It was our first time here since it was rebranded as “Bayberry”. I came for Happy Hour with my husband and bestie. Great drink and food specials! Attentive bartender, Mike, who gave off great vibes and gave great service! We will def be back :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin King
We just had our baby shower here and it was absolutely perfect. Everyone raved about the amazing food and service. The staff was so kind and handled the event so perfectly. Melissa the event coordinator was so helpful through the process communicating with us leading up to the event. Highly recommend Bayberry for your next event or even for a meal. Beautiful place and amazing staff! They truly made my shower so special
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sanah Aaliya
Espresso martini is awesome!!! They add rumchata instead of baileys. Went for brunch - Salmon board is to die for. Stuffed French toast...chefs kiss. Staff is 10/10. Super aesthetic, great vibes.
The manager Laura, was extremely accommodating to me and my family when planning my parents surprise anniversary dinner. I had to change the date multiple times and Laura was patient and kind with rescheduling. I can tell that she truly cares about providing her customers with a stress free and memorable dining experience. I will be planning more celebrations with her in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gale scaglia
Recently had a brunch for 30 people and everyone raved about their French toast and chicken and waffles. My favorite, Croissants were on each tabletop before the main dish was served and absolutely delicious We had the best server Brittany and our event coordinator Melissa was very helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carmela Palmeri
Over a month I grabbed drinks with my girlfriends, I witnessed the manager get really drunk at the bar and getting really loud. I have to say it was very uncomfortable and not sure if I’ll come back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Helena Taylorenko
This place is very beautiful with great atmosphere and very tasty food. Reasonably priced! Will definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimiko
Had a decent meal during LI restaurant week here. There was just too much salad!!!We ordered salads for our appetizers thinking the mains would be not salad based ? but yet our mains came and it had the protein as the background - the second salad was very present! I got the chicken which I should not have done bc it was quite dry, not what I was hoping for ?The ambiance was nice and the lights + decor were very pretty. Other than that the food was subpar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ruben Friedman
We ordered pasta for an appetizer and it came with an unwanted long hair. The last time (perhaps the summer) an ant came walking out of my wife's salad. My wife ordered mussels and she had to ask for a small fork. We will not be going back to Bayberry; we are grossed out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Spring Pea Angliotti, Prime Rib French Dip, Affagato
My fiancé and I had our engagement party at Bayberry this past Saturday and it was truly a memorable experience. Everything was AMAZING! Melissa, the Catering Sales Manager, was very responsive throughout the entire planning process and worked with us to deliver everything we asked for. Brittany, Ashley, and Gianna who worked the party were SO attentive, friendly, and truly took care of everything - they really allowed us to relax and enjoy our guests/experience. The party ran so smoothly.We have been told non-stop how GREAT the food was (specifically the sliders and the Bayberry Chicken were a huge hit). Guests were also really impressed with the atmosphere and renovations. We felt the space accommodated our guest count of 50 people perfectly and allowed for a cohesive flow.We will always remember our time spent at Bayberry and will be recommending the restaurant to friends/family in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda N.
My fiancé and I had our engagement party at Bayberry this past Saturday and it was truly a memorable experience. Everything was AMAZING! Melissa, the Catering Sales Manager, was very responsive throughout the entire planning process and worked with us to deliver everything we asked for. Brittany, Ashley, and Gianna who worked the party were SO attentive, friendly, and truly took care of everything - they really allowed us to relax and enjoy our guests/experience. The party ran so smoothly. We have bee told non-stop how GREAT the food was (specifically the sliders and the Bayberry Chicken were a huge hit). Guests were also really impressed with the atmosphere and renovations. We felt the space accommodated our guest count of 50 people perfectly and allowed for a cohesive flow. We will always remember our time spent at Bayberry and will be recommending the restaurant to friends/family in the future.
Joe T.
Visited here for the first time since it was renovated. Ambiance is much brighter, seating more comfortable and the noise level was fine for conversation. We shared the spinach and artichoke dip. I had the faroe island salmon: excellent and cooked to perfection. Wife had the prime rib French dip which she loved as well. Service was friendly and prompt on all counts. Already making plans to return with some guests.
Heidi Santjer
I'm am islip girl born and raised.Someone invited me to your restaurant.Laura was our bartender / host.She took the raise as soon as I told her this was my home town. She immediately welcomed me home and showed me what a classy upscale islip I was coming back to. Bravo Laura!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Wide Horizons Travel, LLC
You are missing something special if you haven’t discovered Bayberry. My spouse and I enjoyed brunch on a recent Saturday; what a great experience! Our server was very friendly and attentive, remembering my choice of sugar when she brought me a 2nd cup of coffee. My lemon blueberry Dutch baby pancake melted in my mouth with just the right combination of lemony sweetness and my spouse loved the vegetable frittata. The brunch drinks looked yummy, too. Creative and diverse menu, family friendly, and delicious food. Loved it!
