Maxwell's

501 Main Street, Islip
(631) 210-0011

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rosemary S

Very expensive drinks and food. Small portions for the price. The service was great though. Everyone was very friendly. Our drinks cost 96.00 for 6 drinks . Crazy pricing. Probably not going back. I enjoyed maxwells much better.

Google user

The old Maxwell's is now Bayberry. The food was very good. We had Beet Salad with Blackened Chicken. It was good, not amazing. Very fresh though. The French Onion Soup was very good. The bread was crispy in the soup. The pasta was amazing. Lemon spaghetti with Artichokes and Arugula and garlic. You can order half or full sizes, which is very cool. We like to split meals so this came in handy. For drinks we had Polemo, The Bayberry, Mezcal Marg, and Lavender drink that was normally zero proof but they added Gin. Overall, very good. It's worth checking them out. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!

kaylie walsh

Overall amazing experience , They made it look completely different from maxwells but in a great way! My server Rob was great and very informative with the cocktails that you guys have. Will be back very soon

Diane McConnell

Good pub food and drinks. Not much to be considered healthy on the menu.

Dew Maur

it was nice, the menu seemed a little limited. 2 people had salads, one with shrimp one with chicken, both very good. I had the roast beef dip sandwich and another had the hamburger. they were also good. Not a great place, not a bad place - just a good place, not sure I'll go back again.

robert zenor

Good food. Super friendly. Nice mix of people young and old.

Maureen O'Leary Martin

Street fair- food was great-beer was cold-music was love!

Ray Ortiz

Everything was great until the Rangers choked and suck a big cock

Felix Feerock Ordoñez

Great food with awesome atmosphere good music and great service !!!

Bob S

Went there for a retirement party. Food and service was very good. Highly recommend.

terry li

Our igloo dinner experience was amazing! Attentive staff and yummy food! If you’re thinking about booking, do it ! And I have to thank Maxwell’s for being so honest and kind to mail me something personal I had left at the restaurant.

Michael Dragotta

Thanks just threw my wife a surprise 40th birthday. Maxwells did an AMAZING job. We did the cocktail party/top shelf open bar package and it was perfect. Ashley was the manager running things and made sure it went smooth. Our bartender was awesome and Christopher the other manager helped house along the way with Ashley. This is the spot!!!!

D G (DG)

Awful experience. Waiter completely messed up a simple order. Service took forever. When this was brought to the waiters attention, he argued with us! Are you kidding! We will never return.

mindy marcus

Last week stopped for lunch. Rubin was good but chicken tenders burned as were sweet potato fries. Blasting Xmas music. Fountain lemonade l didn’t get and bar maid didn’t know how to make a ginger ale. Don’t plan on stopping there any time soon again.

Richard Bernich

I went to Maxwell’s last night for dinner and I have to say that the experience was beyond enjoyable. Our server Alyssa was attentive, engaging and awesome. The food was excellent and we can’t wait to return.

Loading...