The Pizzeria of Islip

591 Main St, Islip
(631) 581-9500

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Vodka Margherita Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Buffalo Garlic Knots
Vodka Margarita Pie
The Honey Pep Slice
Uncle Benny Slice
Upside Down Slice
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Francese

Menu

Bottle
20 Oz Coke
20 Oz Dr Pepper
20 Oz Diet Coke
20 Oz Sprite
Smart Water
20 Oz Fanta
Coke Glass Bottle
20oz Ice Tea

Two Liter
2Lt Coke
2Lt Diet Coke
2Lt Fanta
2Lt Ice Tea
2Lt Sprite

Featured items
Cesaer Salad
Romain, Shaved Parmesan cheese, Parm Crisps and Croutons
Vodka Margarita Pie
Olive Oil Crust Topped w/ Fresh Mozz & Vodka Sauce
Garlic Bread w/Mozzarella
THE Salad
Field Greens, Honey Crisp Apple Sticks, Cherry Tomatoes, Croutons, Candied Pecans, Parm Crisps and Cheddar Cheese
House Salad
Mixed Field Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Freshly Made Croutons & Mozz Cheese
The Mezzi Rig
Mini rigatoni pasta with seasoned vodka sauce and melted mozzarella cheese

Pies
The Uncle Benny
Olive oil crust with light pizza sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, hot honey drizzle and fresh basil
Crumbling Vodka.
Grandma crust with fresh mozzarella cheese, crumbled sausage and seasoned vodka sauce.
Bar Pie
Olive oil crust with pizza sauce and light mozzarella cheese. Topped with hot honey and dollops of burrata cheese.
Vodka Margarita Pie
Olive Oil Crust Topped w/ Fresh Mozz & Vodka Sauce
Tri-Fecta Pie
Olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella cheese. Topped with pizza sauce, vodka sauce, pesto and parmesan cheese.
Caputo Pie/Upside Down
Our updated upside down pie featuring fresh mozzarella under seasoned marinara sauce and olive oil drizzle
Salad Pie
Large Pie
Grandma Pie
Sicilian Pie
Gluten Free Pie
Gluten free and dairy free crust
The Islip Pie
Our Sweet Red Sauce on Olive Oil Crust w/ Fresh Mozz. Our Version of a Margherita Pie
The Honey Pep Pie
Sicilian with Pepperoni & Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle
Meat Ball Burrata Pie
Meatballs, Burrata, Basil & Red Sauce
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Wings + Pizza, it's a Good Thing
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
Thai Chili Sauce on Pizza? Yes, Trust Us
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Pronounced: C-B-R
Nonna's Non-Dairy Pie
Olive Oil Crust, Veggies & Red Sauce
White Pie
Square Pie w/Ricotta, Mascarpone, Mozz & Truffle Oil
Bruschetta Pie
Balsamic Infused Crust, Cherry Tomatoes, Burrata & Glaze

Slices
Islip Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
The Honey Pep Slice
Grandma Slice
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Sicilian Slice
Meat Ball Burrata Slice
Thai Chili Slice
Bruschetta Slice
Upside Down Slice
Salad Slice
Regular Slice
Vodka Margherita Slice
Uncle Benny Slice
Crumbling Vodka
White Slice
Tri-Fecta Slice
Bar Slice

Starters
Garlic Bread w/Mozzarella
Chicken Roll
Chub's Chicken Cutlets w/Mozz Cheese, Red Sauce and Seasonings
Rice Ball (3)
Risotto, Chop Meat, Mozz Cheese and Red Sauce. (No Peas)
Pepperoni Pinwheel
Cup and Char Pepperoni with Mozz Cheese twirled in our Fresh Dough
Wings
10 Wings Per Order
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried Ravioli (9)
Breaded Ravioli w/ Vodka Sauce to Dip
Vegetable Pinwheel
Broccoli, Cheddar, Mozz & Freshly Chopped Garlic all wrapped up
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Side Meatballs
Calzone
Single Rice Ball
Pesto Chicken Street Sandwich
Freshly Made Focaccia w/ Grilled Chicken, Pesto, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers
Prosciutto Street Sandwich
Prosciutto, Fresh Mozz, Tomato, Basil, Olive Oil on Freshly Made Focaccia
Caprese Street Sandwich

Salads
Cesaer Salad
Romain, Shaved Parmesan cheese, Parm Crisps and Croutons
House Salad
Mixed Field Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Freshly Made Croutons & Mozz Cheese
THE Salad
Field Greens, Honey Crisp Apple Sticks, Cherry Tomatoes, Croutons, Candied Pecans, Parm Crisps and Cheddar Cheese

Pasta
The Mezzi Rig
Mini rigatoni pasta with seasoned vodka sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
Penne Alla Vodka
Pasta with Meatballs
Baked Ziti
Beggars' Purses
5 cheese pasta pouches with vodka sauce and crumbled sausage
Broccoli Rabe
Orecchiette pasta with crumbed sausage, garlic and broccoli rabe
Spaghetti With Tomato Sauce

Dinner
Chicken Parmagiana
Chicken Francese
THE Pizzeria Chicken
Chicken Cutlet Topped w/ Arugula, Cherry Tomato & Balsamic Glaze
Shrimp Parmagiana
Eggplant Parmagiana
Sausage And Peppers
Meatball Parmigiana

Dessert
Zeppoles
Mini Cannoli

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+38 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+37 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Expensive pizza by the slice, but it was delicious. Had the Ricotta slice, the hot honey with pepperoni, and a Sicilian regular. They were all delicious. Unfortunately we were on the motorcycle so we really couldn't order a whole pie.

The staff was nice, the place is clean. It was about closing time so it wasn't crowded.
September 2025
The pizza here is always SPOT ON! We tried hot honey pepperoni, another similar with sausage (OMG yum!), and a Caesar salad wrap with cheese baked on the outside(I'm hooked).

Staff is wonderful, they bring the food to your table and they are patient and help answer any questions you have.

There are two sides to the pizzeria, the front where you order and seating, and a second room with seating. There are restrooms as well! By the way,...
September 2025
This is the place I go to when I want to get away from work for a little while. If heaven has a smell, it’s whatever’s coming out of their ovens.

Falco’s a good dude, the kind of guy who makes you feel so welcome that half the time I’m just waiting for him to hand me an apron and tell me to stir the sauce so it doesn’t stick.

I’m Irish, so by nature I should be living on potatoes, but their pizza is so good I’d trade my ancestral...
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Tellers: An American Chophouse - 605 Main St
Steak House, Salad, Wine Bar, Seafood, Vegan
Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery - 547 Main St
Bakery, Cupcakes, Donuts, Gluten-Free
Harp & Hound - 528 Main St
Irish Pub, American, Irish

The Pizzeria of Islip

591 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
(631) 581-9500