" soup because some delis actually just serve that (gross.) The guy working there said he was "sure" it was homemade soup. I also ordered a "grilled chicken" wrap. When I got home I opened up a pint of Campbell's soup - ughhh!! What made it even worse was the "grilled chicken" wrap was sliced deli meat - NOT grilled chicken. What kind of a deli doesn't even have grilled chicken for their sandwiches??? I'd never go back to this place - ever. Way too many other better delis and places to eat.

Load More