White Cap Fish Market & Seafood Restaurant

120 Main St, Islip
(631) 581-0125

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ramon Rodriguez

It is like going back in time. The food is fresh, reasonably priced and full of nostalgia. In a old boat yard, lots of character. Like a movie set. The lobster roll is packed with coleslaw and French fries. Bring your own beer.

Jerry Weiss

Had dinner there yesterday and was a little disappointed! We had fried calamari appetizer the was dry with little taste! Entrees were broiled combo platter with steamed veggies, second was crab cake platter with fries and both were very good. Staff was friendly and helpful but for a very laid back, dive kinda place the prices were a bit high.

Robert Flannigan

Always fresh seafood. Purchased little neck clams and made linguine with clam sauce.

Kim Saccomagno

Thank you to the nice young man that helped me today! I think his name was Aiden! He greeted me with a smile, made sure there was nothing else I needed, rang me up and thanked me and sent me off with a smile! Dont usually get that kind of service from kids these days! Thanks kiddo and keep smiling! Great job!

Laurie Golan

Staff was friendly and very helpful. We ordered fried calamari, mussels marinara with pasta, and lobster ravioli. The fried calamari was tough and soggy, the mussels were tasteless. There was no sauce, just some canned tomatoes thrown on top. The pasta was lukewarm, undercooked and swimming in red tinged water. The lobster ravioli in pink sauce was pretty good. Prices were high, which I wouldn't have minded if the food had been good, but that was not the case.

Sophia Fiorino

Delicious Long Island Clam chowder 🤩 helpful staff. Tucked away out on the dock. Special place.

Douglas Rigo

Don’t miss out on this dockside gem. Really fresh seafood at reasonable prices. Nice weekend hangout

frances lao

Ordered broiled salmon with vegetables .. Everything was delicious I called in my order and it was ready when I arrived. The gentleman that took my order was very efficient and friendly .Great place ♥️💯!!

MauPau Luzzi

Excellent prices and very good quality.

Drew From Kew

Food was delicious and the atmosphere was perfect. The lobster is over $30 but it's worth it.

Jeff Turner

I went in for a soft shelf crab sandwich, but they sold out within an hour after opening I guess. Tried a krabby patty, taste like came from a factory and was not made there. Very disappointing crab cake sandwich. Chowder was good though.

Ryan wootle

Been loving this spot for years, last few times I’ve came prices are through the roof and the quality is just horrible.

Man… I can’t understand how prices double while everything tastes worse.

Cant support you guys anymore, way too many inedible meals.

Paula Smith

The nicest service clean place

Shakila Jahan Shimu

Great options

korto scott

The staff was customer friendly, and this was my first time at White Cap Fish. The seafood I got was excellent 😋 👌🏾

Loading...

White Cap Fish Market & Seafood Restaurant

120 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
(631) 581-0125