We just left a few minutes ago and all I have to say is they handled something with kid gloves and class. My 12 year old and I went out for some guy time. Food was excellent!
Meg Comparato
Best pizza in town! Love this place! Get the lunchbox special you won’t be sorry!
Andrew Giancontieri
A great pizza place love it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ivan Avalos
Angela’s pizzeria by far best pizzeria in islip! The staff is very nice and friendly. The owner Vinny is also very nice. Check them out and their specialty slices and try my favorite slice the angry Italian: Mozzarella sticks,pepperoni,vodka sauce, hot honey on a garlic knot crust! Insanely good. Great Prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Theresa Walton
This is my second time coming here. The food was delicious. My family enjoyed it And so did my coworkers. Great atmosphere The employees are pleasant and always smiling. I’ll definitely be back for third time😊😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
luis arevalo
The best pizza in town 🤩😋
C Carl
Amazing food and great service and special shout out to a amazing person Vinny
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pranita Veeria
Food is delicious!! They have a variety of pizza. The Garlic knots are the best!! So soft and full of flavor! You have to try their lunch special which is a slice of pizza a side salad a side pasta everyday before 4pm for $10 can’t go wrong with that!! They also do Catering! Check them out you won’t be disappointed. They got the best deals ever!! I travel from Queens just to get a slice and some knots worth the trip. Enjoy you won’t be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luke Brass
Amazing customer service and atmosphere, workers are super down to earth and personable, and the food is fantastic.
So I order a sausage roll from them and he said ok I can make it for I , I got the roll the dough was undercooked there two pieces of sausage in this and he had the nerve to say Oo when u order it fresh that's how it comes . But if u want it done over I'll do it . Like no u didn't cook it all the way so it's not because I ordered it fresh smh
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
Becki Saxton
Awesome food n service Visited from Texas and love the ambiance Nothing like real NY pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jhoseph Beauty Salon
I love, definitely, the real Italian pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Blanco
Very good pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael S
I'm here now at Angelas to load up for the week and pickup pizza for a friend. If I'm lucky I can get here once every 2 months. Not being a local, coming to Angelas is a major treat, as I consider them to have the best pizza in NY. That's a big statement, but amazingly it's very true. There are great pizzerias in NY with amazing food, but Angelas is a 10 to be sure.
A regular plain slice is done to perfection, as is the Sicilian - or square. That's all I need. Good layer of cheese, very flavorful sauce, and a dense, big slice makes it a triple play on all counts. No complaints here. The Sicilian is perfect. Very dense and satisfying. It reheats and toasts well even after days in the fridge, just try it out. One truly gets their money's worth at Angelas, which today is difficult as some places are giving out Dorito sized slices with a spray paint of cheese.
There is quite a variety of pizza, which is difficult for me to sample as the regular slices are so good, but what I did try was excellent. Garlic knots are really good so I've heard. The variety looks like various chicken, pasta, marinara, grandma, and other slices which are very creative.
When you see the store from the outside, you know it's gonna be one of those neighborhood local go-to spots everyone knows about. The inside is small, and can get crowded, which happens alot.
Being a picky eater - no beef, fish, pork, etc, I'm reduced to few options, of which pizza is one. For this reason, I get around and haunt alot of pizzerias in NY and see who's got the best. Angelas is #1 on top in my humble opinion with a very satisfying pizza experience to be sure!
So I had two cheese slices that were so satisfying I'm buying more to take home! Sicilian as well no doubt. Very enjoyable when you realize just how much better a pizzeria can be than the rest. You have to take advantage of that!
The best pizza in Islip and maybe the Long Island
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just left a few minutes ago and all I have to say is they handled something with kid gloves and class. My 12 year old and I went out for some guy time. Food was excellent!
Best pizza in town! Love this place! Get the lunchbox special you won’t be sorry!
A great pizza place love it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela’s pizzeria by far best pizzeria in islip! The staff is very nice and friendly. The owner Vinny is also very nice. Check them out and their specialty slices and try my favorite slice the angry Italian: Mozzarella sticks,pepperoni,vodka sauce, hot honey on a garlic knot crust! Insanely good. Great Prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my second time coming here. The food was delicious. My family enjoyed it And so did my coworkers. Great atmosphere The employees are pleasant and always smiling. I’ll definitely be back for third time😊😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza in town 🤩😋
Amazing food and great service and special shout out to a amazing person Vinny
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is delicious!! They have a variety of pizza. The Garlic knots are the best!! So soft and full of flavor! You have to try their lunch special which is a slice of pizza a side salad a side pasta everyday before 4pm for $10 can’t go wrong with that!! They also do Catering! Check them out you won’t be disappointed. They got the best deals ever!! I travel from Queens just to get a slice and some knots worth the trip. Enjoy you won’t be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing customer service and atmosphere, workers are super down to earth and personable, and the food is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
So I order a sausage roll from them and he said ok I can make it for I , I got the roll the dough was undercooked there two pieces of sausage in this and he had the nerve to say Oo when u order it fresh that's how it comes . But if u want it done over I'll do it . Like no u didn't cook it all the way so it's not because I ordered it fresh smh
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
Awesome food n service
Visited from Texas and love the ambiance
Nothing like real NY pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love, definitely, the real Italian pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm here now at Angelas to load up for the week and pickup pizza for a friend. If I'm lucky I can get here once every 2 months. Not being a local, coming to Angelas is a major treat, as I consider them to have the best pizza in NY. That's a big statement, but amazingly it's very true. There are great pizzerias in NY with amazing food, but Angelas is a 10 to be sure.
A regular plain slice is done to perfection, as is the Sicilian - or square. That's all I need. Good layer of cheese, very flavorful sauce, and a dense, big slice makes it a triple play on all counts. No complaints here. The Sicilian is perfect. Very dense and satisfying. It reheats and toasts well even after days in the fridge, just try it out. One truly gets their money's worth at Angelas, which today is difficult as some places are giving out Dorito sized slices with a spray paint of cheese.
There is quite a variety of pizza, which is difficult for me to sample as the regular slices are so good, but what I did try was excellent. Garlic knots are really good so I've heard. The variety looks like various chicken, pasta, marinara, grandma, and other slices which are very creative.
When you see the store from the outside, you know it's gonna be one of those neighborhood local go-to spots everyone knows about. The inside is small, and can get crowded, which happens alot.
Being a picky eater - no beef, fish, pork, etc, I'm reduced to few options, of which pizza is one. For this reason, I get around and haunt alot of pizzerias in NY and see who's got the best. Angelas is #1 on top in my humble opinion with a very satisfying pizza experience to be sure!
So I had two cheese slices that were so satisfying I'm buying more to take home! Sicilian as well no doubt. Very enjoyable when you realize just how much better a pizzeria can be than the rest. You have to take advantage of that!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...