Eta Pie

1006 W Seneca St, Ithaca
(607) 379-6066

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cheese Pizza \u0026 Can of Soda
Pizza with My Picked Toppings
Cauliflower Crust
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Eggplant
Slice of Pizza
Mykonos Pizza
Cannoli Pie
Prosciutto

Menu

Pizzas
8" Cheese Pizza
A simple pleasure that can never disappoint. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
8" One Veg Topping Pizza
With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
8" Two Veg Topping Pizza
With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
8" One Meat Topping Pizza
8" Two Toppings Pizza
Any.
8" Create Your Own Pizza
Make it anyway you want. Our 8" pizza is perfect for a snack or light meal.
11" Cheese Pizza
A simple pleasure that can never disappoint. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
11" One Veg Topping Pizza
With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
11" Two Veg Topping Pizza
With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
11" One Meat Topping Pizza
11" Two Toppings Pizza
Any.
11" Create Your Own Pizza
Make it anyway you want. Our 8" pizza is perfect for a snack or light meal.
14" Cheese Pizza
A simple pleasure that can never disappoint. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
14" One Veg Topping Pizza
With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
14" Two Veg Topping Pizza
With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
14" One Meat Topping Pizza
14" Two Toppings Pizza
Any.
14" Create Your Own Pizza
Make it anyway you want. Our 8" pizza is perfect for a snack or light meal.
12" Cheese Pizza
Cauliflower crust. A simple pleasure that can never disappoint. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
12" One Veg Topping Pizza
Cauliflower crust. With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
12" Two Veg Topping Pizza
Cauliflower crust. With a large selection of vegetables, you won't be disappointed. Choose from a selection of sauces and cheeses, topping off your creation with our finishing touches and drizzles.
12" One Meat Topping Pizza
Cauliflower crust.
12" Two Toppings Pizza
Cauliflower crust. Any.
12" Create Your Own Pizza
Cauliflower crust. Make it anyway you want. Our 8" pizza is perfect for a snack or light meal.

Chef's Whimsey Pizza

Beverly Hills Pizza
Smoked salmon, garlic dill creme fraiche, red-chili infused, and extra virgin olive oil.
Buffalo Pizza
Buffalo chicken, gorgonzola, mozzarella, buffalo sauce drizzle, and gorgonzola creme fraiche drizzle.
Fall River Pizza
Garlic scallops, garlic shrimp, clams, pesto, and mozzarella.
Fiesole Pizza
Red sauce, fried eggplant, ricotta cheese, and mozzarella.
Fond du Lac Pizza
Macaroni and 5 cheeses, mornay sauce, mozzarella, and natural ham.
Glouster Pizza
Garlic scallops, garlic shrimp, clams, red sauce, and mozzarella.
Jaipur Pizza
Organic masala sauce, spinach, mozzarella, paneer, and onions.
Juarez Pizza
Roasted pineapple habanero sauce, mozzarella, feta, carnitas, and crema drizzle.
Lahaina Pizza
Pineapple, natural ham, red sauce, mozzarella, and onion.
Milano Pizza
Sausage, broccoli, red sauce, mozzarella, and pesto drizzle.
Mykonos Pizza
Spinach, feta, mozzarella, caramelized onions, and tzatziki drizzle.
Napoli Pizza
Traditional pizza margherita, san marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil.
New Orleans Pizza
Beer battered shrimp or fried oysters, spinach, mornay sauce, and mozzarella.
Palo Alto Pizza
Bbq sauce, grilled chicken, red onions, mozzarella, and smoked gouda.
Philly Pizza
Sliced grilled steak, onions, and housemade cheese wiz.
Providence Pizza
Red sauce, mozzarella, clams, bacon, green peppers, and onions.
Reamauville Pizza
Grilled or fried chicken, black forest ham, Swiss cheese, mozzarella, and mornay sauce.
Torino Pizza
Red sauce, mozzarella, spinach, fried eggplant, grilled chicken, and mushrooms.
Sauverne Pizza
Escargots, caramelized onions, bacon, gorgonzola, provolone, and mornay sauce.
Vallarta Pizza
Spicy red sauce, garlic shrimp, jalapenos, mozzarella, and bacon.

Salads
Small Salad 2 Chop-Ins
Make it your way! Our small salads are 24 oz. of pure deliciousness. Choose from a wide selection of cheeses, or vegetables.
Small Salad 3 Chop-Ins
Make it your way! Our small salads are 24 oz. of pure deliciousness. Choose from a wide selection of cheeses, or vegetables.
Small Salad 4 Chop-Ins
Make it your way! Our small salads are 24 oz. of pure deliciousness. Choose from a wide selection of cheeses, or vegetables.
Create Your Own Entree Salad
Make it your way! Our entre salads are 32oz of pure deliciousness. Choose from a wide selection of cheeses, meats, or vegetables. We have clever house-made dressings that are sure to make your taste buds light up.

Chef's Whimsey Salads
Calabasas Salad
Choice of greens, BBQ chicken, smoked gouda, grape tomatoes, gorgonzola crumbles, add 1 extra vegetable chop-in of your choice for no extra cost.
Laguna Nigel Salad
Organic spinach and romaine, bacon, crispy onions, chicken or falafel, corn, and gorgonzola.
Maggiore Salad
Romano or asiago or parmesan blended cheese, housemade ceaser dressing, and croutons.
Ruidoso Salad
Choice of greens, garlic shrimp, grape tomatoes, pickled red onion, croutons, and pineapple habanero crema.

Sides
Cheesy Bread Sticks
Our Cheesy Bread Sticks are an explosion of garlic-y goodness that will leave you satisfied.
Extra Dipping Sauce 2 oz.
Extra Dressing 2 oz.

Beverages
Arizona Sweet Green Tea Bottle
Coke Can
Diet Coke Can
Sprite Can
Fox Orange
Poland Spring Bottled Water
Pure Leaf Unsweet Tea
Fox Cherry
Fox Diet White Birch
Fox Grape
Fox Kola
Fox Lemon-Lime
Fox Cream Soda
Fox Rootbeer
Fox White Birch
Fox Gassosa
Fox Ginger Ale

Desserts
Cannoli Pie
A new spin on the favorite Italian dessert cherished by so many. The filling in this delectable treat is a family recipe passed down for 3 generations.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+23 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+22 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I ordered a pizza a short while ago and it is OUTSTANDING! All the ingredients are very fresh, the sauce and crust are just how I like them and it looks amazing. I think this is the best pizza in Ithaca and it will be my go to place from now on! About a month ago I had an issue with a Door Dash order and Nate went above and beyond to make it right.
December 2025
Some of the nicest people you'll find around.

The owner is seemingly almost always there, and he knows his customers and greets you by name.

There's admittedly a lot of pizza options in Ithaca and many of them are good, but no one comes close to the value and creativity of ETA pie.

They're also one of two pizza places here that make good salads, and by a wide margin ETA pies are more creative.
November 2025
Good pizza they do not skimp on toppings and the staff are super nice. Probably the best salads to can get from any Pizza place, freshly made and good portions. Great price for the amount of food you get.
November 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Yxi’s Arepas & Gordito LLC - 301 Taughannock Blvd
Venezuelan, Gluten-Free
On The Street Pitas - Food truck concessions
Greek, Food Trucks
Kelly's Dockside Cafe - 319 Old Taughannock Blvd
Seafood, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian

Eta Pie

1006 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 14850
(607) 379-6066