Americano Pie Bar

517 Main St, Islip
(631) 581-8700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kristen LoCascio

We didn’t end up eating here because they didn’t have a mocktail menu to accommodate those who don’t drink. Cancelled our reservation and moved next door because they had a mocktail list with alcohol free spirits. A good suggestion for the bar manager!

Killah K

Delicious! The chicken Ceasar sandwich didnt disappoint. It comes on a folded pizza crust and the dressing was amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris H

Always delicious !! Erin at the bar is what everyone bartender should be!! 👏👏

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Big Mac Pizza

ian larson

Exceptional food from appetizers to main meals. Drinks were also very good. Our waitress Maya was very polite and helpful to all our needs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marlene Vergara

Had a great experience today, the bartenders were phenomenal even the kid helping them was very attentive to us.
We were surprised how fast our food was ready for how busy it was, definitely coming back here!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy Brzostek

Probably the worst experience I've ever had for take out pizza. Ordered a regular cheese pie online and got there to pick up 20 minutes later. Got in the car and opened the box to eat a hot slice, but this pie looked like it was sitting out for at least 35 minutes. It was cold. I should have just brought it back in.

Food: 1

Service: 3

Glenn Sinatra

It was good. Not great. A little disappointed after all the hype. Service was slow. Waits staff, while friendly, seemed overwhelmed. 20 minutes for drinks to arrive is unacceptable. One pasta dish which was requested with extra sauce was dry. Pizza selections were different and intriguing but were just ok. Great atmosphere and beautiful decor. Went in expecting a wow experience and it just wasn’t.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 2

Caren Jacobs

What a hidden gem. Great food - the portions are huge - the prices are reasonable compared to other restaurants and they have the nicest staff you ‘ll ever meet - Mia and Andrew’s are top notch! Don’t walk, run to this place! You won’t be disappointed!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

tom jif

I had the best experience at this place. Heather was an amazing waitress, she gave us great recommendations. The strawberry limoncello, the hot honey pizza, and the oreo cheesecake were great. Thank you to heather for being a great server and helping us choose our meals. Overall amazing experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Debra Rodriguez

Everything good but place waa freezing and chefs cook witjh far too much salt got pressure headache afterwards. Otherwise would go nack if took that into consideration

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kylie McNamara (Festival Freaks)

I went here with a group of girlfriends and it was a very nice venue. The waiter was very nice. The service a little slow.

The food was very nice. I had the Fillet Mignon Rigatoni and the steak was delicious. Perfectly cooked !

The calamari and fried mozzarella were delicious. All the meals impressed my friends. Cocktails were divine.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Christina

I was very excited to bring my boyfriend here because it was our first date night in a month and because my family and I have been here multiple times before and we love the food and atmosphere. We walked in today (8/1) around 7pm and there was one hostess at the stand (a young blonde girl). She was sitting very unprofessionally, with her knees up against the stand and looking down. She did not acknowledge us so we initiated by requesting a table for 2. She asked if we had a reservation which we did not so she said she would get back to us about the wait once the other hostess returned to the stand. Shortly after, 2 gentlemen walked in and also requested a table for two. The same hostess asked if they had a reservation to which they also replied no. As we were waiting by the stand, another employee came by and spoke to the 2 gentleman who came in after us and proceeded to sit them down immediately. That’s when we realized she was the other hostess and that the young blonde hostess did not speak to her about which pair was there first. Once the second hostess returned after sitting the two gentleman, I spoke up to both of them about the situation. The other hostess said she was not aware (which is true) and that it would be a long wait for a table, and the young blonde hostess just shrugged us off, mumbled something and proceeded to not show any regret or solution other than waiting for the next available table. That’s what really aggravated us because we were there first and now suddenly had to wait a while to be seated. That’s when my boyfriend and I made the decision to walk out of the restaurant. My boyfriend and I are very patient people and would have had no problem waiting, however, given that we were completely overlooked and the blonde hostess did not apologize or do anything to fix the situation, we felt very disrespected and I’m very disappointed.

Shauna S

3rd time ordering food here. Dine in was superb. Take-out was just as good. It came earlier than expected and the food was good and hot! I really do enjoy the food here!
I do wish theyd bring back the halibut!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Bates

Excellent pizza. Why when u order take out pizza do they charge a delivery cg and the driver doesn't get it but I always tip him. Every time I call to question the girls that answer the phone have absolutely no clue what I am talking about

Food: 1

Robert Schaefer

Great place to pull up to the bar and have some Apps and drinks with my wife and sister

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...