It was our first time here since it was rebranded as “Bayberry”. I came for Happy Hour with my husband and bestie. Great drink and food specials! Attentive bartender, Mike, who gave off great vibes and gave great service! We will def be back :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just had our baby shower here and it was absolutely perfect. Everyone raved about the amazing food and service. The staff was so kind and handled the event so perfectly. Melissa the event coordinator was so helpful through the process communicating with us leading up to the event. Highly recommend Bayberry for your next event or even for a meal. Beautiful place and amazing staff! They truly made my shower so special
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Espresso martini is awesome!!! They add rumchata instead of baileys. Went for brunch - Salmon board is to die for. Stuffed French toast...chefs kiss. Staff is 10/10. Super aesthetic, great vibes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Poke Tuna Tacos, Crispy Oysters Rockefeller, Eggs Benedict
Great place for drinks and apps!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The manager Laura, was extremely accommodating to me and my family when planning my parents surprise anniversary dinner. I had to change the date multiple times and Laura was patient and kind with rescheduling. I can tell that she truly cares about providing her customers with a stress free and memorable dining experience. I will be planning more celebrations with her in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recently had a brunch for 30 people and everyone raved about their French toast and chicken and waffles. My favorite, Croissants were on each tabletop before the main dish was served and absolutely delicious We had the best server Brittany and our event coordinator Melissa was very helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Over a month I grabbed drinks with my girlfriends, I witnessed the manager get really drunk at the bar and getting really loud. I have to say it was very uncomfortable and not sure if I’ll come back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place is very beautiful with great atmosphere and very tasty food. Reasonably priced! Will definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a decent meal during LI restaurant week here. There was just too much salad!!!We ordered salads for our appetizers thinking the mains would be not salad based ? but yet our mains came and it had the protein as the background - the second salad was very present! I got the chicken which I should not have done bc it was quite dry, not what I was hoping for ?The ambiance was nice and the lights + decor were very pretty. Other than that the food was subpar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
We ordered pasta for an appetizer and it came with an unwanted long hair. The last time (perhaps the summer) an ant came walking out of my wife's salad. My wife ordered mussels and she had to ask for a small fork. We will not be going back to Bayberry; we are grossed out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Spring Pea Angliotti, Prime Rib French Dip, Affagato
Restaurantji Recommends
My fiancé and I had our engagement party at Bayberry this past Saturday and it was truly a memorable experience. Everything was AMAZING! Melissa, the Catering Sales Manager, was very responsive throughout the entire planning process and worked with us to deliver everything we asked for. Brittany, Ashley, and Gianna who worked the party were SO attentive, friendly, and truly took care of everything - they really allowed us to relax and enjoy our guests/experience. The party ran so smoothly.We have been told non-stop how GREAT the food was (specifically the sliders and the Bayberry Chicken were a huge hit). Guests were also really impressed with the atmosphere and renovations. We felt the space accommodated our guest count of 50 people perfectly and allowed for a cohesive flow.We will always remember our time spent at Bayberry and will be recommending the restaurant to friends/family in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My fiancé and I had our engagement party at Bayberry this past Saturday and it was truly a memorable experience. Everything was AMAZING! Melissa, the Catering Sales Manager, was very responsive throughout the entire planning process and worked with us to deliver everything we asked for. Brittany, Ashley, and Gianna who worked the party were SO attentive, friendly, and truly took care of everything - they really allowed us to relax and enjoy our guests/experience. The party ran so smoothly. We have bee told non-stop how GREAT the food was (specifically the sliders and the Bayberry Chicken were a huge hit). Guests were also really impressed with the atmosphere and renovations. We felt the space accommodated our guest count of 50 people perfectly and allowed for a cohesive flow. We will always remember our time spent at Bayberry and will be recommending the restaurant to friends/family in the future.
Visited here for the first time since it was renovated. Ambiance is much brighter, seating more comfortable and the noise level was fine for conversation. We shared the spinach and artichoke dip. I had the faroe island salmon: excellent and cooked to perfection. Wife had the prime rib French dip which she loved as well. Service was friendly and prompt on all counts. Already making plans to return with some guests.
I'm am islip girl born and raised.Someone invited me to your restaurant.Laura was our bartender / host.She took the raise as soon as I told her this was my home town. She immediately welcomed me home and showed me what a classy upscale islip I was coming back to. Bravo Laura!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
You are missing something special if you haven’t discovered Bayberry. My spouse and I enjoyed brunch on a recent Saturday; what a great experience! Our server was very friendly and attentive, remembering my choice of sugar when she brought me a 2nd cup of coffee. My lemon blueberry Dutch baby pancake melted in my mouth with just the right combination of lemony sweetness and my spouse loved the vegetable frittata. The brunch drinks looked yummy, too. Creative and diverse menu, family friendly, and delicious food. Loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5