Celebrated my daughter’s bridal shower at Bayberry. Truly a fantastic experience from beginning to end. The Event Planner, Melissa, is an absolute treasure, she’s professional, offered great ideas for party menu and decorations, accommodated special dietary needs for guests, she took care of everything!! The event space is gorgeous, it’s definitely a vibe. Party guests were complimenting the food, the extremely attentive staff, the beautiful atmosphere and mentioned they were adding the restaurant to their favorites list!! Truly can’t say enough good things! Side note, definitely try the lobster rolls!
Sandra Quackenbush
Loved, loved, loved everything! Food is so delicious. Exceeded our expectations! Thank you to the amazing Chef and staff! We had a wonderful Father's Day dinner.
Melanie Zeltmann
Kaylie was great and super friendly! Had a great time and the food was fantastic!
Alex Creamer
We recently held our baby shower at the Bayberry in Islip on June 7th, and we couldn’t have been happier with the experience! From start to finish, everything was phenomenal. Our party coordinator, Melissa, was absolutely amazing. She made sure every detail was perfect and went over all aspects of the party setup to ensure a smooth event. Melissa was always available to answer our questions promptly and was so courteous throughout the process.
The food at the buffet was exceptional—several of our family and friends commented that it was the best food they had ever had at an event. The bartending and wait staff also went above and beyond, making sure every guest was taken care of with professionalism and kindness.
If you are planning a baby shower, bridal shower, or any other special event, we cannot recommend the Bayberry enough. Their outstanding service and attention to detail truly made our day unforgettable. Thank you to the entire team at the Bayberry!
David S
All round wonderful place ever thing was great.
patrick white
Kim was amazing! I think we found our new date night place.
Lucia Gomes-Abreu
Great vibe, delicious cocktails and wide variety of apps , salads and entrees on the menu!
Maureen Earley
firs time here. food was good a little pricey, but a woman that worked there was talking very inappropriately to one of the workers. It seemed like she was the manager, but I her language was very inappropriate for my dining experience. I will not be coming back here.
Kathryn Patricia
When it came to choosing a venue for our wedding celebration, we were looking for a fun, laid-back space with amazing food/cocktails. Bayberry was the perfect choice for us. From the start, Melissa made the planning process seamless and genuinely enjoyable. The entire staff was beyond attentive, and our guests raved about the food (mini lobster rolls 🙌🙌). Thanks Bayberry for the best day 🩵🩵
Marcy S
I recently went to The Bayberry for the first time. I came in the back entrance and didn’t realize there was a whole other side. My first impression was it was beautiful and immaculate. We hade the lunch specials My goat cheese salad was delicious and my burger was cooked perfectly. Even the fires were just right. Our server Kayla was friendly and on point. Ashley was also incredibly helpful. I would recommend this place to everyone and look forward to returning soon. It was also nice that there is an outside area available.
This was our first time at Bayberry in Islip, and we had our Thanksgiving Day dinner there this evening. The buffet was FABULOUS! There were plenty of choices for the whole family…and not too many that made what to choose overwhelming. Wait staff were very attentive and always seem to appear exactly when needed—otherwise they seem to be hiding in shadows. Also, parking was easy and the atmosphere was spectacular. I don’t think our Thanksgiving Day dinner could have been any better! Thank you to the Bayberry manager, Laura and the amazing staff! We will definitely go back for a regular evening.
Theresa Kosiner
I just had my daughter's baby shower at Bayberry. A truly wonderful experience! The staff were very helpful, friendly and attentive. Food was A+! Everyone commented on how delicious the brunch was. Melissa kept us on target for dates and quickly responded to any emails. Do not hesitate to book your next event at Bayberry. You will not be disappointed. You and your guests will be extremely happy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Dunlop
Excellent menu, nice atmosphere. Would go back again.
Christina & Matthew L
Atmosphere & service was excellent but the food was overpriced & tiny portions & honestly wasn’t that good.
Celebrated my daughter’s bridal shower at Bayberry. Truly a fantastic experience from beginning to end. The Event Planner, Melissa, is an absolute treasure, she’s professional, offered great ideas for party menu and decorations, accommodated special dietary needs for guests, she took care of everything!! The event space is gorgeous, it’s definitely a vibe. Party guests were complimenting the food, the extremely attentive staff, the beautiful atmosphere and mentioned they were adding the restaurant to their favorites list!! Truly can’t say enough good things!
Side note, definitely try the lobster rolls!
Loved, loved, loved everything!
Food is so delicious. Exceeded our expectations! Thank you to the amazing Chef and staff! We had a wonderful Father's Day dinner.
Kaylie was great and super friendly! Had a great time and the food was fantastic!
We recently held our baby shower at the Bayberry in Islip on June 7th, and we couldn’t have been happier with the experience! From start to finish, everything was phenomenal. Our party coordinator, Melissa, was absolutely amazing. She made sure every detail was perfect and went over all aspects of the party setup to ensure a smooth event. Melissa was always available to answer our questions promptly and was so courteous throughout the process.
The food at the buffet was exceptional—several of our family and friends commented that it was the best food they had ever had at an event. The bartending and wait staff also went above and beyond, making sure every guest was taken care of with professionalism and kindness.
If you are planning a baby shower, bridal shower, or any other special event, we cannot recommend the Bayberry enough. Their outstanding service and attention to detail truly made our day unforgettable. Thank you to the entire team at the Bayberry!
All round wonderful place ever thing was great.
Kim was amazing! I think we found our new date night place.
Great vibe, delicious cocktails and wide variety of apps , salads and entrees on the menu!
firs time here. food was good a little pricey, but a woman that worked there was talking very inappropriately to one of the workers. It seemed like she was the manager, but I her language was very inappropriate for my dining experience. I will not be coming back here.
When it came to choosing a venue for our wedding celebration, we were looking for a fun, laid-back space with amazing food/cocktails. Bayberry was the perfect choice for us. From the start, Melissa made the planning process seamless and genuinely enjoyable. The entire staff was beyond attentive, and our guests raved about the food (mini lobster rolls 🙌🙌). Thanks Bayberry for the best day 🩵🩵
I recently went to The Bayberry for the first time. I came in the back entrance and didn’t realize there was a whole other side. My first impression was it was beautiful and immaculate. We hade the lunch specials My goat cheese salad was delicious and my burger was cooked perfectly. Even the fires were just right. Our server Kayla was friendly and on point. Ashley was also incredibly helpful. I would recommend this place to everyone and look forward to returning soon. It was also nice that there is an outside area available.
Restaurantji Recommends
great staff. great food. great cocktails!
This was our first time at Bayberry in Islip, and we had our Thanksgiving Day dinner there this evening. The buffet was FABULOUS! There were plenty of choices for the whole family…and not too many that made what to choose overwhelming. Wait staff were very attentive and always seem to appear exactly when needed—otherwise they seem to be hiding in shadows. Also, parking was easy and the atmosphere was spectacular. I don’t think our Thanksgiving Day dinner could have been any better! Thank you to the Bayberry manager, Laura and the amazing staff! We will definitely go back for a regular evening.
I just had my daughter's baby shower at Bayberry. A truly wonderful experience! The staff were very helpful, friendly and attentive. Food was A+! Everyone commented on how delicious the brunch was. Melissa kept us on target for dates and quickly responded to any emails.
Do not hesitate to book your next event at Bayberry. You will not be disappointed. You and your guests will be extremely happy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent menu, nice atmosphere. Would go back again.
Atmosphere & service was excellent but the food was overpriced & tiny portions & honestly wasn’t that good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Loading...