Collegetown Bagels
420 College Ave, Ithaca
(607) 273-0982
Customers' Favorites
Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
California Sunrise
San Diego Bagel
Reuben Sandwich
Turkey Hill blt
Chicken Bowl
New Yorker
6 Bagels
Pesto
Menu
Photos
+58 photos
+57 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Everything was made well, pretty good portion sizes, felt pretty normal as far as the taste - a lot of your typical sandwiches, salads, soups, etc. it has a college-town vibe which can be fun, but the place can be crowded at times.
The bagels are expensive but good, the coffee is passable, but the sanitary practices and customer service are lacking.
I waited at the register while an employee, wearing gloves, sat using her phone for about two minutes before another worker came to take my order. I then watched as the same employee, still without changing her gloves, wiped surfaces with a sanitation rag, flipped through a magazine, chatted with coworkers, and continued using her phone all...
I waited at the register while an employee, wearing gloves, sat using her phone for about two minutes before another worker came to take my order. I then watched as the same employee, still without changing her gloves, wiped surfaces with a sanitation rag, flipped through a magazine, chatted with coworkers, and continued using her phone all...
Ordered a cappuccino which was completely flat with a thin layer of foam on top (as opposed to properly frothed/steamed). It was also scalding hot (AKA over-steamed) and I burned myself trying to drink it. Got a nova lox bagel ($13) and came out to be $17 after subbing for allergens, making one addition, and tax.
The additional fees for subs seems excessive and borderline exploitive to people who require these accommodations to eat, especially when the sub ingredients...
The additional fees for subs seems excessive and borderline exploitive to people who require these accommodations to eat, especially when the sub ingredients...
You May Also Like
D.P. Dough - 408 College Ave
![]()
Italian, Chicken Wings, Burgers, Vegan
Fusia Bento Bar - 405 College Ave
![]()
Asian, Chinese, Japanese, Vegetarian
Dos Amigos - 403 College Ave
![]()
Mexican, Tacos, New Mexican Cuisine, Vegan