John Thomas Steakhouse
1152 Danby Rd Ste A, Ithaca
(607) 273-3464
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
This is a nice restaurant but extremely expensive. Expect to pay $50-$100 per person. The atmosphere is enjoyable and the history of the restaurant is interesting, however I would expect it to be nicer considering the price.
Overpriced restaurant by all means. Food was mediocre at best. Service was excellent. Decor makes you feel like you're in the 80's
The best steakhouse ever!
The ambience, food and service were all excellent. With a student at Cornell we look forward to more dinners there!
Everything about this meal underwhelmed. The big problem is lack of flavor. The steak was the best part, so I guess that’s good, but even there I’ve had better steaks at Ruth’s Chris.
We had : calamari and lobster bisque for appetizers. I ordered the ribeye, she got the t bone. I would recommend getting a piece of meat and get one that is dry aged. Bisque was ok calamari left me wanting more. I wouldn't come here for seafood but I definitely would go out of your way to get some beef here. The cheesecake was 9 out of 10 bisque 7 or an 8. Calamari was a 6. Steaks were a 9.5-10 we got brussel sprouts and mushroom caps as our sides and those were a solid eight or a nine. Pulled off very nicely. The server Chris (spelling?) Was a delight and the whole service staff was attentive. No empty water or drink glasses. We would most definitely come here again. I must say that the attire is not for hoodies and ball caps. Go here if you want a nice treat or something special. The calamari needs help, I would have gave it a perfect five other than that. My apologies for the photos in low lighting I didn't do any editing but the presentation was excellent.
Best steak in the county! Lobster too!
Excellent service and superb food. It is very expensive. The steaks were great, prime rib awesome, and the crab cake was all crab - no filler.
My first time dining here was not a disappointment. The staff were wonderful and the food was great. Best steak and mashed potatoes I've ever had. Looking forward to making this a dining tradition!
As upscale as it gets in Ithaca. Very pricey but worth it
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food and service.
Too expensive for what you get. Better value found elsewhere.
The service and the food were amazing. From salad to cheesecake, every bite was better than the last. The scallop special was probably the best scallops that I have ever had.
Excellent taste, service off the charts good!!
Hey this place is amazing. It was the best steak I've ever had and that sentiment was shared by all 5 of us at the table. It's expensive and worth the price
Loading...