I was in the area and was craving pizza. I read all the reviews of how good this place is, so I stopped by.
Paid 6 dollars for a margarita slice, which is genuinely insane. I have never seen it above 4 dollars anywhere. (I eat a lot of pizza)
The slice looked good, definitely thick crust but fluffy. Fluffy is the only compliment I can give.
This slice is the most bland tasteless slice of pizza I have had in long time. You can tell the ingredients were sourced from a high quality supplier but the flavor is just not there. Too much cheese and nowhere near enough sauce that a margarita slice should have.
Staff were indifferent to me and my visit, so I have no comment on them.
I did not bring up this issue, I simply finished up as much of the slice as I could and I left.
I can’t really recommend this place based off this experience, however I only tried this slice and location once, everyone has a bad day. Maybe your experience would be the opposite of mine.
Bob Coletti
This is one of several The Pizzeria’s in Suffolk County. I have gone to several all of these places and all take the time to make your order just the way you asked.
JennieLesley Moritz-Lopez
The food and people were amazing! The Salad was interesting, fresh, and delicious. The trifecta pizza was AMAZING!! On top of that, everyone was very sweet and helpful and the place was extremely clean! Highly recommend this place.
Christian Novissimo
Loved this place. Had a nice casual sit down with my kids. The staff was helpful and welcoming. The environment was perfect for families that might ne a little loud. The food was very good. We have two gluten free people and the gluten free pizza was excellent and no sickness from contamination.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan Vazquez
The staff is very careless...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Hasan Kaya
A wonderful business with friendly and attentive staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill Barrett
Best gluten free pizza around. My wife gets an individual GF pie and I get a couple of slices. GF pie is always great and variety of slices to choose from is extensive. Just had a pesto slice that was very good.
Food: 4
CPNY
I usually like this place- this location has kids working there and the music is a bit too loud, the tables need to be cleaned and the pizza was not fresh-they need to tighten it up here.
MARTINO MASIELLO
This is the best pizzeria in Islip... blows the competition away! Great staff, great food! I suggest it to everyone!!!
The Pizzeria in Islip is the best! Their pizza is delicious! The staff is phenomenal! An absolute recommend. PS: I like the Islip location the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Faith Gillen
12/10 you should ONLY get your pizza here. Food is superb and the vibe as well as the people can't be matched
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon Carey
Such great quality food!! Service with a smile! The entire crew are very attentive and friendly. Clean and bright inside. Good for a quick grab and go, or sit in and eat.
Girl with the tattoos especially makes such a friendly interaction.
Oh, not to mention they’re great for large events/gatherings/parties too.
Definitely my go to spot, for any of my pizza needs 🍕☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Margherita Slice, Upside Down Slice, Vodka Margarita Pie, Buffalo Chicken Slice, Garlic Knots, Buffalo Garlic Knots, Baked Ziti, Bar Pie, The Uncle Benny, Islip Slice, Chicken Francese, The Salad, Uncle Benny Slice, Meat Pizza
Delicious food and amazing service.
I was in the area and was craving pizza. I read all the reviews of how good this place is, so I stopped by.
Paid 6 dollars for a margarita slice, which is genuinely insane. I have never seen it above 4 dollars anywhere. (I eat a lot of pizza)
The slice looked good, definitely thick crust but fluffy. Fluffy is the only compliment I can give.
This slice is the most bland tasteless slice of pizza I have had in long time. You can tell the ingredients were sourced from a high quality supplier but the flavor is just not there. Too much cheese and nowhere near enough sauce that a margarita slice should have.
Staff were indifferent to me and my visit, so I have no comment on them.
I did not bring up this issue, I simply finished up as much of the slice as I could and I left.
I can’t really recommend this place based off this experience, however I only tried this slice and location once, everyone has a bad day. Maybe your experience would be the opposite of mine.
This is one of several The Pizzeria’s in Suffolk County. I have gone to several all of these places and all take the time to make your order just the way you asked.
The food and people were amazing! The Salad was interesting, fresh, and delicious. The trifecta pizza was AMAZING!! On top of that, everyone was very sweet and helpful and the place was extremely clean! Highly recommend this place.
Loved this place. Had a nice casual sit down with my kids. The staff was helpful and welcoming. The environment was perfect for families that might ne a little loud. The food was very good. We have two gluten free people and the gluten free pizza was excellent and no sickness from contamination.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The staff is very careless...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
A wonderful business with friendly and attentive staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best gluten free pizza around. My wife gets an individual GF pie and I get a couple of slices. GF pie is always great and variety of slices to choose from is extensive. Just had a pesto slice that was very good.
Food: 4
I usually like this place- this location has kids working there and the music is a bit too loud, the tables need to be cleaned and the pizza was not fresh-they need to tighten it up here.
This is the best pizzeria in Islip... blows the competition away! Great staff, great food! I suggest it to everyone!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Is android the pizza at this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza , Great People! 🍕🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Pizzeria in Islip is the best! Their pizza is delicious! The staff is phenomenal! An absolute recommend. PS: I like the Islip location the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
12/10 you should ONLY get your pizza here. Food is superb and the vibe as well as the people can't be matched
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such great quality food!! Service with a smile! The entire crew are very attentive and friendly. Clean and bright inside. Good for a quick grab and go, or sit in and eat.
Girl with the tattoos especially makes such a friendly interaction.
Oh, not to mention they’re great for large events/gatherings/parties too.
Definitely my go to spot, for any of my pizza needs 🍕☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Margherita Slice, Upside Down Slice, Vodka Margarita Pie, Buffalo Chicken Slice, Garlic Knots, Buffalo Garlic Knots, Baked Ziti, Bar Pie, The Uncle Benny, Islip Slice, Chicken Francese, The Salad, Uncle Benny Slice, Meat Pizza
Loading...